Captain Beefheart And His Magic Band*Safe As Milk

Genre:

Rock, Blues

Style:

Rhythm & Blues, Garage Rock, Psychedelic Rock, Blues Rock

Year:

Tracklist

Sure 'Nuff 'N Yes I Do2:15
Zig Zag Wanderer2:40
Call On Me2:37
Dropout Boogie2:32
I'm Glad3:31
Electricity3:07
Yellow Brick Road2:28
Abba Zaba2:44
Plastic Factory3:08
Where There's Woman2:09
Grown So Ugly2:27
Autumn's Child4:02

Notes

The making of Safe As Milk, the debut album of Captain Beefheart And His Magic Band, is a long and convoluted story, revealed at length elsewhere upon the Web and in written accounts. However, some rudimentary details are worth having here for those wishing to submit.

Early US issues had red labels, followed by 'kaleidoscope' labels, then later black labels (under Arista). For some stereo issues a foil 'stereo' sticker was applied to mono sleeves. First inner liners had a photo-montage & loose sticker.

The band recorded in the Spring of 1967 at Sunset Sound Studios, later for the finished work at RCA Studios, Hollywood, C.A., USA.
The band members were:
Don Van Vliet, aka Captain Beefheart, publishing in his real name and performing by his alias. (Vocals, Harmonica & Bass Marimba).
Alex Snouffer, aka Alex St. Clair, also known as Alexis St. Clare Snouffer. (Guitar).
Jerry Handley (Bass Guitar).
John French, aka John 'Drumbo' French or simply Drumbo. (Drums & Percussion).
Ry Cooder (Guitar, Slide Guitar & Bass Guitar) [A subsequently disaffected member & not appearing in photos].
Session or Guest Musicians [that are known. Others were present]:
Taj Mahal (Percussion), Russ Titelman (Guitar), Milt Holland (Log Drums & Percussion), Dr. Samuel J. Hoffman aka Sam Hoffman (Theremin).

Vliet wrote all of the songs, with the exception of Grown So Ugly, by Robert Pete Williams. Herb Bermann (Lancaster resident & soul-mate at the time) co-wrote the lyrics with Vliet on all songs - with the exception of the aforesaid and; Call On Me, I'm Glad and Abba Zaba. Jerry Handley co-wrote Plastic Factory with Vliet & Bermann. Cooder arranged Sure 'Nuff 'N Yes I Do & Ugly, Vliet arranged the remainder.

At this time, in 1967, 'Kama Sutra' records had a distribution deal with MGM. Meanwhile a Verve 3000 series catalog was allocated for Beefheart (FTS 3054), but not used because Vliet had signed with Kama Sutra after failing to be picked up by A&M. To extricate from MGM, Kama Sutra had created Buddah Records late in 1967, headed by Neil Bogart. Thus, Vliet & the band were recording for Buddah, although signed to Kama Sutra and Kama Sutra is shown on international releases. Bob Krasnow and Richard Perry produced the sessions. Some engineering was done by future TMR bassist Gary Marker*, then Hank Cicalo at RCA. This is the first mono & stereo album on the Buddah label, later celebrated by the reissue on BMG's new-look & retitled Buddha in 1999.

After "Safe As Milk" the band line-up was in flux. When they re-entered a recording studio in October 1967, for what was to be a double album "It Comes To You In A Plain Brown Wrapper", the project met various problems. Tracks from sessions surfaced on Beefheart's 2nd "Strictly Personal" & 5th "Mirror Man" albums, among other releases. Consequently, some of the recordings from these sessions appear later, issued as 'bonus' tracks on "Safe As Milk" releases**.

The album's working title was "Abba Zaba", after the American candy bar of Cardinet Candy Co., in a yellow/black checkered wrapper (hence the back cover design). See; Abba Zaba. However, the company vetoed use of the name and a title that was as 'safe as milk' was used. (A track titled "Safe As Milk" can be found on "Strictly Personal").

*Marker engineered at Sunset Sound, as he describes in the 'Grow Fins' set.
**These are technically 'Compilation' releases, as indicated thereon by reissue distributors BMG [for example]. Being compiled by 3rd parties from 2 different recording sources and significantly remastered without control by the artists.

