When people learn the wrong lessons
May. 19th, 2026 07:47 amThis article from the Verge about a "nightmare roomate" seems to be a little smug about how unrealistic and naive progressive policies are, but it's mostly a tale about a very rich and privileged person who is themselves unrealistic and naive, and seems to have never learned about how people like her ex-roommate operate.
You should "believe women" but people in law enforcement shouldn't take sides without ample evidence. However, they will, because taking sides is what people do. The law definitely shouldn't "believe women" in court; evidence is required. I can't say if progressives are generally more naive than people on any other end of a political spectrum. But the saying "trust, but verify" comes to mind. Her mistake was not making this woman sign a lease and also not doing a background check. Her next mistake was not trusting her gut.
Abusers will figure out how to use any law no matter who it is supposed to protect. I've seen it before, and I'm sure I'll see it again, but this woman is a classic case of somebody who is probably a narcissist, and who is incapable of meeting her own basic needs (partly because she's an alcoholic), so she cons people into meeting them for her. She was likely abused as a child, learning from a parent how to find conflict-avoidant, easily manipulated bleeding hearts that can be bullied (or seduced) into providing the shelter, food, clothing, and probably money that she is basically incapable of securing for herself. The law simply is not set up to uncover liars, and I think that when laws are enacted, recourse is almost an afterthought if it's there at all. What is needed is harsh, or harsher punishment for this type of fraud, and the punishment should parallel the level of problems that your lie got the other person into.
Even better, we need to be better at recognizing the signs of, and stopping child abuse and neglect. This woman didn't turn out awful all by herself and what she needs - once she's been stopped from perpetrating her abuse cycle on others - is addiction treatment and mental health care.
Edit: After I posted this, it occurred to me, given what Mollisson's boyfriend said "she's going to be here a long time," how the boyfriend seemed to be enabling her behavior, and also how Mollisson spent a lot of time drunk and doing drugs, I think it is quite possible that this "boyfriend" might have gotten her addicted and may even have been pimping her. I wish they would have investigated Mollisson's story more, or reported more on the relationship between her and the boyfriend.
Lots of people wind up with shitty, shitty tenants who have become experts in exploiting the law to their own advantage, no matter what political atmosphere it was passed in. My father, a good Christian veteran who lives in a rural town in a red state, had tenants who destroyed his rental house so bad he had to take it down to the framing to get it rentable again. These tenants were literally on an episode of Jerry Springer. They didn't pay rent for months. He had to get the sheriff to kick them out. He didn't question his Christian faith or politics because he had shitty tenants though.