Looking back at a year of reading 2025 edition

Nearing the end of another year, and time for my annual recap of the books I’ve read in the last year, including general patterns, favourites etc. I enjoy looking back each year, and hope that the books mentioned may help some others.

To be blunt I’m also still delighted that I’m reading masses, albeit in increasingly difficult circumstances. I’ve lived with a progressive neurological disease now for 31 years, and although we’ve been able, with strong ongoing treatment, to slow the progression down a lot, it does mean that I am now extremely disabled and restricted. Including in what I can read.

Fortunately ebooks with gargantuan size fonts came to the rescue for me, and help me continue reading. I also still read graphic novels, though I am less likely to read traditional print. I have been an enthusiastic reader throughout all my life, and it’s very important to me that I can keep reading. I also have a PhD in historic reading habits … So yes, invested!

Looking back at the year I finished 58 books this year, the same number as in 2024, compared with 60 in 2023, and 75 in 2022. I don’t generally read short books, and my 58 books this year represent over 16,000 pages of reading. An average of over 300 pages a week. Almost always read on my Kindle, late at night, or during the day fitting around my extended sleeping and bedbound periods. I am usually reading lying down …

The picture below shows a glimpse of some of the books I was reading.

Screenshot showing a variety of book covers, including "Insomniacs After School" manga, "Forgotten Churches", a Peter Capaldi 12th Doctor graphic novel, "Some of Us Just Fall" by Polly Atkin, and many more. Very varied designs.

Two thirds of the books I read this year were fiction, and one third were non fiction. I tend to prefer reading novels, but also enjoy reading short stories. And my non fiction reading is quite varied and wide ranging. I tend not to read poetry, though I enjoy it, but occasionally read plays, including this year Born With Teeth by Liz Duffy Adams, the fictional retelling of the relationship between William Shakespeare and Christopher Marlowe, recently staged in London with Edward Bluemel and Ncuti Gatwa playing those roles. I enjoyed reading this play script a lot, rating it 5/5 on Goodreads and StoryGraph.

I had a number of other 5-star reads this year, including the 1988 painting book The Silvery Tay: Paintings and sketches from a Scottish river by Keith Brockie. Obviously of great interest to me living in Dundee. Similarly Luke Sherlock’s mix of architecture, history and place Forgotten Churches: Exploring England’s Hidden Treasures was a total delight.

My favourite genre for reading by a very long way is fantasy – not scifi, even though I’m a big fan of TV scifi series like Doctor Who, Babylon 5 and Star Trek. This year, for the first time, I read a Robin Hobb book, Assassin’s Apprentice, and was wowed. Though devastated in places while reading too! I expect to read more of her books. Better late than never. Other genres that I regularly enjoy reading include history, horror (though horror is very carefully selected to avoid some things that are too triggering for me) and manga.

I continued to slowly read Robert Jordan’s The Wheel of Time series of books. I’ve been reading them, widely spread out alongside other books, slowly since October 2021. This year I read books 9 and 10 – the latter a particularly disappointing book, though I had been forewarned. Things should pick up after that point, and I expect to read books 11 and 12 in 2026, and hopefully 13 and 14 in 2027. To take me to the end of the series. I am still enjoying this series, though am taking an extremely strategic approach to get me to the end.

As usual I reread a few books. Every October, I read A Night in the Lonesome October by Roger Zelazny, the gothic horror tale of a mysterious game taking place in the Victorian English countryside around Halloween. I am one of many many people around the world who reread this book every year at this time.

At the start of the year I reread my favourite Charles Dickens book, Our Mutual Friend. A palette cleanser after a rather torrid read of something else! And I am continuing to slowly work my way through a reread of Arthur Conan Doyle’s original Sherlock Holmes short stories. Which I am enjoying immensely as always, and writing little capsule reviews/thoughts on each one on my Dreamwidth blog.

Another book that I reread this year, for the first time in 30 years or so, was George Mackay Brown’s award-winning and Booker-shortlisted Beside the Ocean of Time. Told through the dreams and imaginings of a young Orcadian boy, this is a lyrical and powerful telling of Orkney history through time. An absolute highlight for me this year, and thoroughly recommended.

I also reread Terry Pratchett’s The Wee Free Men, continuing my slow reread of his “Witches” books in his Discworld fantasy series, following a slow reread some years ago of *all* of his Discworld books. This book is the very first book he wrote about young witch Tiffany Aching, and is a joy, and assumes no prior knowledge of the Discworld series. I was so happy to read it again, and have the rest of Tiffany’s books to reread in coming years too.