Versions

Filter by
    120 versions
    Image, In Your Collection, Wantlist, or Inventory
    Version DetailsData Quality
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967-08-00, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Mono, Red Label
    Buddah Records – BDM 1001US1967US1967
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Mono, Promo
    Buddah Records – BDM 1001US1967US1967
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Test Pressing
    Buddah Records – BDS 5001US1967US1967
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Promo, Stereo, White Labels
    Buddah Records – BDS 5001US1967US1967
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967-08-00, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Stereo, Red Label
    Buddah Records – BDS 5001US1967US1967
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967-08-00, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Stereo, Red Label
    Buddah Records – BDS 5001US1967US1967
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967-08-00, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Mono, Red Label
    Buddah Records – BDM 1001US1967US1967
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967-08-00, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Stereo, Santa Maria Pressing
    Buddah Records – BDS 5001US1967US1967
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967, 4-Track CartridgeSafe As Milk
    4-Track Cartridge, Album, Stereo
    Buddah Records – F-1-5001US1967US1967
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967, 8-Track CartridgeSafe As Milk
    8-Track Cartridge, Album, Stereo
    Buddah Records – L-1-5001US1967US1967
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Mono, Promo
    Buddah Records – BDM 1001US1967US1967
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967, AcetateSafe As Milk
    Acetate, LP, 33 ⅓ RPM, Album, Mono
    RCA Custom Records – U3RM-5547, Radio Corporation Of America – U2RM-5448, Kama Sutra – BDL-1001US1967US1967
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1967, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Stereo, Pitman Pressing
    Buddah Records – BDS 5001US1967US1967
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1968, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Mono
    Astor – PLP 1249Australia1968Australia1968
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1968, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Stereo
    Astor – SPLP 1249Australia1968Australia1968
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1968-02-00, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Mono
    PYE International – NPL 28110, Pye International – NPL.28110UK1968UK1968
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1968, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album
    Buddah Records – HBDS 5001Netherlands1968Netherlands1968
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1968, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Stereo
    Buddah Records – 203 009Germany1968Germany1968
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1968, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Promo, Stereo
    Buddah Records – 203 009Germany1968Germany1968
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1968, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Mispress, Stereo, Mono
    Astor – PLP 1249, Astor – SPLP 1249Australia1968Australia1968
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1968, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Stereo
    Buddah Records – BDS 5001, Buddah Records – 203 009Germany1968Germany1968
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1968, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Mispress, Stereo
    Astor – SPLP 1249Australia1968Australia1968
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1968-02-02, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Test Pressing, White Label
    Pye Records – NPL 28110UK1968UK1968
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1968, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Repress, Stereo
    Buddah Records – BDS 5001US1968US1968
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1969-03-00, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Mono
    Marble Arch – MAL 1117, Pye International – MAL 1117UK1969UK1969
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1969, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album
    Buddah Records – 921024, Buddah Records – BDS 5001France1969France1969
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Dropout Boogie, 1970, VinylDropout Boogie
    LP, Album, Stereo, Reissue
    Buddah Records – 2349 002UK1970UK1970
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1970, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Reissue
    Buddah Records – BDS 5063US1970US1970
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Plastic Factory, 1970, VinylPlastic Factory
    LP, Album, Reissue
    Buddah Records – 2318 014Germany1970Germany1970
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1970, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Reissue, Kaleidoscope Label
    Buddah Records – 60017France1970France1970
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Dropout Boogie, 1970, VinylDropout Boogie
    LP, Album, Stereo, Reissue, Mispress
    Buddah Records – 2349 002UK1970UK1970
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1970, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Reissue, Promo
    Buddah Records – BDS 5063US1970US1970
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1970, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Reissue, ARP Pressing
    Buddah Records – BDS 5063US1970US1970
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1970, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Reissue, Stereo
    Buddah Records – 2318 056New Zealand1970New Zealand1970
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1970, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Reissue, Sonic Pressing
    Buddah Records – BDS 5063US1970US1970
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1970, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Promo, Reissue, Stereo
    Buddah Records – BDS 5063US1970US1970
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1970, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Reissue, ARP Pressing
    Buddah Records – BDS 5063US1970US1970
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1970, VinylSafe As Milk
    LP, Album, Reissue, Stereo, Monarch Pressing
    Buddah Records – BDS 5063US1970US1970
    Recently Edited
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1970, 8-Track CartridgeSafe As Milk
    8-Track Cartridge, Album, Stereo
    Buddah Records – BDS 5063US1970US1970
    New Submission
    Cover of Safe As Milk, 1970, CassetteSafe As Milk
    Cassette, Album, Reissue
    Buddah Records – M 55063US1970US1970
    New Submission

