I sometimes say being in a play is like being on vacation or going away to camp. You have to set aside time in your life away from your normal world. It’s a whole separate sphere from your friends, family, and your job. You have to work with a group of people you may not know or at least not spend time with regularly. A play becomes your second family, your second job, and your primary social life. It can feel so far removed from your regular life that it can lend itself to the idea that what happens in the theater, stays in the theater.
I think that’s why being in a play can so easily create the situation called “showmance”. Actors are thrown together, isolated from their daily lives, for several hours every week. This can create some close friendships that may or may not extend beyond the theater. Romances can happen as well – and that sometimes means illicit romances.
Ever since I started doing community theater, I have seen my share of showmances. That includes hearing rumors of romances that are a tad unsavory.
When I did my first show with The Harrison Players in high school, the lead actor in the show began dating a member of the dance ensemble. The ended up married.
For my second show with the Harrison Players, the stage manager brought along his girlfriend to be his assistant. They seemed like a great couple. She ended up cheating on him with one of the hot young guys in the cast. I'm not sure what became of either relationship.
When I was in my twenties, I was single and unhappy about it. During a rehearsal for a Harrison Players show, I was chatting with my married friend Carmela about it. Carmela said I had all the wrong hobbies for meeting men, and I should add golf to my schedule. Ironically when I asked her how she met her husband, she said she met him when they performed together in a Harrison Players show.
Five years ago I was performing in The Addams Family with Bedford Community theater and one evening my friend Ken was in the audience. Ken is a character to say the least. He has an insane sense of humor and will do almost anything on stage (and offstage). Some of the kids in The Addams family had been in a production of The Secret Garden with Ken two years before at that theater. They liked Ken and were happy to see him. They were also gossiping a lot about how Ken carried on an affair with a fellow cast member. They barely kept it a secret.
Ken and his wife are still married. That makes me wonder about how common it is for people to have a relationship during a show and then walk away and go back to real life. Ken's wife does theater too, although she tends to work more backstage than onstage. Did she have any illicit trysts of her own?
Stories like this hit home because of something that happened at the cast party this weekend. All five of us in the cast and the director were there. My castmate Eric, who played my onstage husband, was the first to leave. He went around the room and hugged everyone goodbye. When he got to me, he gave me a huge bear hug and a sloppy wet kiss on the cheek and said, “I love you.”
Eric and I were working together several hours a week for over three months. The only other woman in the cast also had her partner in the cast. Eric and I played husband and wife. Sometimes when we spoke offstage, he was flirty. Was he merely staying in character, or was there more to it? Sometimes when actors have to be affectionate with each other on stage, it can initially be awkward. When his character walked on stage and had to give me a hug and a kiss hello, he did so without hesitation right from the beginning. Again, that could be nothing more than knowing how to feel professional detachment. Plus it made me a lot more comfortable with it. I wasn't trying to read too much into anything.
We were drinking a lot of champagne at the cast party. He had a beer or two in between. That probably helped with the insertion of his foot in his mouth. When he said "I love you," he likely meant, "I really enjoyed working with you." It also could have meant, "I'm attracted to you and I'm too tipsy to have the inhibitions not to say so and also too tipsy to say it more subtly." (I am glad he was able to drive home safely.)
How do I feel about him? I like him. He's attractive and funny and sweet. He has the most beautiful crystalline blue eyes. If we weren't both married I wouldn't kick him out of bed. However, I'm married to a great guy and I intend to stay married and be faithful. His wife came to a few shows. I saw them together. They are clearly quite happily married. There was nothing to worry about. I figured our flirtation would run its course once the show was over and so it has.
But I wonder what the optics were for everyone else.
The party was at the home of our castmates Michele and James who have been cohabitating for the last eighteen years. During the party we were all talking our relationships and how long we had been together and how we met our spouses. Michele and James were a showmance. They met while doing community theater in their home state of Montana. They said their romance was a bit scandalous when it began because one of them was still married. Michele eventually confessed it was her. What was the state of her marriage at the time she met James? Is her ex-husband a theater person? It's clear to me she needs to be with another theater person. This showmance was a bit scandalous, but it worked out for them in the end. They are a strong and solid couple together.
But knowing what they know, I wonder if they observed what happened and questioned it. After everyone left, were they gossiping to each other about what they saw? Did they notice anything else during the whole rehearsal and run? Did they see things I never saw? Were they not surprised Eric behaved that way with me at the cast party?
I think a showmance has to be treated the same way a workplace relationship should be treated. When I was single, I refused to date coworkers because I felt it would be too awkward to be in the office with someone every day if the relationship ended. If the relationship is illicit, it can call the entire reputation of the participants into question with both management and your coworkers. Now expand that to the theater world. Actors encounter many of the same people across various shows. While starting a legitimate romance can lead to a happy ending, you do have to consider if things don't work out, your ex might be in the same cast as you in the future. If you are having an illicit affair, you will deal with the gossip for years to come (as Ken proved). Plus you will might be cast in another show with your affair partner in the future and that would be awkward. Eric and I could not only be cast in future shows together, but he could also be cast in a show with Kevin (they were already in
The Shawshank Redemption together). In other words, even if I were single, dating castmates is trickier than it seems.
Saturday night The Manor Club is having a Semiquincetennial musical review celebrating the history of the US and US theater. I have a few theater friends in it and Leslie Ann the stage manager is in it as well. Eric's wife is in it. I'm going and I'm going alone since
Death of a Salesman is going up that weekend (I am seeing that on both Friday and Sunday so I have Saturday night free.)The whole cast will be there, so we will be having a reunion of sorts. I'm wiping the slate clean. These castmates are my friends. Eric was nothing more than a friendly castmate who was good at his role. He acted dumb in a tipsy moment that I don't even remember as of right now. That's my story and I sticking to it. What happens during a show stays at the show.