Scream 3
PAIRINGS: yan!plan batfam x neglected!billy loomis!reader | WC: 5.1k
SUMMARY: being the product of bruce's one night stand with a stripper, a small boy had the misfortune of being born in crime alley. with an absent father, absent mother and a criminal environment, how would you think said child would turn out?
WARNINGS: SEMI-UNRELIABLE NARRATOR! the story is from the readers pov, so things will be described how he perceives them to be even if said character, or he himself, didnโt want to come across like that or actually didnโt feel that way. angst, emotional abuse, lowk only semi-canon, murder, mentions of prostitution, physical abuse, neglect, bullying, mentions of death, blood and violence.
A/N: this kinda took a while so im sorry about that but ive been busy with school and my internshipโฆ on a positive note though, i have summer holidays now so iโll have more free time !!! so expect updates to come faster lol. also to put it here officially if you didnโt see my post, louis isn't going to be the love interest. i thought about it, and while theyโre fond of each other, i see them more as platonicโฆ theyโre more than best friends but less than lovers imo. a relationship as a thin as a veil if you may. this chapter is also a little shorter and more lazily written icl.
itโs been three days since dick or bruce last saw your face in the flesh. three whole days of passing like a you're invisible through the manorโs drafty corridors, leaving nothing behind but maybe an empty bowl in the sink after youve eaten something.
the manor, to say straightforwardly, has been weird as fuck. itโs like those russian roulettes, where you always wait for someone to get the first shot before hell breaks loose. but nobody has acted on any of it yet - theyโre just watching from the sidelines, letting the silence stack up until itโs thick enough to choke on and you want to choke them for it.
you don't give them the satisfaction of a confrontation either. it's better to simply slip through the cracks, have your bare feet memorize the exact spots on the hardwood that don't make a sound so they'll stay outta your way.
it is not exactly a hard job to take notice of how damn on the edge everyones has been around you lately.
you wouldnโt even have bothered to take much notice of it if you didnโt notice how it was more intense than usual - an undercurrent that makes the hair on your arms stand up. it leads you to believe that maybe dick saw that fucking spot on the denim jacket (curse that complete idiot louis for wearing it twice. how fucking braindead can someone get?)
the timing is too perfect. with the teacher murdered being an instructor from your own school, the pieces are lying right there on the table. you don't know for sure if they actually suspect you one hundred percent yet - they haven't brought down the iron gates or cornered you in the study or however else they treat their cartoon villains - but something is definitely off.
currently, you're sitting at the corner table in the academy cafeteria. the air in here is.. down right disgusting. smelling like greasy tater tots, old sweat, and the cheap floor bleach the janitors use to sweep the halls that leave that nasty sting in your nose. the cafeteria is a total fucking madhouse because every single kid is buzzing about gerald hayes - how maybe it is some mob hit โcause the teacher got on their bad side.
you slowly pick at a turkey sandwich while louis vibrates right next to you on his plastic chair. chloe and maya are huddled close across the table, whispering under their breaths, looking like they might literally piss themselves if a locker slams too loud down the hall.
you look at chloeโs white knuckles clutching her glass and you resist the urge to roll your eyes. itโs pathetic. these people have spent their entire lives being and feeling protected, completely blind to how easy it is to break the world in half. their pathetic reactions are only to be expected but it should be a crime how simple minded people can be. as if the damn killer would strike someone he like he did gerald hayes in broad fucking daylight. use those two brain cells you got, wonโt you?
and then, much to your (mis)fortune, seth slides into the booth. the schoolโs resident unhinged horror movie geek - even more so than you at times you reckon.
