There where the sun flies, there where the sky is bluer still
Rewatching John Carpenter's Starman (1984) in full for the first time in decades reminded me of the odd, small cycle in American science fiction of its decade with their almost folkloric exploration of passing for human—learning what it is to be human, which is never required to mean replicating it perfectly. Jeff Bridges as the Starman retains his slight, birdlike glitches of movement and artifically accurate cadences to the last. His eidetic mimicry of television fills in for the cultural tics and expectations he has not yet worked out the rules of, but whose pattern he can reproduce well enough for normal social weirdness. It took me well into adulthood to understand the humor of the scene in Splash (1984) in which Madison is initially upset by a shootout in an episode of Bonanza because that extra-diegetic awareness of acting which a slightly nonplussed Allen explains to her was exactly how I learned to separate my own emotional reactions from fictional images that similarly disturbed me. The Brother from Another Planet (1984) and The Hidden (1987) would be the other titles that come to mind; I may be overlooking others, but the superficial appearance of Earth-humanity is a necessary criterion. Of course they are immigration stories, too, or so many of our heroes wouldn't have an inimical government on their tails. Madison and the Brother even make their respective landfalls at Ellis Island. I would love to be able to interpret this strain as a rebuttal to the paranoia of so much of the previous generation's science fiction where the federal government, fueled by the Cold War and the Red and Lavender Scares, was fully justified in blowing the aliens away, but I might need a larger sample set. I can at least track that the nonhuman characters under discussion are just trying to get on with their own lives, whose cosmically personal stakes are love or freedom or knowledge. "I make maps," the Starman explains himself. They feel more like Zenna Henderson's People stories than even something like The Man Who Fell to Earth (1976). I saw three of them as a small child. It was a useful additional reinforcement of the different ways to be a person.

no subject
ETA—though I think the main joke there is that in LA, literal space aliens can 1. get a California makeover; and 2. behaviour-wise are no weirder than anybody else.
no subject
And Julie Brown can sing about anything.
(I'd still point-blank forgotten about this movie while remembering others to rule them out, e.g. E.T. (1982) or Flight of the Navigator (1986) or *batteries not included (1987), so I appreciate you throwing it into the discussion even if it only part-Venns.)
no subject
no subject
I appreciate the data point!
no subject
Oh mood.
no subject
It's a measurable mood in more than one movie from this era and I am fascinated by its presence!
no subject
no subject
It doesn't feel like that kind of single-source radiation, partly because social mimicry is also involved in all cases, but I did think of that film in relation to this cycle (and then winnowed it out because it is explicitly not about learning anything).
no subject
no subject
I recommend it! It is essentially a road movie: cross-country, working-class, more concerned with the difficult, delicate relationship developing between the Starman and Karen Allen's Jenny Hayden than with the mechanics of the science fiction (he carries seven metal spheres with him which are obviously some kind of energy-manipulating tool and are just as obviously played by ball bearings). For years it was the only thing I had seen by John Carpenter, which did not actually mean anything to me. It has always felt like a folktale to me.
no subject
Thank you for the mini review!
no subject
As of this most recent rewatch, there are like two lines which I feel the script could have left out and otherwise it holds up for me (and the lines are sfnal preference, not, like, the '80's).
Thank you for the mini review!
Thank you!
Starman
It reminded me a bit of The Straight Story, as both are films that doesn't fit really the stereotypical shorthand view of a director's work, but which nevertheless clearly examines their preoccupations.
Also, it reminded me how many more films of this era ought to have featured Karen Allen.
Re: Starman
I have not yet seen The Straight Story, but everything I have heard about it makes sense of that comparison to me. It took me decades to see anything else by Carpenter. (Fortunately, that included The Fog before Widow's Bay hit my pseudo-TV screen.)
Also, it reminded me how many more films of this era ought to have featured Karen Allen.
Yes!
