pauraque: drawing of a wolf reading a book with a coffee cup (customer service wolf)
[personal profile] pauraque
This is a collection of short stories set in the fictional Central European country Orsinia. Most of the stories are new for the book, though a couple were published previously, and the invention of the country itself was one of Le Guin's first creative writing projects. It's basically an alt-history Czechia or Hungary, borrowing from real wars and political events; stories set in the Cold War era show Orsinia as a satellite state of the Soviet Union. Aside from the alternate history, the stories have no speculative elements.

I hadn't read this before because it didn't sound like it was up my alley. But it was next up in my chronological read of Le Guin's books, so I gave it a chance, and guess what? It wasn't up my alley!

I freely admit that a big part of the issue is that I'm the wrong audience for what she was trying to do here. A number of the stories are the sort of litfic where the entire plot is family/relationship drama and everyone is miserable, which is a genre that I find deadly dull even if Ursula Le Guin writes it. But I also don't think the prose is up to her usual standard. It's more reminiscent of her early work, and some of it openly is early work! But even the stories dated 1976 read like revisions of something pulled from the previous decade's drawer.

What surprised me the most is how generic I found the worldbuilding to be. It comes off like she wanted to write about Central Europe but didn't have the depth of knowledge to write about any specific country, so instead we have this Ruritanian stand-in that does not have any real weight to it or any distinctive qualities or culture. The stories I enjoyed the most were the ones set prior to the 20th century, which at least took me to an interesting time if not to an especially compelling place.

So yeah, this wasn't for me. Oh well, at least it was short.

Date: 9 Nov 2025 12:15 pm (UTC)
princessofgeeks: Shane smiling, caption Canada's Shane Hollander (Default)
From: [personal profile] princessofgeeks
You are exactly right: She DID want to write about Hungary or Slovakia but felt that she didn't have the time or research chops to really make it accurate, so instead in order to explore the themes that she wanted, she made up a country.

I enjoyed these stories immensely because of her characterization skills, and I felt the writing was up to her standards personally.

The description of the lake near the main family's country home has stayed with me for years.

In fact you are prompting me to reread!

Date: 9 Nov 2025 03:28 pm (UTC)
princessofgeeks: Shane smiling, caption Canada's Shane Hollander (Default)
From: [personal profile] princessofgeeks
I have never read any of her poetry except one piece I really liked: Always Coming Home.

But I don't know much about that part of her work at all.

Date: 9 Nov 2025 01:23 pm (UTC)
raven: [hello my name is] and a silhouette image of a raven (Default)
From: [personal profile] raven
Agree agree agree. These ones are so dull to me, because they don't have any SFF distinctiveness, and so much of the relationship drama is miserable and tedious. There is a book by Zoe Gilbert, Folk, which I feel like might be drawing on some of Le Guin's ideas and I have just dnf'ed because dull.

Date: 10 Nov 2025 07:22 pm (UTC)
starshipfox: (poetry books)
From: [personal profile] starshipfox
I remember reading somewhere that she said she came up with Orsinia because she didn't realise you could write fantasy that wasn't set in a version of Europe? And once she did realise that, she could write much more freely. I don't know why she decided to revisit this in the 70s in the case. I've read a couple of these stories within a longer anthology of her work, and I thought they were OK, but I've never been tempted to seek out more!

July 2026

S M T W T F S
   1 23 4
567 89 1011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Tags