"you guys are literally fucking blind," seth rants, leaning so far across the table his navy school tie dips straight into chloe's ranch dressing. heโs waving his hands around wildly, his eyes wide behind his thick glasses. "this isn't some generic gotham mob hit. the maronis don't slit a guy's throat and sit him like a goddamned mannequin. this is.. this is more slasher movie style. whoever is doing this is following the absolute rules of the genre."
seth mulls, his face twisting with this frantic, breathless sort of excitement. there's a loud, annoying weight to the chatter that surrounds him, but your mind is already drifting somewhere else.
you don't know why so suddenly contrast to your just recent emotions, amusement begins to stir up within you. likely due to the hilarity of it - how could these kids be so dull-witted and completely clueless, in not only in guessing what went down - but to fumble the pieces back together so clumsily?
sethโs fingers are digging through the rumors, little schoolboy is trying to play detective so eagerly. doesnโt he know the best way to survive a horror movie is to not fucking engage? if you're gonna play with blood, shouldn't you be a little more meticulous?
idiot. that's the only word you can think of.
and an idiot who thinks himself better than the rest of his lot at that.
you think about the instructor's death, the very thing they were all trying to figure out so desperately.
gerald hayesโ death lacked the weight of tragedy. it was less like losing a life than brushing away a fly that had spent more time circling the room than your own space - a minor nuisance, largely more someone elseโs problem, but one whose disappearance still made the air feel cleaner. it's absence barely registered, save for the quiet satisfaction that it would trouble no one again.
gerald hayes died and the world just kept turning. the sky didn't fall, the police didn't magically appear at your doorstep.
"seth, shut the fuck up, you're being so extra," chloe groans, wiping her tie with a napkin.
"no, listen to me!" seth barks, pointing a carrot stick directly at your face and then at louis. "think about it! itโs always the quiet ones. the best friend, the creepy brother, whatever. look at you two! you guys never eat dinner at home, you're out past midnight like, i dunno - every single night, and you literally look like the suspects from a nineties thriller. not only that, you both are even worse horror movie geeks than i am! if i vanish next, the principal is checking you two first, cause im onto you both."
louis lets out a loud, high-pitched, completely unhinged wheeze, his shoulders bouncing as he stuffs a handful of chips into his mouth. "no way! seth thinks we are in a movie or something. tell him he is crazy."
you roll your shoulders, your head shaking once. you aren't about to give this little shit the satisfaction of even a flinch. the softest parts of this city are always the ones that get run over first, and seth is as soft as they come. youโre loathe to speak the truth out loud. not now; not when the manor is crawling with its own paranoid bats.
or maybe youโre the paranoid one?
"movies don't create psychos," you drawl as you curb a corner of your sandwich wrapper with your index finger. "movies make psychos more creative."
seth freezes, blinking at you stupidly . the table goes quiet for a split second, and louis giggles louder in the background, leaning forward with a massive, unhinged grin on his face.
"maybe you need to stop living in your damn fantasies seth," you mutter, a small smile touching your lips as you lean back against your seat. "you sound like a total amateur."
louis nods aggressively, flicking a tater tot across the table. "honestly, seth is a compleeetee idiot. you dunno whatchu talkinโ about."
you give louis a side eye with a raised brow - its not like louis knows either what the hell he's talking about half the damn time either.
louis keeps wearing his smile, giving you a thumbs up. ignoring him, you look out the cafeteria window, watching the grey rain beat against the glass.
while itโs pathetic and sad how idiotic they are, itโs a good thing for you. they are all looking in the wrong direction or sound too damn high to actually have anyone take worthy notice of their words - like how it is with seth.
by the time the final bell rings, the schoolyard is a total wash of rain, turning the gravel into a muddy slop.
louis managed to somehow get himself thrown into after-school detention for throwing a wet paper towel at the chalkboard, so youโre entirely on your own for the walk to the gates.
of course, you didnโt bother bringing an umbrella for whatever reason, one you regret now.
so instead shove your hands deep into your pockets, yank your hoodie you had kept in your locker up over your ears, and try to blend into the sea of people rushing for the buses.
then she steps right into your path.
a big, bright red umbrella cuts off your line of sight, the metal ribbing almost catching the edge of your hood. you stop dead, your jaw popping as you look up.
youโve heard of her, obviously. everyone at the academy knows the lead reporter for the school paper - mostly because sheโs notoriously bossy, incredibly rude, and completely stuck up - or so they say. apparently, she treats the high school journalism column like some sort of crazed witch hunt.
sheโs got a heavy vintage leather satchel slung over her shoulder, her hazel eyes narrow as she looks at you.
you think you can see some sort of wilderness in her eyes. spoiled and beautiful and easily bored.