Continuing my love of fantasy books, I read a number of newly published fantasy books this year. Two 4-star reads for me were V.E. Schwab’s Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil, and R.F. Kuang’s Katabasis. The former a tale of vampires, over many centuries, the latter a journey into the Underworld by two students of magic at Cambridge University in England, trying to save their academic supervisor, so they can complete their PhDs. Both were enjoyable, but not quite hitting the top spot for me. But I’m very glad that I read them.

The V.E. Schwab book was a book club read for me this year. Other book club reads for me included The King of Elfland’s Daughter by Lord Dunsany (liked it, but glacially slow, and more descriptive than either plot-driven or character-driven) and Carmilla by Sheridan Le Fanu (I greatly disliked the very convoluted writing style, which I could barely read). I don’t read all of my book club monthly reading choices, but cherry pick the ones of most interest to me.

I’d like to mention a couple of other books that I particularly enjoyed. Firstly D.V. Bishop’s City of Vengeance, the first in his series of 16th century set Florence thrillers. Gripping! I will definitely read more. Notebook by Tom Cox was a 5-star read for me, a delightful set of varied scribblings and musings, often funny. Tom has had a torrid time with his former publisher Unbound, who treated him and other authors appallingly, as well as pre-order customers like me. If you want to read this or any of his other books, make sure that you get the new edition from his new publisher Swift Books, who are publishing his new books and rereleasing his old ones. Unscrupulous resellers are reselling copies of his former Unbound-published book, but Tom doesn’t get any revenue from those sales. The same applies to other ex Unbound authors, whose books are being resold similarly.

I’ve written a lot, so I think I should wrap things up now. Hopefully some of this was of interest to others. I’m delighted to report another good year for reading for me, despite everything. Hopefully next year will also bring fun reads, new book and new author discoveries, and the delights of rediscovering old favourites.

Favourite and recommended books by year throughout my life

Prompted by Jean Menzies, a YouTuber I watch, I’ve had fun drawing up a list of book favourites and recommendations with one for each year of my life up to 2024. No repetition of authors. Not necessarily my all time favourites each year, but things that spoke to me and that I’m happy to recommend. Many not read in year of publication, especially when I was very small!

The list is long already, and I’d like to add a few additional words about each book chosen. So I’ll do each line in the list as an expandable block. Click on a book title to read more about it (this may work best on the website version of the post, rather than the one emailed to blog subscribers). The books are listed by year of publication.

1972 – A Pattern of Roses, by K.M. Peyton

A spooky time slip book that I read as a young child, and that chilled me delightfully. The 1983 TV movie version starring a very young Helena Bonham Carter is also worth a watch.

1973 – The Dark is Rising, by Susan Cooper

The second in the longer fantasy series of the same name, a magical tale of childhood, mythology, Good versus Evil, and the countryside, all set in the days around Christmas.

1974 – Poirot’s Early Cases, by Agatha Christie

Almost the last book by Agatha Christie published during her lifetime, this is a strong set of short stories, showing how effective her character Poirot is in the shorter format.

1975 – The Mythical Man-Month: Essays on Software Engineering, by Fred Brooks

Though somewhat dated now, this can still be appreciated as a groundbreaking work in software engineering and computer science. I read it avidly as a computer science student in the early 1990s, pulling the book from the short loans shelf to read while I worked part-time as a library assistant in the Physics, Maths and Computing library at St Andrews University.

1976 – Letters from Father Christmas, by J.R.R. Tolkien

Many worldwide are familiar with Tolkien’s Hobbit and Lord of the Rings tales. But for a different take on him, read these handwritten Christmas letters he crafted over many years for his young growing family, writing as if from the North Pole, and illustrating them with characterful drawings. Just charming.

1977 – J.R.R. Tolkien: A Biography, by Humphrey Carpenter

No surprise here I’m a big Tolkien fan! This was one of the first biographies of his life that I read. The biographer writes in a lyrical style, and had unparalleled access to Tolkien and his papers. Recommended without question. One of the best biographies I have ever read, even many years later.

1978 – The C Programming Language, by Brian W. Kernighan and Dennis M. Ritchie

Strictly speaking I read the 1988 2nd edition of this book, but the original version came out in 1978, so I’m including it here! This book saved me during a particularly fraught series of undergraduate computer science lectures at St Andrews in 1991/2 (so problematic, they led to a student rebellion, and a dramatic drop in student numbers for the following honours years). C programming was absolutely fundamental to learn and understand for my degree, and this book played a vital part in me getting through that.

