Login
Critical Consensus: Oscar Best Picture 2000s
Sort by:
Showing 19 items
Decade:
Rating:
List Type:
Add items to section
2009
4921
8
8.3
Up (2009)
#1
IMDb- 83%
Listal- 81%
Metacritic- Critics: 88%, Users: 88%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 98%, Users: 90%
Overall Score- 88%
BradWesley123's rating:
2209
7.3
7.5
The Hurt Locker (2008)
#2 (**WINNER**)
IMDb- 76%
Listal- 73%
Metacritic- Critics: 94%, Users: 73%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 98%, Users: 84%
Overall Score- 83%
BradWesley123's rating:
3218
7.5
7.9
District 9 (2009)
#3
IMDb- 80%
Listal- 75%
Metacritic- Critics: 81%, Users: 81%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 90%, Users: 82%
Overall Score- 82%
BradWesley123's rating:
5538
8
8.4
Inglourious Basterds (2009)
#4
IMDb- 83%
Listal- 80%
Metacritic- Critics: 69%, Users: 77%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 89%, Users: 87%
Overall Score- 81%
BradWesley123's rating:
5596
7.1
7.9
Avatar (2009)
#5 (Tie)
IMDb- 79%
Listal- 71%
Metacritic- Critics: 83%, Users: 75%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 83%, Users: 82%
Overall Score- 79%
BradWesley123's rating:
1361
6.9
7.3
Precious (2009)
#5 (Tie)
IMDb- 74%
Listal- 70%
Metacritic- Critics: 79%, Users: 80%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 91%, Users: 81%
Overall Score- 79%
2164
7.2
7.4
Up in the Air (2009)
#5 (Tie)
IMDb- 75%
Listal- 72%
Metacritic- Critics: 83%, Users: 74%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 91%, Users: 79%
Overall Score- 79%
BradWesley123's rating:
1435
7.1
7.2
An Education (2009)
6. An Education
IMDb- 73%
Listal- 72%
Metacritic- Critics: 85%, Users: 80%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 94%, Users: 78%
Overall Score- 80%
BradWesley123's rating:
1405
6.9
7
A Serious Man (2009)
9. A Serious Man
IMDb- 70%
Listal- 69%
Metacritic- Critics: 79%, Users: 65%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 89%, Users: 65%
Overall Score- 73%
BradWesley123's rating:
1591
7.2
7.6
The Blind Side (2009)
#10
IMDb- 77%
Listal- 73%
Metacritic- Critics: 53%, Users: 70%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 66%, Users: 85%
Overall Score- 71%
BradWesley123's rating:
Add items to section
2008
4044
7.5
8
Slumdog Millionaire (2008)
1. Slumdog Millionaire (**WINNER**)
IMDb- 81%
Listal- 75%
Metacritic- Critics: 86%, Users: 78%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 94%, Users: 90%
Overall Score- 84%
2. Milk
IMDb- 77%
Listal- 76%
Metacritic- Critics: 84%, Users: 76%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 94%, Users: 88%
Overall Score- 82%
3. Frost/Nixon
IMDb- 78%
Listal- 75%
Metacritic- Critics: 80%, Users: 78%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 92%, Users: 86%
Overall Score- 81%
4. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
IMDb- 78%
Listal- 475%
Metacritic- Critics: 70%, Users: 70%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 73%, Users: 81%
Overall Score- 74%
5. The Reader
IMDb- 76%
Listal- 75%
Metacritic- Critics: 58%, Users: 74%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 61%, Users: 78%
Overall Score- 70%
2008 Combined Total: 78%
BradWesley123's rating:
Add items to section
2007
4194
7.9
8.2
No Country for Old Men (2007)
1. No Country for Old Men (**WINNER**)(Tie)
IMDb- 82%
Listal- 79%
Metacritic- Critics: 91%, Users: 72%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 95%, Users: 84%
Overall Score- 84%
1. There Will Be Blood (Tie)
IMDb- 81%
Listal- 81%
Metacritic- Critics: 92%, Users: 75%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 91%, Users: 84%
Overall Score- 84%
3. Juno
IMDb- 77%
Listal- 73%
Metacritic- Critics: 81%, Users: 84%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 94%, Users: 89%
Overall Score- 83%
4. Atonement
IMDb- 78%
Listal- 76%
Metacritic- Critics: 85%, Users: 75%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 83%, Users: 79%
Overall Score- 79%
5. Michael Clayton
IMDb- 74%
Listal- 68%