"well, well, well if it isn't gothamโs favorite billionaire trust fund," valerie says, her voice fast, dripping with a wit that instantly reminds you of some old-school television reporter. she looks you up and down, a slight judging expression at your messed up appearance thanks to the rain - a look you almost grow offended by.
โgodโฆ wayne, you look miserable. tell me, do you always walk through a downpour brooding like the sky pissed on you or is the brooding look just a lifestyle choice? i don't think the girls are into that stuff, kinda stuff from yesterday if you ask me."
you force up a sarcastic smile - hahaha. how really fucking funny.
instead of replying immediately, you look down at the little red light blinking on her recorder. "i'm walking to my car, valerie. move the umbrella."
"not a chance. i need a quote, pretty boy, and you're the only one who isn't currently sobbing in the guidance counselor's office, running from the rain or-" she looks to your right side, the one where louis usually always walks next to you โ-stuck in detention.โ
she tilts the red canopy just enough to keep the rain off your face, her words hitting without a single break - god how much can she talk?
"let's talk about timing, shall we? because gerald hayes was found dead on a shipping crate early in the morning after heading out at midnight, and from what the office staff tells me, he officially, or well, wanted to, put a failing grade on louis vanceโs permanent record a few days before he mysteriously died. and louis... well, louis didn't exactly look like he was going to take that lying down, did he?"
you keep your hands in your pockets, letting your head tilt to the side. "louis is an idiot. he gets mad at video games. he doesn't care about essays."
"right, of course not," valerie scoffs, her eyes dancing with a mocking light. "which brings me to my next question-โ your face palms, another one? โ-because according to a very reliable source at the plaza theater, you and your little partner-in-crime were spotted walking out of the back exit quite late at night. right the same times hayes was nearing the docks, actually. which is a pretty incredible coincidence, don't you think? unless you two just really, really needed to do some late night thing like checking out the concessions near the harbor?โ
your chest goes tight for a split second, your heart actually beating.
how the fuck does she even know that? nobody was supposed to be looking at the plazaโs side doors. fuck, you frequent that theater so much because the damn theater manager is a drunk who doesn't even check the ticket stubs, let alone the security cameras! your mind instantly starts tracking the variables.
surprisingly, this girl isn't an idiot. sheโs actually smart. sheโs the first person you've met in this entire goddamned school who isn't stumbling over her own feet.
you don't back down - you take a step forward, deliberately invading her space, leaning in under the red fabric until your face is just inches from hers. the smell of her wet hair and the plastic umbrella hits your nose.
you look straight at ber, your voice smooth and confident, completely dismissing everything she just threw at you.
"you're real cute when you're playing detective, valerie," you drawl, a small smirk spreading across your lips. "but you're barking up the wrong tree. louis and i were watching a late-night horror movie, nothing odd โbout that is there? you want a real scoop? hayes wasn't the type to look at the big picture. you should check his desk. people who focus too much on people pleasing and small mistakes usually miss the glare coming off the water."
itโs a sorta a lie, of course.
hayes died exactly because of a high school grudge, his throat opened up because he dared to threaten louisโs future (not that you think his future was actually threatened but louis insisted that it was - his parents surely wouldโve saved his ass if it came hard to hard). but the hint you drop is subtle, buried in abstract nonsense about the glare on the water, a quiet nod to pier four, and the people pleasing (considering the dumb fuck did go to down there at midnight just to please his fucking superiors) that would make absolutely zero sense to an outsider.
valerie freezes. her breath catches right in the middle of her throat, her eyes widening just a fraction as she stares at you.
sheโs very curious you can tell - almost completely intrigued, even?
howeverโฆ valerie is valerie and she stays right there instead of leaving, her fingers tightening on the grip of her satchel.
"the glare on the water, people pleasing?" she mutters, her flustered expression showing for a fraction of a second before her usual stuck up one returns. she tries to keep her voice steady, but the rhythm is broken. "that sounds incredibly specific for someone who claims they were only inside a dark theater, wayne. what is that supposed to mean?"
"believe whatever you want," you whisper, your face going neutral again as you take a step back out into the downpour, letting the cold water hit your face.