1979 – The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, by Douglas Adams

I can’t remember if I saw the 1981 BBC TV version of this before reading the book. But either way, I was an instant fan. A scifi classic, with a wry humour, bonkers plot, and Marvin the Paranoid Android!

1980 – Maus, by Art Spiegelman

A powerful and devastating tale of one family’s loss and survival in the Holocaust, and the long-term impact of it on them. This was the first graphic novel to win a Pulitzer Prize. It also won an Eisner Award.

1981 – Scottish Roots: A step-by-step Guide for Ancestor-hunters in Scotland and overseas, by Alwyn James

I bought a copy of this book in St Andrews Tourist Information Office (then on the corner of South Street and Queen’s Gardens) in the early 1980s on a family summer holiday. It was an eye-opening book for still very young me, revealing the rich potential of Scottish genealogical records held in New Register House (the General Register Office for Scotland) in Edinburgh. It’s largely thanks to this book that I got so hooked on Scottish genealogical research, and later became an academic historian.

1982 – The Virgin in the Ice (Brother Cadfael), by Ellis Peters

As a teenager I worked my way through many of the detective and crime books in Hawick Public Library. This included many of Ellis Peters’s Brother Cadfael series of medieval mysteries. This one is my favourite, set in a magical wintry setting, and uncovering unexpected depths for Cadfael himself.

1983 – The Forest of Doom (Fighting Fantasy), by Ian Livingstone

As a youngster I gobbled up as many of the Fighting Fantasy books as I could. These were a British spin off from Choose Your Own Adventure, and repackaged tabletop roleplaying, complete with stats and dice, in a form a solo player could hold in their hand. Forest of Doom was the first one I bought, from John Menzies in Hawick. And it remains one of my favourites. I especially liked the artwork in Fighting Fantasy books of the 1980s (not so keen on more modern reprinted versions), and my mind was stunned by the imaginative storytelling potential of them. Plus I got very adept at sticking tons of fingers in the pages to act as temporary bookmarks, in case I needed to back track in my choices!

1984 – Hackers: Heroes of the Computer Revolution, by Steven Levy

I only read this many years later, but found it a gripping tale of early amateur computing enthusiasts, many of whom led to some of the greatest innovations in popularising the home computer worldwide. Tales of the 1970s and 1980s Homebrew Computer Club and its members were mesmerising.

1985 – The Ruby in the Smoke, by Philip Pullman

Many readers encountered Philip Pullman’s books, including the Northern Lights trilogy, as children. I read them later in life, as a young adult. And this is my favourite. An almost Conan Doyle esque tale of Victorian times and a plucky young female lead character. I also watched and enjoyed the BBC TV version starring Billie Piper, and a supporting cast including a very young Matt Smith …

1986 – Redwall, by Brian Jacques

Another book that I read later in life than many other people, this tale of a medievalesque world of talking woodland animals, defending their abbey and way of life against marauding pirate-like rats is gripping. Definitely aimed at a younger age than I was when I read it, but still an excellent read.

1987 – Mary Queen of Scots Got her Head Chopped Off, by Liz Lochhead

Even as a very young child I was captivated by tales of Scottish history. And, above all, the life of Mary Queen of Scots. I read and reread Antonia Fraser’s acclaimed biography many times. Years later, as an undergraduate at St Andrews in the early 1990s, I saw a Byre Theatre production of Liz Lochhead’s play about Mary’s life. And it was thoroughly gripping. Reading the play script book also works very well.

1988 – The Player of Games, by Iain M. Banks

I have only read one of Iain Banks’s scifi novels. And it’s this one, which I found both accessible as a newcomer to the scifi world he had created, but also a vivid representation of the power of games and gaming to engross participants, and be used in even life threatening ways. I’m not sure how well I would get on reading it now, as my probable aphantasia has got much worse. But when I first read it, I could readily visualise the game playing that was described throughout the novel, and was captivated by it.

1989 – O Choille gu Bearradh / From Wood to Ridge: Collected Poems in Gaelic and English, by Sorley MacLean

I am a long-time learner of Scots Gaelic, though I wish I had made more progress! I adore Gaelic songs by bands such as Runrig and Capercaillie, the latter especially often reusing much older works. Among modern Gaelic poets there are two that speak to me the most: Sorley MacLean and Iain Crichton Smith. I was keen to include one of their books on this list. This one, the only collection of poems by Sorley MacLean published during his lifetime, won the Saltire Scottish Book of the Year award. It is a fantastic introduction to his poetry, with a huge number of his poems, including the acclaimed “Hallaig”. The Gaelic original text is given on left hand pages, with MacLean’s own English translation on the right side.