Re: Starman
Re: Starman
I saw it in their collection of Harry Dean Stanton! I will endeavor to finally watch it.
no subject
no subject
*hugs*
no subject
no subject
It's on Tubi!
It's fascinating how completely opposite this kind of alien-passing-for-human story is from the remake of Invasion of the Body Snatchers from just a few years earlier.
Yes! One of the other films which doesn't fit into this cycle is The Terminator (1984), where the human skin is just aggressive mimicry.
no subject
Oh, and don't forget that Jeff Bridges was nominated for a Best Actor Oscar for Starman, back when acting nominations for anything that even hinted that it might be skiffy were exceeding rare, possibly non-existent except for Cliff Robertson's win for playing Charly.
The comparison with The People stories is quite apt. Did you ever see the TV-movie adaptation?
Liquid Sky comes to mind as a very '80s movie about aliens trying (sorta) to pass as human, but I'm not sure if it belongs in the same paddock as Starman, or really with anything else at all with the possible exception of Repo Man. Cocoon certainly has charms similar to both Starman and Splash but I'd hesitate to say their themes were all that similar. Strange Invaders is all about aliens trying to pass as human but I don't remember it very well, except I don't think those aliens were particularly nice.
"Red means stop, green means go, yellow means go very fast."
no subject
I would trust you to recognize them!
Oh, and don't forget that Jeff Bridges was nominated for a Best Actor Oscar for Starman, back when acting nominations for anything that even hinted that it might be skiffy were exceeding rare, possibly non-existent except for Cliff Robertson's win for playing Charly.
I saw that! It was well deserved for his nonhumanness. And wiped off the map like everyone else by Amadeus.
The comparison with The People stories is quite apt. Did you ever see the TV-movie adaptation?
I never did. Do you recommend it? The closest I have seen is Escape to Witch Mountain (1973), which I could not process in elementary school as anything but a ripoff. (I revisited it in 2020.)
Liquid Sky comes to mind as a very '80s movie about aliens trying (sorta) to pass as human, but I'm not sure if it belongs in the same paddock as Starman, or really with anything else at all with the possible exception of Repo Man.
I loved it and I wouldn't class it with this cycle even if it hadn't reminded me more of art and music and written fiction than other movies when I saw it, but it is among my favorite science fiction of the '80's and it turns out I like a lot of '80's science fiction.
Cocoon certainly has charms similar to both Starman and Splash but I'd hesitate to say their themes were all that similar. Strange Invaders is all about aliens trying to pass as human but I don't remember it very well, except I don't think those aliens were particularly nice.
I'm familiar with Cocoon by reputation, but I don't think I have even heard much about Strange Invaders. Huh.
"Red means stop, green means go, yellow means go very fast."
"'Yelled, "Greetings!" and melted his lug wrench'?"
no subject
I never did. Do you recommend it?
Gosh, I think I saw it when it premiered in January 1972 as an ABC TV-movie. (The Night Stalker original movie had premiered on ABC the previous week. Oh, those were the days!) So my memory of it is pretty vague. I had not at that time read any of Henderson's stories, so I didn't have that background to catalyze a stronger reaction. But my impression, as I look back on it through deep time and after having read the first book of the People stories a few years ago, is that it was a respectful, sincere adaptation but covered only a narrow swath of People lore; Wikipedia says it's an adaption of a single story, "Pottage." According to my copy of Fraser A. Sherman's Cyborgs, Santa Claus and Satan: Science Fiction, Fantasy and Horror Films Made for Television (McFarland 2000) -- highly recommended if you can find an affordable copy, if only for the movie timeline -- it was an early production of American Zoetrope with Francis Ford Coppola executive producing and with music by Carmine. So yes, I'd recommend it.
no subject
Okay, neat! I will keep it in mind as a single-shot adaptation.
no subject
no subject
I was thinking of nonhuman characters rather than displaced human ones. Time travel stories feel adjacent but not identical. I will take other suggestions from the '80's!
no subject
no subject
Yes! Even the fact of their difference is important.