Metacritic- Critics: 82%, Users: 72%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 90%, Users: 72%
Overall Score- 76%
2007 Combined Total: 82%
BradWesley123's rating:
Add items to section
2006
5326
8
8.5
The Departed (2006)
1. The Departed (**WINNER**)
IMDb- 85%
Listal- 80%
Metacritic- Critics: 86%, Users: 81%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 93%, Users: 92%
Overall Score- 86%
2. Letters from Iwo Jima
IMDb- 80%
Listal- 75%
Metacritic- Critics: 89%, Users: 83%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 91%, Users: 85%
Overall Score- 84%
3. Little Miss Sunshine
IMDb- 79%
Listal- 76%
Metacritic- Critics: 80%, Users: 76%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 91%, Users: 90%
Overall Score- 82%
4. The Queen
IMDb- 74%
Listal- 70%
Metacritic- Critics: 91%, Users: 64%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 97%, Users: 74%
Overall Score- 78%
5. Babel
IMDb- 75%
Listal- 72%
Metacritic- Critics: 69%, Users: 57%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 69%, Users: 76%
Overall Score- 70%
2006 Combined Total: 80%
BradWesley123's rating:
Add items to section
2005
3236
7.2
7.7
Crash (2004)
1. Brokeback Mountain
IMDb- 77%
Listal- 73%
Metacritic- Critics: 87%, Users: 82%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 87%, Users: 77%
Overall Score- 80%
2. Capote
IMDb- 69%
Listal- 74%
Metacritic- Critics: 88%, Users: 78%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 90%, Users: 73%
Overall Score- 79%
3. Good Night, and Good Luck
IMDb- 76%
Listal- 71%
Metacritic- Critics: 80%, Users: 75%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 93%, Users: 73%
Overall Score- 78%
4. Crash(**WINNER**)
IMDb- 79%
Listal- 73%
Metacritic- Critics: 69%, Users: 79%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 76%, Users: 89%
Overall Score- 77%
5. Munich
IMDb- 77%
Listal- 72%
Metacritic- Critics: 74%, Users: 72%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 78%, Users: 78%
Overall Score- 75%
2005 Combined Total: 78%
BradWesley123's rating:
Add items to section
2004
3961
7.6
8.1
Million Dollar Baby (2005)
1. Million Dollar Baby(**WINNER**)
IMDb- 81%
Listal- 76%
Metacritic- Critics: 86%, Users: 79%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 92%, Users: 87%
Overall Score- 83%
2. Ray (Tie)
IMDb- 77%
Listal- 72%
Metacritic- Critics: 73%, Users: 85%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 81%, Users: 87%
Overall Score- 79%
3. Sideways (Tie)
IMDb- 76%
Listal- 69%
Metacritic- Critics: 94%, Users: 64%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 96%, Users: 77%
Overall Score- 79%
4. Finding Neverland
IMDb- 78%
Listal- 73%
Metacritic- Critics: 67%, Users: 83%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 83%, Users: 84%
Overall Score- 78%
5. The Aviator
IMDb- 75%
Listal- 69%
Metacritic- Critics: 77%, Users: 72%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 87%, Users: 73%
Overall Score- 75%
2004 Combined Total: 79%
BradWesley123's rating:
Add items to section
2003
9095
8.2
8.9
1. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King(**WINNER**)
IMDb- 89%
Listal- 82%
Metacritic- Critics: 94%, Users: 89%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 94%, Users: 83%
Overall Score- 88%
2. Lost in Translation
IMDb- 78%
Listal- 74%
Metacritic- Critics: 89%, Users: 68%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 95%, Users: 84%
Overall Score- 81%
3. Mystic River
IMDb- 80%
Listal- 76%
Metacritic- Critics: 84%, Users: 62%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 87%, Users: 86%
Overall Score- 79%
4. Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World
IMDb- 74%
Listal- 68%
Metacritic- Critics: 81%, Users: 58%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 85%, Users: 75%
Overall Score- 73%
5. Seabiscuit
IMDb- 73%
Listal- 63%
Metacritic- Critics: 72%, Users: 73%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 77%, Users: 74%
Overall Score- 75%
2003 Combined Total: 79%
BradWesley123's rating:
Add items to section
2002
2547
6.8
7.2
Chicago (2002)