1990 – Tracing your Scottish ancestors: a guide to ancestry research in the Scottish Record Office, by Cecil Sinclair

I first went to New Register House (the General Register Office for Scotland, in Edinburgh) to research my family tree when I was aged about 12 in 1984. But it took until near the end of my school days and start of university years for me to venture into the mysterious and somewhat intimidating Scottish Record Office next door. This book was my gateway guide to this vast archive of Scottish historical material. I also quickly bought the sister publication, about researching Scottish local history in the SRO. Both books were essential to my baby steps into the SRO (now the National Records of Scotland).

1991 – Scientific Progress Goes “Boink”, by Bill Watterson

I could have included any Calvin and Hobbes comic book in this list. This one is pretty much a representative for all of them. My future husband, who was an undergraduate at St Andrews at the same time as me, got into Calvin and Hobbes sooner than me. But I have since become a huge fan. The tales of a young mischievous boy and his more philosophically inclined stuffed tiger are timeless.

1992 – Death at La Fenice (Commissario Brunetti, #1), by Donna Leon

My husband and I first visited Venice in 1998, in our mid 20s. We always go out of season, in the depths of winter, when it is much quieter. Though it can get very flooded … It took me some years to discover Donna Leon’s fantastic whodunnits set in Venice. I especially like the ones set in a foggy wintry city.

1993 – A Night in the Lonesome October, by Roger Zelazny

This has become an annual reread ritual for me, in the run up to Halloween. A gothic horror delight, it tells of a fantastic game, involving a cast of familiar and less so gothic horror characters. All narrated to us by Jack the Ripper’s dog Snuff, one of a number of animal companions in the book. Just a joy.

1994 – Beside the Ocean of Time, by George Mackay Brown

I read this book in the 1990s, and have remembered it fondly ever since. A lyrical retelling of Orcadian history, through the dreams and day dreams of a crofter’s young son on the island in the 1930s. It won the Saltire Scottish Book of the Year, and was shortlisted for the Booker Prize.

1995 – Behind the Scenes at the Museum, by Kate Atkinson

An astonishingly assured debut novel, which won multiple prizes. Told through a mix of a life running forward and flash backs into the past, it also plays with narrative and reader expectations.

1996 – “By the Banks of the Neva”: Chapters from the Lives and Careers of the British in Eighteenth-Century Russia, by Anthony Cross

I discovered this book by chance in the late 1990s on the shelves of St Andrews University Library. I borrowed it many times, captivated by the tales of British people, including many Scots, in eighteenth-century Russia. I have a similar story in my own family history, of a g..uncle originally from East Lothian working for Empress Catherine the Great. Though he doesn’t get a mention in this book, it helped put my own family history in context. I was very happy to buy a paperback copy of the book for myself years later.

1997 – Who on Earth is Tom Baker? An Autobiography, by Tom Baker

I’m a huge Doctor Who fan, and Tom Baker’s Fourth Doctor was my first Doctor, watching in 1978 as a 5-year-old. This is a very bonkers biography, I believe not ghost written, and thoroughly unputdownable.

1998 – Blackadder: The Whole Damn Dynasty, 1485-1917, by Rowan Atkinson, Richard Curtis, Ben Elton, and John Lloyd

I was lucky to have my own TV in my bedroom as a teenager in the 1980s. The first Blackadder TV series didn’t grab me. But then came Blackadder II. And I’ve been a fan ever since. I picked up a hardback copy of this script book some years ago, and it’s almost as funny to read in print as watch on the telly. Oh and my favourite episode is “Potato”, though all of Blackadder II is utterly brilliant.

1999 – Inside the Music: The Musician’s Guide to Composition, Improvisation, and the Mechanics of Music, by Dave Stewart

I’ve played musical instruments since the age of 4, when I started piano accordion lessons. But I’ve never had any deep music theory training. I didn’t, for example, do O’Grade Music at school. And I definitely feel some gaps! I’ve looked at a fair few music theory books over the years. But nothing has impressed me as much as this compact book, written by Dave Stewart of the Eurythmics. It’s highly accessible, written with a light touch, and thoroughly inspiring. It covers so much.

2000 – The Truth, by Terry Pratchett

I could have included many Terry Pratchett books on this list. My all time favourite is “Guards! Guards!” (1989). But the Pterry one I’ve gone for is “The Truth” from 2000. An insightful look at the impact of moveable print and journalism on the Discworld, and so much more. Highly recommended.