"somethings are better left undiscovered, you donโt wanna get caught in something you canโt escape from." you turn on your heel and walk toward the parking lot, leaving her standing under her red umbrella.
the town car ride back is quiet, the steady slap of the windshield wipers the only thing filling the space while you sit in the back seat, staring at the rain.
your mind keeps looping back to the gates. to valerie. that odd, odd girl. sheโs dangerous, not because she has a badge or a cape, but because she actually has a brain. most people are idiots, a thing you keep repeatedly getting reminded of, but sheโs looking for the cracks, and youโre going to have to make sure she finds only what you want her to see.
the car rolls to a stop under the manor's grand stone portico. you swing the heavy door open, barely offering alfred a nod before you cross the threshold, expecting the usual. the familiar hollowness of a massive house that doesn't care if you're breathing or not.
you step into the grand sitting room and freeze, your hands freezing inside your pockets. the entire fucking circus is justโฆ waiting for you. itโs completely uncanny, like walking into a room full of wax figures that someone forgot to turn off. bruce is a massive by the fireplace, staring down into the embers. dick is hovering on the edge of the leather sofa, spinning his keys. tim is leaning against the grand piano, his arms crossed tight with an uncomfortable to expression, while stephanie is sitting rigidly in an armchair, pretending to read a book that you know for a fact she hasn't turned the page of in a while because it stills the first damn page.
even cassandra is there, blending into the dark wood of the doorframe and damian right next o her.
they are all trying way too hard to look casual. itโs fucking terrifying.
the second your boots click against the floor, dick forces this massive, bright smile onto his face. it doesn't reach his eyes. "hey! you're home," he says, his voice bouncing a little too loud off the high ceiling. "how was the rest of your day at school?"
you don't answer, because what the fuck? your jaw pops in the dead silence, your eyes doing a sweep of the room. what the fuck is this?
they actually do know something, donโt they? fuck. did tim actually find an anomaly? did they run your data? you thought you covered every single track, you thought the watchtower encryption loop you built was flawless, but looking at them now, the paranoia settles deep into your ribs like grease.
"we were actually just talking," tim speaks up, his voice hesitant, completely lacking that professional edge he usually carries. he clears his throat, shifting his weight against the piano. "thought maybe we could all go out for a family dinner tonight. just us. we haven't really done that inโฆ well, ever."
"yeah!" stephanie chips in a little too quickly, her laugh sounding thin and brittle as she shuts her book. "thereโs that little italian place downtown. the one with the red checkered tablecloths you used to love when you were a kid. remember?" you stopped going there after jason died - its a place you frequented with him. how the hell does she know about that anyways? from dick? you doubt jason would tell her.
talking about him, next to dick, jason is sitting with his boots dragged back, his jaw locked tight as he stares at you through his messy bangs. he looks completely miserable, like he was dragged into this room by his throat - aka he looks like he always does. dick notices your stare glances at him, then back at you, the smile widening. "we even convinced jason to join us! the whole family. what do you say?"
jason doesn't say a word, but damian does. "this is a pathetic waste of tactical time," he sneers from the corner, his small frame rigid as he glares at his own shoes. "we should just take him already and go." so much for consent, wow.
cassandraโs eyes stay wide, bottomless, tracking the subtle hitch in your chest. "he is cold," she whispers softly, "it was raining heavily outside, it must still be on him."
dick takes a closer look at your clothes at her statement, eyes slightly widening. โohโฆ you're right cass-โ
you blur their conversation out.
looking at the whole pathetic lineup, a wave of pure, unadulterated disgust rolls through your stomach. a family dinner. they spent years treating you like an invisible in their billionaire playground - someone odd and to keep away from, and now that a teacher from your school gets his throat slit, they suddenly want to play happy family? itโs hella weird. itโs a setup. theyโre trying to soften you up, trying to gauge your reaction, checking to see if you've done some shit. if youโre still good so their savior complex doesnโt get hurt.
you reach down, yanking the sleeves of your oversized grey sweatshirt completely down until they cover your knuckles and you look right past dickโs bright smile, your eyes locking onto bruceโs gaze as the old man takes a slow step forward, clearly trying to find the words to "check in" on his blood son.
