I've been really cranky about fandom things the past few weeks.
a. I didn't sign up for Yuletide this year, despite appearing on
Fandomspotting to talk about how excited I was to do it. This is because I spent the month of October labouring under the misapprehension that they'd disqualified
Assassin's Creed III, despite the fact that it didn't even exist as a source at the time of nomination, and I was so fucking pissed about it that I couldn't bring myself to sign up. But it turns out that it was reinstated, only NO ONE EVER REPLIED TO MY COMMENT TELLING ME THAT IT HAD BEEN, so I only found out when I was going through the DYW letter spreadsheet and saw that someone had requested it. Good fucking job, Yuletide admin. I know they've got lots of other stuff to worry about beyond whether my pet fandom gets in, but this (plus other annually recurring bullshit) has pretty much completely soured me on the exchange. I'm happy that other people are excited about it, and I guess I might still try to write a treat, but overall: ugh.
b. I've been finding lj-based hockey fandom a really unpleasant place to be lately. I'm sure there are some perfectly lovely people left on lj (and yes, whoever's reading this, you are probably one of them) but I find, in general, that lj-based hockey fandom is a real cult of nice. And if you're wondering why I never post about hockey anymore: this is why. Because I've certainly written hockey-related posts; I just don't post them, because I find that the culture that's developed on lj to be extremely unwelcoming of the kind of stuff that I want to talk about. Being critical of other people's grasp of characterization, setting, Canadian culture, or even hockey in general, is strongly discouraged. I find the whole thing kind of distressing, actually, because how the fuck do you do fandom without talking about the problems with 1) the source material or 2) fannish output? For example, I spent months and months in Inception
complaining (in a pretty high profile way) about
bad characterization and all the
gross shit people wrote, and I never once felt like I was doing anything wrong. But now? If I want to make a post explaining (for example) how gross the Good Canadian Boy stereotype is when it shows up in all earnestness either in fic or in meta commentary, or how a lot of fic doesn't ring true for me because a lot of authors don't make a meaningful distinction between Canadian culture and American culture, I feel like fandom will close ranks and run me out for being a dick. Because fandom doesn't want to have these conversations, because it's
too mean and it
might hurt someone's feelings to have their ideas criticized.
What it comes down to is that I feel like the only acceptable way to be fannish about hockey on lj is to post mindless squee about butts, or Jonathan Toews' inability to have an emotion, or otherwise to complain about things that no one could possibly disagree with, like the lockout or how Gary Bettman is a weasel in a skin suit. It's not that people shouldn't talk about those things, but I want it to be acceptable and even
encouraged to talk and argue about other things, too. Why is it so hard to imagine that we, as a fandom, can disagree about things without somehow destroying the whole endeavour? Why can we not have dissent that isn't automatically branded as wank, or seen as evidence of evil forces conspiring to ruin happiness? Because I don't want to tear fandom apart, but I do want to be able to talk about what's wrong with it. But the prevailing culture won't allow that, and it's making me pretty miserable here.
ON A COMPLETELY UNRELATED TOPIC, here is a thing that will never make me miserable (and marries elements of points a and b):
WHO IS GOING TO WRITE THE STORY WHERE CAREY PRICE IS AN ASSASSIN? I DON'T KNOW WHAT WOULD HAPPEN BUT CLEARLY PK SUBBAN AND STEVEN STAMKOS SHOULD ALSO BE INVOLVED SOMEHOW, BECAUSE THEY'VE BEEN HANGING OUT LATELY I THINK? PERHAPS GARY BETTMAN IS ACTUALLY THE HEAD OF ABSTERGO AND THEY MUST RID THE WORLD OF HIM FOREVER? THE POINT IS, CAREY PRICE WITH HIDDEN BLADES.
Discuss amongst yourselves.