2001 – The Inform Designer’s Manual, by Graham Nelson

I’ve loved text adventures / interactive fiction since first playing Colossal Cave / Adventure in 1980 on an Apple II computer my Dad borrowed from work to bring home over the Christmas holidays. This was followed by the glory days of text adventure company Infocom, as well as British rivals like Magnetic Scrolls. But the 1990s also saw a major amateur revival in IF, spearheaded by British mathematician Graham Nelson, who reverse engineered the Infocom game file format, and created a compiler to let people write new games in that style. I first dabbled with the resulting game coding system in the 1990s. But 2001 saw the first print version of Nelson’s book guide to writing in his Inform language.

2002 – Ramsey Campbell, Probably, by Ramsey Campbell

Ramsey Campbell is an acclaimed British horror writer, especially for Lovecraftian-style horror. But he’s also an insightful and interesting essay writer. This is a thoroughly entertaining mix of essays covering a huge range of topics (though mostly horror themed) as well as reviews.

2003 – Understanding Gamers (Dork Tower, Vol. 5), by John Kovalic

John Kovalic’s “Dork Tower” series of comic strips is an affectionate look at tabletop roleplaying gamers and geek culture in general. Any of his collected comic books could have made my list. But I went for this one, which opens with a marvellous introduction to tabletop roleplaying games as a concept.

2004 – Paw Tracks in the Moonlight, by Denis O’Connor

A heartwarming tale of a man who rescues a young kitten during a snowstorm. Beware it will pull at the heartstrings terribly in places. I also bought a copy for my Mum to read.

2005 – The City of Falling Angels, by John Berendt

An unusual perspective on Venice and its inhabitants, told by a long-term visitor to the city. Some of the theories in the book about the 1996 fire at La Fenice opera house have been disproved more recently. But it is nevertheless a fascinating read. Venice remains one of my favourite places in the whole world.

2006 – Never the Bride (Brenda and Effie Mysteries), by Paul Magrs

The first in a delightfully whimsical modern fantasy series set in the Yorkshire seaside town of Whitby, with the lead characters a B&B landlady with hidden secrets and her best friend. My late Dad discovered this series separately from me, and told me with joy one day about these books he was reading from the library. “Ah you mean the Brenda and Effie books!” I said.

2007 – Hobby Games The 100 Best, by James Lowder

A collection of mini essays about great tabletop games, board games, card games and more. Thoroughly readable, eminently dip-in-and-out-able. And a great way of finding new games to try that you will enjoy.

2008 – The History of the Beano: The Story So Far, by Morris Heggie and Christopher Riches

I picked this up by chance at the Edinburgh Book Festival, a total impulse buy. A hefty coffee table book to bring home! It’s long out of print now, but is an excellent guide to the much-loved and long-running children’s comic published here in Dundee where I live, and the city’s comic history is much cherished.

2009 – Wolf Hall, by Hilary Mantel

It took me ages to get to this. I was very seriously ill around its initial publication and over the next few years. But when I did, wow. Admittedly the writing style took a little getting used to. But I have never read a novel that inserted me so much into the story and place before. An incredible sense of being physically right there among the action and dialogue. Her achievements in writing this series are immense. And as a history buff (and academic historian!) long fascinated by the Tudor period of English history this was magical.

2010 – At the Water’s Edge: A Walk in the Wild, by John Lister-Kaye

A supreme example of nature writing, this follows a year viewed through the eyes of a familiar nature walk. All recorded with acute observational skills.

2011 – A Discovery of Witches, by Deborah Harkness

I don’t usually read romance novels, but this is the first in a gripping series of romantic fantasy novels, including elements of academia, history and supernatural beings. My only regret is that it took me so long to read after I first bought the ebook back in 2013. The announcement of a new TV version prompted me to finally get to it. And I’m so glad I did.

2012 – The Express Diaries, by Nick Marsh

This was written by a friend, writing a novelised version of some more friends playing through a Call of Cthulhu roleplaying game campaign, set in the 1920s, seeing them cross Europe to Istanbul on the Orient Express. And face so many occult dangers on the way.

2013 – Whitstable, by Stephen Volk

Peter Cushing has been one of my favourite actors for as long as I can remember. He’s well known for his roles in horror films, especially for Hammer Films. This novella by Stephen Volk is a powerful and moving reimagining of a particularly difficult period of Peter Cushing’s life. Some horrors are much closer to home …

2014 – The Scottish Town in the Age of the Enlightenment 1740-1820, by Bob Harris and Charles McKean

Big disclaimer: this book was written by my two history PhD supervisors, and I was the original research assistant for the pilot study, and only didn’t continue on to more research assisting work because my neurological illness had relapsed suddenly and unexpectedly in 2004. The resulting book is a groundbreaking work of historical writing, that won multiple Saltire Book Awards, including the overall Saltire Scottish Book of the Year. Which was particularly moving for me, because it was published after Charles McKean had died.