"i'm not hungry," you say. dickโs smile falters instantly, his jaw tightening. you take a step toward the grand staircase, turning your back on the whole uncanny display. "save the savior complex for the streets, bruce. it doesn't work on me."
the click of your boots against the first few steps is the only sound in the hall. you don't look back, you don't want to see their tight, anxious faces or whatever version of family guilt they're trying to push onto you today.
but the floorboards behind you suddenly groan.
"wait, just hold on a second," dickโs voice barks out, his light, athletic footsteps rushing across the rug. heโs chasing you up the stairs, his hand reaching out in the dim light of the landing like heโs trying to catch a ghost before it slips through his fingers. "we're just trying to talk to you. you don't have to always slam the door on us, okay? we just want to know how you're doing."
fuck that. you don't slow down, not even a slight pause to give him a witty comeback or look at his desperate, older-brother face. you just want to get the fuck outta here - your heart thudding against your ribs as you bolt down the corridor of the second floor. your room is right at the end, a door that represents the only somewhat safe square inch in this circus.
dick stops at the bottom of the second flight. you can hear his chest heaving, his sneakers squeaking on the wood as he realizes you aren't turning around. his arms drop back to his sides, completely blown off by the coldness you left in your wake.
you slide inside your bedroom, yank the door shut, and turn the heavy metal key until it locks with a sharp, echoing click.
dick comes back down the stairs slowly, his sneakers making a defeated drag against the bottom step. his chest is still heaving slightly, his face completely pale under the warm chandelier light. he rubs the back of his neck, his fingers twisting into his collar as he looks at the rest of the family, his hands still trembling just a fraction.
"he didn't even look back..," dick mutters, his voice dropping, completely stripped of that brightness he had earlier. he drops back onto the edge of the leather sofa, staring blankly at the rug. "he just... he bolted straight into his room and locked it. wouldn't even let me finish a sentence."
"because your strategy is entirely incompetent, grayson," damian sneers from his corner, his small arms crossed tightly over his crest as he glares at the wall. "forcing a pathetic performance of domestic tranquility upon an obvious tactical threat is a waste of resources. we should have subdued him and run an analysis on his garments hours ago."
"shut the fuck up, damian," jason barks out near the piano, his voice raw, an ugly, defensive snap cutting through the quiet. heโs still standing with his jaw locked, his eyes tracking the stairwell where you just disappeared.
he hates himself for letting bruce drag him into this little trap, hates himself for sitting here like a prop while they all look at you like youโre some wild animal. "heโs not a target. heโs seventeen. you don't talk about him like heโs some rogue we're trying to put in arkham."
"jason, nobody is trying to put him in arkham," tim speaks up, his voice anxious as he shifts his weight against the grand piano. "but when the shoe fits it fits. we can't just ignore that. if he's the one doing this... if he's the slasher, he's killing completely innocent people right under our noses. we have to find out the truth."
"but what if we're wrong?" stephanie asks, her hand clenching the edge of her book. she looks between dick and bruce. "god, did you see his face? he looked at us like he literally detests our guts. if heโs innocent, and weโre here running digital wiretaps on his room because a teacher from his school died, we are completely destroying whatever tiny bit of trust he had left in this family. he already thinks we hate him!โ
cassandra looks at stephanie, moving over to place a comforting hand onto her shoulder. "he must be anxious because he knows the eyes are on him. heโs simply not used to it.โ
stephanie gives cassandra a thankful glance in return.
bruce doesn't say a word. he stays entirely still by the fireplace, the orange embers casting shadows across the lines of his face.
he really thought keeping you away from the masks would protect you. he thought if you didn't know the horrors of the loop, you could stay pure, stay normal. instead, he just left you alone in the dark until you mutated into something he can't even read anymore. can't recognize.
..or maybe he never recognized you in the first place. never knew you at all.
"bruce?" dick prompts, his voice cracking slightly on the vowels as he looks up, pleading for an answer, pleading for someone to tell him his little brother isn't a monster. "since he obviously doesnโt want to spend timeโฆ do we just confront him directly?โ
bruce slowly lifts his head, his dark eyes looking eighty years old under the warm lamplight. his jaw is locking into a hard, stubborn line.
