I doubt that anyone who reads my journal is unaware of the hideous privacy nightmare that is Google Buzz. But I just found out about another, less headline-grabbing story of Google's problems.
After
Dreamwidth got targeted by (a group presumed to be) Warriors for Innocence, PayPal requested that DW "remove entries on [their] service that contain nothing but constitutionally and legally protected speech that is not against [the DW] Terms of Service".
As I've previously written, Dreamwidth did the right thing, and told PayPal they were taking their business elsewhere.
Apparently they took their business to Google Checkout. And
the puritanical group attacking Dreamwidth went to Google and complained, and Dreamwidth says that Google has "decided to terminate our business relationship unless we alter our Terms of Service to
prohibit all adult content." (emphasis mine)
The lovely thing about Google's "Don't be evil" motto is that it never says you actively have to be good. But I'm not sure that this move meets even that low, low bar. Let's be clear: Google has told a group that's actively working to promote free speech that it must ban all adult content on its service in order to keep doing business with Google.
This is certainly within Google's rights; I'm not saying they have to do business with anyone they don't want to. But muzzling people's right to discuss adult topics? It's pretty damn close to evil. Remember that "adult topics/content" doesn't just mean slashfic or porn — it also means: discussions of rape, including survivor groups; promotion of equal rights for sexual minorities; spreading and discussing safer-sex information...
Keeping this information hidden doesn't make a better world. It makes things worse, for everyone. And how is making the world worse "not evil"?
If Google doesn't want to do business with Dreamwidth, I don't really want to do business with them. I'll continue to use their free services, like search and maps... but please don't bother sending email to my (ad-supported) Gmail account any more. It's going to vanish shortly.
I welcome discussion of which other services of theirs would be appropriate, or inappropriate, to keep using. I also welcome pointers to alternative services. And I would
love to help welcome any of you to Dreamwidth — let me know if you want an invite code.
This entry is public; you may link to it freely.