2015 – Close Encounters of the Furred Kind, by Tom Cox

Tom Cox has written a number of delightful books, both funny and moving, often about his life, especially with the many characterful cats he has owned. This is one of my favourites of his. Get to know the cats including The Bear and larger than life Roscoe. A joy.

2016 – First Light: A celebration of Alan Garner, edited by Erica Wagner

Like many British children growing up in the 1970s and 1980s, I grew up with the stories of Alan Garner as frequent companions. “The Weirdstone of Brisingamen” was a particular favourite, but there are so many great titles by him, that together fired the imaginations of young readers. This book was compiled as a tribute to him, and includes contributions from friends, colleagues, family and fans, ranging across Alan’s many interests.

2017 – Grognard: Ruminations On 40 Years in Gaming, by Loren Wiseman

I’ve never played the Traveller roleplaying game, one of the earliest published tabletop roleplaying games, and an early scifi example. This book collects decades of editorials for the Traveller newsletter by original Traveller game designer Loren Wiseman. But that didn’t stop reading this book to be an eye opening read for a fan of RPG games in general. It has a sad ending – it was published posthumously – but is well worth spending time with.

2018 – Doctor Who: The Day of the Doctor, by Steven Moffat

I’ve been reading Doctor Who paperback novels since the late 1970s. I didn’t read as many as my future husband did at a similar time, but I did cherish those that I had and read. This was the pre-video era when the only way to revisit a Doctor Who story from the past was to find a Target novelised version and read that. And of course so many early Who stories are largely lost, after the BBC wiped the master recordings. The return of Doctor Who to TV screens in 2005 also led to a number of new old-style episode novelisations over the following years. And this one, written by former showrunner Steven Moffat, is in my opinion one of the best, retelling the 50th anniversary special, in an extremely creative way.

2019 – Spirits of the Season: Christmas Hauntings (British Library Tales of the Weird #5), edited by Tanya Cook

In recent years the British Library has published a large number of “Tales of the Weird” collections of spooky stories etc. Each book has a different theme. I could pick lots. But I’ve gone for one of the Christmas collections. There’s something quite magical about spooky stories at Christmas. All of the festive collections in this range are an excellent opportunity to revisit spooky festive stories of the past. Unsurprisingly MR James makes an appearance, but so do many other authors who are not so well remembered today.

2020 – Retro Tea Breaks Selected Interviews Vol. 1, by Neil Thomas

This is a marvellous collection of short interviews with early computing and computer game pioneers. All conducted by a British YouTuber and retro computing expert who now runs a computer history museum in Gloucestershire. I was lucky to nab a copy of the hardback version of the book, which is sadly unavailable now. But it is still available to buy as an ebook, and thoroughly recommended.

2021 – The Anthropocene Reviewed, by John Green

I discovered this book thanks to another YouTuber I follow. A wide ranging collection of short essays about the current world. Superbly written, effortlessly rereadable.

2022 – Babel, by R.F. Kuang

A publishing sensation, this is a powerfully written novel, almost Dickensian in its style, ranging over colonialism, academia, and the power and uses of language. It was the first RF Kuang book I read.

2023 – The Art Thief, by Michael Finkel

As someone who has long loved Renaissance art works this was a devastating read. But one that I couldn’t put down. A jaw dropping true tale of a phenomenally prolific art thief and the works he stole.

2024 – The Lewis Carroll Puzzle Book, by Lewis Carroll and edited by Brian Sibley

I’ve loved the Lewis Carroll Alice books since a young age. And then when I was a bit older I enjoyed his logic puzzles. Many editions of them have been published over the years. Any are worth picking up. But this is a particularly nicely packaged new introduction to his world of puzzles. All accompanied by the classic illustrations by John Tenniel.

So that’s my list up to last year. It’s been enormous fun looking back on books throughout my life in this way. I hope that some of the titles chosen may inspire your own reading. Or that my list may prompt your own reading reflections.

Review of “Captive Queen: The Decrypted History of Mary, Queen of Scots” by Jade Scott

I read this book recently on my Kindle. It was published in October 2024 in the UK, and is newly out in February 2025 in the US.

I went into this book expecting it to focus on the recently deciphered letters of Mary Queen of Scots found in the Bibliothèque Nationale in France. It does use some of these newly decoded letters in its discussion, but alongside many more previously decrypted letters by Mary, especially those held in the English National Archives in London.