"no," bruce rumbles, his deep voice putting an iron curtain over the entire sitting room. "we do not confront him. not without definitive proof."
"bruce, there's enough clues to make him a suโ" tim starts. "i said no, tim," bruce cuts him off, his tone dropping into an authoritative register.
"just focus on the weapons shipment tonight. dick, you monitor his terminal logs. tim, watch his phone location. if he leaves this house tonight, i want to know the exact second his boots hit the gravel and where he goes. clear the room."
the room is completely dark, the only light coming from the sickly grey twilight bleeding through the rain-streaked window panes. you lean your back against the solid wood, letting out a breath through your nose.
they definitely know something. fuck. theyโve been a hundred percent digging but you donโt know what they know. no way they would act this fucking weird otherwise.
your old man could not love, but maybe he believed he could, and you guess that must be enough for someone like him, because perhaps half this godforsaken world feels the exact same way. he believed he loved you, sure, to comfort his own miserable, regretful heart, but you could tell him face-to-face how fucking untrue that was. you could sit him down and list for him the exact number of times his heroic little crusade had placed you squarely within the jaws of death before you were even old enough to shave. you could list for him every single time he had completely failed to be a father to you, his motherless kid, while he was too busy running wayne enterprises and becoming a grand man of this world.
he loved, he loved; he loved himself. it is perhaps the way of all men, especially the ones who wear capes in the dark and try to play fucking hero.
a sudden buzz in your front pocket cuts through the bitter noise in your head. you pull your phone out, itโs a text from louis.
louis: boss man look out the window right fucking now look down
you let out a breath through your nose, your jaw popping as you walk over to the massive glass window. you look down into the rain-drenched courtyard below - the storm is absolutely hammering the laurels, the heavy green leaves shaking violently under the downpour.
and right there, tucked neatly into the wet dirt of the hedge near the iron gate, you spot him.
louis is crouching in the bushes, soaking wet, his clothes clinging to his skin like a second layer of plastic. his dark hair matted completely flat against his skull and the idiot is grinning this absolutely dumb, wide-eyed smile up at you through the freezing rain, trying so damn hard to keep his eyes open against the fat drops pelting his face. the second he sees your silhouette against the glass, he aggressively throws up a massive double thumbs-up, maybe trying to signal that he is okay? you donโt even know.
all you can see is that he's blinking like crazy as the water pools in his eyelashes.
you stand there for a second, staring down at his soaking wet, moronic ass, and you sigh once more. you roll your eyes so hard it almost hurts, rubbing the bridge of your nose as you look down at the blinding screen in your hand. he is a total lunatic, a complete loose wire, but heโs the only thing in this whole city that keeps you from going entirely brain-dead.
you: loose that smile you absolute fucking idiot and wipe your face
you: whats with everyone acting weird as fuck today??
you: the whole fucking clown show just tried to trap me in the living room offering me DINNER, trying to act like a real family. it was literally horrifying wtf
louis: no shot LMAOOOO ๐
louis: someone save poor boss man from family bonding boohoo ๐ฟ๐ฟ๐ฟ๐ฟ
you: stfu dick joke lit chased me up the stairs
you: i blew em off but itโs hella weird. yk why
louis: shii we are ๐งโ๐ณ cooked๐ฉโ๐ณ boss man
louis: whatโs the play??
you glance back out the window. louis is still down there, staring at his phone, his stupid smile flattening out into a slight, pouty twitch in his jaw - even in the middle of a panic, heโs still clearly annoyed that you ditched him when he got detention and is most likely going to whine about how you spoke to that reporter chick when going back to the manor instead of staying with him.
a soft, amused chuff comes through your nose and text him back.
you: get out of the dirt. i'm slipping out the back
you: were spending the night at your place. we need to talk.
louis: bet. car is around the corner. don't get caught by the big bad bat ๐คซ
you leave him on seen and slide the phone into your pocket, getting everything you need and taking an umbrella with you this time -
it's time to hatch up a plan.
if you wish to be tagged for the next chapter comment pls! :)