1. The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers
IMDb- 87%
Listal- 80%
Metacritic- Critics: 88%, Users: 90%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 96%, Users: 92%
Overall Score- 89%
2. The Pianist
IMDb- 85%
Listal- 82%
Metacritic- Critics: 85%, Users: 87%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 96%, Users: 94%
Overall Score- 88%
3. The Hours
IMDb- 75%
Listal- 73%
Metacritic- Critics: 81%, Users: 86%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 81%, Users: 82%
Overall Score- 80%
4. Chicago(**WINNER**)
IMDb- 71%
Listal- 67%
Metacritic- Critics: 82%, Users: 78%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 87%, Users: 80%
Overall Score- 77%
5. Gangs of New York
IMDb- 75%
Listal- 70%
Metacritic- Critics: 72%, Users: 72%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 75%, Users: 76%
Overall Score- 73%
2002 Combined Total: 81%
BradWesley123's rating:
Add items to section
2001
4877
7.6
8.2
A Beautiful Mind (2001)
1. The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
IMDb- 88%
Listal- 80%
Metacritic- Critics: 92%, Users: 88%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 92%, Users: 92%
Overall Score- 89%
2. In the Bedroom
IMDb- 74%
Listal- 68%
Metacritic- Critics: 86%, Users: 75%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 93%, Users: 78%
Overall Score- 81%
3. A Beautiful Mind(**WINNER**)
IMDb- 81%
Listal- 75%
Metacritic- Critics: 72%, Users: 75%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 78%, Users: 91%
Overall Score- 79%
4. Moulin Rouge!
IMDb- 76%
Listal- 73%
Metacritic- Critics: 66%, Users: 88%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 76%, Users: 88%
Overall Score- 78%
5. Gosford Park
IMDb- 73%
Listal- 70%
Metacritic- Critics: 90%, Users: 64%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 86%, Users: 75%
Overall Score- 76%
2001 Combined Total: 81%
BradWesley123's rating:
Add items to section
2000
6709
7.8
8.5
Gladiator (2000)
1. Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
IMDb- 79%
Listal- 73%
Metacritic- Critics: 93%, Users: 72%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 97%, Users: 81%
Overall Score- 82%
2. Traffic
IMDb- 77%
Listal- 70%
Metacritic- Critics: 86%, Users: 80%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 92%, Users: 81%
Overall Score- 81%
3. Gladiator(**WINNER**)
IMDb- 85%
Listal- 77%
Metacritic- Critics: 64%, Users: 87%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 78%, Users: 85%
Overall Score- 79%
4. Erin Brokovich
IMDb- 72%
Listal- 67%
Metacritic- Critics: 73%, Users: 78%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 84%, Users: 76%
Overall Score- 78%
5. Chocolat
IMDb- 73%
Listal- 70%
Metacritic- Critics: 64%, Users: 73%
Rotten Tomatoes- Critics: 63%, Users: 82%
Overall Score- 71%
2000 Combined Total: 78%
BradWesley123's rating:
In keeping with my Oscar
motif, I present this list. Taking scores from Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, IMDb, and our very own Listal, I rank the films that are and have been nominated for the Academy Award for Best Picture.
motif, I present this list. Taking scores from Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, IMDb, and our very own Listal, I rank the films that are and have been nominated for the Academy Award for Best Picture.
Added to
RSS FeedPeople who voted for this also voted for
5-Star Quality Television
Top 20 Best Simpsons Episodes
Best Games of 2014
Dramas That Were Axed Too Soon
the giraffe vs. Marilyn Manson
The 100 best games of all time - Gamesradar
Great Soundtracks/Scores
My Favourite Movies
Albums Listened to in 2014
Norway
Meryl Streep's Best Actress Nominations
My favourites romantic movies
If the World doesn't end, i'll watch in 2013
Romantic Comedies
1999 The Movies
Academy Award for Best Makeup: 2000s
BradWesley123's Movie Journal- June 2009
30 Days, 30 Shows
BradWesley123’s Television Journal- May 2018
BradWesley123’s Television Journal- November 2020
BradWesley123’s Television Journal- October 2020
BradWesley123's Movie Journal- November 2012
