Tags: advice

Wall-E

Graduate School Is a Means to a Job

Graduate School Is a Means to a Job

I thought this was a pretty good article in The Chronicle; it gives some really good advice. It is geared more towards the humanities/social sciences so some of the advice applies more to those areas (e.g. going on the market while ABD... that seems to be much more common in these fields). But most of the advice can be applied to all different disciplines.

Introduction

Hi everyone! I'm new to LJ and this community so thought I'd try introducing myself. I'm working towards a PhD with a major in English philology. I study social action online, more specifically online communities and how a sense of community is created online. I've been registered as a post-graduate student since spring 2010 but I only recently received my first grant so my work has not progressed very far yet. The grant is only small but I do now have an office at university and the opportunity to spend about 60% of my time on the PhD (I work elsewhere for the other 40%), at least for a few months, so I'm hoping to make good progress in order to convince those authorities that I'm a worth investment and should be given more grants!

It's been a long road to get to this point, and I've really struggled to get to grips on what PhD work is all about (since we don't have a lot of highly structured PhD programmes here). In the past month I've figured out that the most important ingredients for PhD success are:
a) the ability to break your project down to small pieces, and then break it down some more;
b) the ability to let go of control over the whole project; it will all come together in the end; and
c) community, i.e. the fellowship of others in the same boat as you.

The last point is especially important, since it's something I didn't have until recently. Being at university close to full-time helps, but more than anything I'm thankful that a good friend of mine has also started working on a PhD, and has become a major source of advice and comfort in helping me understand that my problems are not unique. The best form of stress-relief to me is having a cup of tea and a chat about our respective projects. Writing a PhD may be independent work but never discount the importance of sharing the experience with others doing the same! I wonder if anyone else has had similar problems of feeling aimless/not knowing how to structure your studies?

Have you ever done a "Directed/Independent Study"?

I have a day or so before I have to sign off to do one.  I need advice.  If you've done one, do you recommend it? Is it worthwhile? The only thing I know about it is that I get to pick 5 to 6 books to read and then I have to write a final paper that ties them all together.  These books all deal with my topic for my thesis.  I'd rather take an actual class, however there aren't a lot of interesting classes offered this term. Yay or Nay? Thanks!

Religion Major

I'm hoping you all can give me some advice as I seem to be in a bit of a bind. I'm a religion major and had always wanted to teach at the University level. I have my Master's and I am into my 3rd year of a PhD program. I'm at the point where I don't want to continue! It's not that I'm doing poorly it's more because jobs are almost impossible to come by and I really believe that all this effort is a waste of time, money, and effort. The big question I have is what do I do now? I have nothing to put on my resume except years of schooling - no real job experience. What type of job can I realistically think about applying for? Any ideas?

PhD programs in Communication?

I'm about halfway through my master's program (I'm on the 3 year plan, so about a year and a half left to go), and I'm toying with the idea of getting my PhD. I'd want to take a break of at least 1-2 years before starting, partially because I'm 24 now and have more or less been in school my entire life, and also because it'd be nice to bring some more general life/work experiences with me into the program. Since I'm still turning the idea over in my mind, I haven't really started looking for programs or anything, but... how would I go about doing this?

I'm feeling pretty intimidated right now. Finding a program, taking the GMAT, applying to said program(s), etc. all seems like a really daunting task. Are there any websites that sort of walk you through it, where you can plug in the field you're interested in and it makes suggestions based on that? Alternately, does anyone have any recommendations for PhD programs in the communication field? I'd probably want to stay in MA or at least New England, but right now I just kind of want to get a feel for what's available to me before I even attempt to narrow it down.

x-posted to applyingtograd
Pascal

Random Series of Questions...

I posted these in my own journal too, but I'm thinking that I need more answers than I'll get from just my Friends list. Apologies for the randomness, these made sense in the context of the post that I made (about my goals for my 2nd year of my PhD in terms of organization and time management), but might seem unconnected as I'm going to post them here:

1) How do you create your daily routine (waking up, going to sleep, working out, etc.)? How much do you follow your body's natural routine, and how much do you force it to conform to what you need it to do?

2) I have Verizon Wireless now and I'm up for a new phone. I'd like to get a smartphone that can sync with Google calendar--will be playing with my sister's Droid when I see her in a week or so to see if I like that. But, any other suggestions of phones I should look at?

3) Any recommendations for a good, affordable printer I can have at home that won't break the bank in terms of ink costs? I have an old HP Deskjet right now, but it doesn't seem to function properly with the newest versions of Windows for some reason, but I'd like something that can do bigger jobs than this really can handle. (Printer related fun that always makes me laugh.)

getting grad degrees in unrelated fields

I'd like to hear from people who have switched into other fields after getting one postgrad degree. I'll be finishing my humanities MA in a concurrent program next year, but I've known for some time that I don't want to do a PhD in this field. I was planning on writing an MA thesis (you can do a nonthesis option also), but now I'm reconsidering that as well since my main motivation before was looking good to PhD schools within my current field. I'm kind of scraping to stick out the MA even, knowing I really don't want to go into a career in this field anymore.

I have a pretty good GPA right now but I suspect my grades from this spring will hurt it a little. I guess I'm wondering mainly:
a) if I don't write a thesis and later want to do an MA/PhD in a sort-of related or totally unrelated field, will this really hurt my chances?

b) If my GPA is just 'good' or they see that my grades slipped a bit towards the end of my program, will this really hurt my chances of getting in somewhere else for a different field? The grade slippage is partly from being disillusioned with the field, but also from other issues gong on. (By slip I mean getting B's instead of A's, so not totally failing, but still a big deal)

c)Are advisers/profs still generally willing to write you rec letters if you leave the field? What is the best way to kindly break that you're not going to do the PhD? (Am I naive to think they will even care?)

FWIW, I'm thinking if I do pursue another postgrad degree it will be something like public policy with more outside-academia applications.
gfp mouse

Choosing a mentor

I'm a first-year PhD student in neuroscience. At my program, students come in without a mentor and do three lab rotations before choosing a "home" for their dissertation research. I'm on my third rotation now, and hope to finish and pick a lab in the next month or so. I'm having the somewhat pleasant problem of not knowing which lab to choose, because I like two of them.

Collapse )