Archiving this here as well. I have been planning to write a proper, coherent rebuttal to all the most frustrating excuses people give for hating Juliette, but that will have to keep sitting on the backburner for now. To be clear, I have no problem with people disliking Juliette. My buddy
recrudescence hates her face pretty literally, and I have no beef with that. What I have a beef with is people presenting "reasons" for hating her that actually make no sense/are completely unfair to the canon. Such as this:
I Strongly dislike Juliette. There, I said it.I dislike her for one reason, and one only:
BITCH CAN’T MAKE UP HER MIND

Gif 1= Exhibit A. She clearly knows something is up. She is smart enough to connect the dots. What is her conclusion? Perhaps those fairytales are real! Cool, Juliette is on the same wavelenght as Nick right?
Wrong

Gif 2= Exhibit B. Nick has just told her fairytales are real! You’d think she’d understand given the fact she JUST TOLD NICK THAT EXACT THING. Nope, she decides to flip out on her boyfriend she ‘loves soooo much, but doesn’t want to marry because hes being sheltered’. First she wants the truth, then she doesn’t. She believes in the supernatural, then she doesn’t. This drives me insane.
I have a lot of problems with this take on the situation. I’m on heavy meds rn for my chest infection BUT I CAN’T HANDLE THE RAGE I HAVE HERE so I’m going to try to be coherent anyway.
There is a very, very big difference between having a weird passing moment where you think something totally crazy and voice it to somebody you trust, and having that person behave in a way that, to all intents and purposes, is fucking insane. There’s a massive difference between, “HEY MAYBE FAIRY TALE CREATURES ARE REAL” and ”LOOK AT MY MURDER TRAILER I PROMISE I’M NOT CRAZY EVEN THOUGH I AM TELLING YOU I KILL THINGS YOU CANT SEE THAT LOOK LIKE NORMAL HUMANS TO YOU”.
Juliette was super mature when she told Nick they can’t get married yet. I love how communicative and strong and
adult their relationship is. She loves him, and knows he loves her, but it’s true they need to sort out this wall between them first.
Nick knows that too, and it’s obvious throughout the eps that not being able to be honest with Juliette is really hurting him. He wants to tell her, but it’s true… he’ll sound insane. Think about it, honestly: your partner tells you right now that they can see fairytale creatures and sometimes they have to kill the bad ones. Of course you’d be freaked out. Of course you wouldn’t just be oh okay awesome honey thanks for sharing.
As much as it broke my fucking heart, Juliette’s reaction in the finale is completely real and justified. You can see it on her face as Nick gets more and more animated in the trailer… she’s thinking, oh god, the man I love really has lost his mind.
Despite this very understandable reaction, she gets back in the car with him, which on its own speaks to how much she trusts and loves him despite what he has just told her. Think honestly again: if your partner just told you he kills evil things with human faces, while showing you their secret trailer of weapons, how would you feel? Would you feel safe getting into a car with them?
But Juliette does. Juliette goes with him to see Monroe, to give him a chance, and it’s obvious in that scene that her initial tearful, distraught response has evolved into something else. She’s calmer. She’s angry and confused and worried about her partner, who she loves and wants to marry.

Well DUHUnfortunately, she doesn’t get a chance to calm down from the shock of what has just happened. She doesn’t get a chance to listen to and see Monroe, to go talk to Rosalee, to come to terms with this impossible, insane, crazy thing she has just been told. But it seems obvious that she would get there just fine, if given a chance. She does want the truth, but the truth in this case is a very difficult complex thing to swallow, so of course it is going to take a little time.
Her reaction in the heat of the moment was completely understandable and realistic, and I side-eye the fuck out of anyone who suggests that it makes her a bitch, or indecisive.
ETA: I also think the whole thing would have gone far, far better if it had been done calmly, in a planned out way that capitalised on the fact that yes, Juliette HAS seen things she can’t explain. But it wasn’t. It was rushed and unplanned and Nick was worried and angry and boiled over with all his own feelings and frustrations, his intense fear and how much he hates having to put that wall between them to begin with, and it all coalesced into a gross situation that really couldn’t have expected any other reaction from Juliette.
This entry was originally posted at http://cthonical.dreamwidth.org/10…