The book’s focus is on Mary’s period of captivity, so 1567-1587, and especially 1568 onwards when she was a captive in England. However, before this the book contains lengthy coverage of her prior history, especially her marriages to Darnley and Bothwell. The book assumes no prior knowledge from the reader. But it does mean that you only get to the discussion of the decrypted letters relatively far into the book as a whole.

However, when you get here, there is the most thorough discussion I’ve ever seen in a book of Mary’s correspondence and activities during her period of captivity. Unlike some past biographies, it shows her as a highly active and engaged prisoner, using networks of correspondence – conducted through secret routes and encrypted letters – to reach out for help, and engage in plots and strategies for her release. This section is incredibly detailed, and well cited, with source references to letters discussed. It also explains the evolving network Mary was working within, including her secretaries, and various people, including foreign ambassadors, who helped her correspond with the outside world.

At the end the book ends rather abruptly, with Mary’s execution, and then, and rather strangely for me, a chapter about James VI and his relationship with and attitudes to his mother. I would have liked more assessment from the author here on Mary as a person, and whether her personality and story should be reassessed in the light of the letters. I just wanted more reflection at this point on Mary, not James. Until then it was very strong.

After the main text the book contains a summary chronology, lengthy notes/citations, and a bibliography. In the Kindle edition the end of the book includes the many illustrations, though I don’t know if these appear earlier in the printed version of the book. There is an index at the back. The opening of the book includes a list of “Dramatis Personae”, including most of the figures discussed in the text. This would be especially useful to readers of the print edition to flick back to, when reading the detailed discussion of the letters, though is cumbersome to switch back to on the Kindle.

Not quite the book I was expecting going in as a reader, but, actually, something much better. Highly recommended, though perhaps best read in print if you can.

Cover of "Captive Queen: The Decrypted History of Mary, Queen of Scots" by Jade Scott. The cover is richly designed, with emblems such as the thistle and rose against a rich blue background. At the top of the cover is a contemporary image of Mary herself. Around the edge designs twine further.

Looking back at a year of reading 2024 edition

It’s Hogmanay 2024, so time for another year’s reading retrospective from me! I adore reading, but read with great difficulty now due to my progressive neurological disease. I really envied the historic readers I was studying for my history PhD on Scottish reading habits … Thankfully my Kindle lets me read with an utterly gargantuan font, so I’m still gobbling up books, even as my disease continues to progress. But print books are rarely feasible for me now. Though I still read and enjoy graphic novels.

This year I finished 58 books, almost 17,000 pages read, and an average of 325 pages a week. Of these most of the books were fiction, with just 17 non fiction. I also read a couple of plays, and some works of poetry. The picture below shows a glimpse of some of the books I was reading over the months.

Various covers, including in the centre "Why We Love Middle-Earth" showing a warm Prancing Pony scene, and around the edge covers for some other books, including non fiction, manga and fantasy.

20 of this year’s books were fantasy, my favourite genre by far. This included a number of rereads, such as Tolkien’s The Fellowship of the Ring and Susan Cooper’s The Dark is Rising. I also did my usual pre-Halloween reread of Roger Zelazny’s A Night in the Lonesome October. Great new fantasy discoveries for me this year included V.E. Schwab’s A Darker Shade of Magic and Diana Wynne Jones’s Howl’s Moving Castle – yes I’m a bit behind the game with these ones!

I also read 10 graphic novels or manga books. Particularly manga books, and especially the Insomniacs After School series, which I found a delightful mix of slice of life, growing up, insomnia, astronomy and light romance. Quite a mix. I was also constantly amused because the main male character looks like a young version of my husband of 30 years!

16 reads were non fiction. I always have multiple non fiction books on the go. Highlights included Marchese and Sisto’s Why We Love Middle-earth: An Enthusiast’s Book about Tolkien, Middle-earth, and the LotR Fandom; Travis Nelson’s Sigrid Rides: The Story of an Extraordinary Friendship and An Adventure on Two Wheels; Michael Finkel’s The Art Thief (like a slow motion car crash, but unputdownable); Oliver Darkshire’s Once Upon a Tome: The Misadventures of a Rare Bookseller; and Aaron A. Reed’s 50 Years of Text Games: From Oregon Trail to A.I. Dungeon, which was a stunning achievement.

In my Goodreads record I rated 19 of this year’s reads 5 star, including 4 of the 5 books I reread this year. My average Goodreads rating was 3.8, but I did abandon some books that weren’t working for me, and didn’t record a score for them. And others are set to the side to be resumed later.

Looking ahead to 2025 I want to continue my very slow read of The Wheel of Time series by Robert Jordan. I think I am up to book 9 now. I’d also like to read more history books, and continue rereading some Shakespeare plays. Above all though I want to read and have fun, and look forward to discovering new gems as well as rediscovering old favourites.

Review of David Dobson’s “Scottish Genealogy: The Basics and Beyond”

I recently read this book, published by the Genealogical Publishing Company. It’s a compact paperback, 171 pages long.

Titled “Scottish Genealogy: The Basics and Beyond”, its emphasis is very much on the latter aspect, introducing the reader to less commonly used material which can be rich in information for people researching their family trees. The author draws on over fifty years of experience in this field, and is well qualified to write on this topic.

After a brief introduction to the basic Scottish genealogy records (birth, marriage and death certificates, census returns, and old parish registers) it turns to the other less known records. Examples covered (and these are just some of them) include other church records, gravestone inscriptions, statistical accounts, tax records, sasines and land registers, maritime records, burgh records, tracing specific occupations, covenanters, military records, education, poor law records, and emigration. It really is quite an extensive list. In each section there is a brief introduction to the type of record, and then a look at key archival sources (including document references) and published (usually in print, not online) guides and indexes.

The approach of focusing on archival and published material is both a strength and a weakness. A strength because it alerts the user to the existence of these records that they may not otherwise know of, and points them towards the original manuscript documents and relevant index material. A weakness because the book sometimes misses newer resources and indexes, particularly online, and because it doesn’t always direct the reader to the most efficient way of searching.

For example, the military records section directs the researcher to paper records at Kew etc but fails to mention the voluminous digitised and indexed versions of many of these records available through subscription services such as FindMyPast and Ancestry. These have revolutionised research into many military ancestors, including identifying records through the new indexes that could not be traced practically before. Likewise the emigration section fails to mention the considerable number of digitised passenger lists, which, particularly for the Victorian period onwards, allow us to newly trace post-1800 migration of ancestors and relatives in a way that was never practical before. Again available through subscription genealogy sites as named above.

The biggest omission for me was that there was no mention of the Scottish Indexes website. This, for many years now, has been providing free access to a growing number of indexes – all directing the user to original manuscript records with reference numbers, usually in the National Records of Scotland. These indexes cover many aspects of Scottish genealogy. As I write this review, the website’s Scotland’s Criminals Database now includes 178,654 entries (including 38,872 prison register entries), its Mental Health Records Index has 117,882 entries, and its Scottish Paternity Index contains 41,178 entries. These indexes cover many parts of Scotland, and facilitate access to manuscript records impractical to search before.

Such omissions are of particular concern because often the family historian, especially if at a distance as they often are, really needs good advice on how to search most efficiently and effectively for ancestors. With the mass of resources available now this is often best done using a mixture of online and offline resources.

Another niggle for me is the testamentary records section. This allows six pages for a very extended list of local testamentary index books (published, in print). Examples of index entries from each commissary court are given, but there is no guidance about the detailed content you might find in an original will or testament document. For example the sort of detailed information you can get on debt and credit, legacies, sometimes lists of personal possessions etc. That would have been a much more helpful use of space. It’s also worth noting that most Scottish genealogists now will search these records using the indexes online at ScotlandsPeople, not through the earlier published print volumes.

Nevertheless, and despite the above concerns, most of the book is extremely useful stuff, and is especially good as a reference source. I particularly enjoyed the sections on maritime records, burgh records and tracing specific occupations. I should also praise the emigration chapter, which draws on the author’s own rich experience in this (reflected by how many of his own useful indexes he refers to). Although as noted, this chapter has some weaknesses in its post-1800 advice. And its depth of coverage of the historical background for emigration feels somewhat indulgent compared to the briefer coverage of other topics elsewhere in the book that could be equally deserving.

A key question is who the book is for? I’ve already commented that I think it’s an excellent reference resource, albeit not totally comprehensive. In terms of practical use the book offers the greatest potential to someone able to conduct research on the spot in Scotland, especially in Edinburgh in the National Records of Scotland. Yet even for Scottish descendants at a distance it provides a good introduction to a large range of lesser used Scottish genealogical sources, and pointers to many published indexes, albeit missing many useful online resources. Although many of the manuscript records the book directs the reader to will still involve research in Scotland, and so it may be necessary for someone at a distance to hire a professional researcher.

So yes while I may have some concerns certainly regarding coverage and applicability, my assessment is generally positive overall. I’m certainly glad that I read this book.