    Recommendations

    • Neil Young - Harvest
      Harvest
      1972 US
      Vinyl —
      LP, Album, Stereo
      Shop
    • Frank Zappa - Hot Rats
      Hot Rats
      1969 US
      Vinyl —
      LP, Album, Stereo
      Shop
    • Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young - Déjà Vu
      Déjà Vu
      1970 US
      Vinyl —
      LP, Album, Stereo
      Shop
    • David Bowie - The Rise And Fall Of Ziggy Stardust And The Spiders From Mars
      The Rise And Fall Of Ziggy Stardust And The Spiders From Mars
      1972 UK
      Vinyl —
      LP, Album, Stereo
      Shop
    • Love - Forever Changes
      Forever Changes
      1967 US
      Vinyl —
      LP, Album, Stereo
      Shop
    • Talking Heads - Talking Heads: 77
      Talking Heads: 77
      1977 US
      Vinyl —
      LP, Album
      Shop
    • The Velvet Underground - White Light/White Heat
      White Light/White Heat
      1968 US
      Vinyl —
      LP, Album, Stereo
      Shop
    • The Mothers - We're Only In It For The Money
      We're Only In It For The Money
      1968 US
      Vinyl —
      LP, Album, Stereo
      Shop
    • Miles Davis - Bitches Brew
      Bitches Brew
      1970 US
      Vinyl —
      LP, Album, Stereo
      Shop
    • The Beatles - Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
      Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
      1967 UK
      Vinyl —
      LP, Album, Mono
      Shop

    Reviews

    • jiricervenka's avatar
      jiricervenka
      The pressing is basically excellent, the records are almost flat, except for a few cracks they play cleanly, without distortion (washed out). The sound is perfect. The cover and insert are of good quality.
      Very original and great album, the bonus LP expands the experience.
      I recommend it. Have fun...

      Played on:
      Technics SL-100C, Ortofon Concorde Music Bronze, Supra Phono 2RCA-SC, Rega Fono MM MK5, Technics SU-G700M2, Yamaha NS-777, Vinyl Cleaner Pro-Ject VC-E
      • iggypopsjacket's avatar
        Another winner from Music on Vinyl. This sounds like it should do imo, fat bass, fuzzy guitars and great separation making for a sound that's both detailed and organic. Just wish someone could do a job like this with the 13th Floor Elevators albums.
        • HazzaMack's avatar
          HazzaMack
          Edited one month ago
          This is an album which has never sounded particularly good. It's become widely accepted that the original US stereo and mono pressings of this album are the way to go, which I would agree with having heard needledrops of both (which are my preferred digital versions). Almost every subsequent issue has had one problem or another, including the 1999 remaster which is overcompressed in my opinion, and the 2013 'mono' release which is a Frankenstein of a poor quality needledrop and a stereo folddown. This version sounds decent, but the soundstage is quite narrow (it nearly sounded mono to me) compared to the original stereo pressing, and is somewhat lacking in bass. I also noticed a substantial dropout near the end of Dropout Boogie (ironic?), but this pressing does not have the mastering fault on Abba Zaba that has been noted on other pressings. Not a terrible release overall. Oh, and the High Fidelity cameo is pretty neat!
          • windup-rob's avatar
            windup-rob
            Definitely stereo mix, listening to zigzag this moment. Lead vocal centre, gtr hard left drums hard right tambourine hard left etc etc.
            • Minimal-Man's avatar
              Minimal-Man
              G - R - E - A - T — R - E - C - O - R - D ! ! !
              • corpseliquor's avatar
                corpseliquor
                looking for an og stereo sleeve in VG+ or better condition; message me
                • Tracksonvinyl's avatar
                  Tracksonvinyl
                  The Australian 1968 pressing on Astor sounds great. Got the Stereo, have not heard a Mono of this pressing
                  • ClausRudolf's avatar
                    ClausRudolf
                    Edited 3 months ago
                    WOW. What a groovy record !

                    I know & love "Safe As Milk" since I was 14 years old ( over 4 decades ago ) and own a couple of different pressings; but this little bugger is a real BEAST ! Okay, I never owned an original MONO, but I guess this Sundazed offering captures the fat, rough and farty garage-feeling of that recording-session on the spot ! Yes, there's distortion - of course - it should be there !
                    I really don´t care about all that fuzz you find online about this pressing; people discussing what´s not "right" and what part/second is from different sources... I don't give a F... !
                    Those people don't listen to music, they just want to talk.... so let them talk, folks.
                    Buy that record, grab a bootle of cheap red wine ( cause you will need the money for that record ! ) and celebrate the genius of the Captain ! Cheers.

                    p.s. it's flat like the dessert - and hot like electricity !

                    "I´m glad" to own that record.
                    • dementian27's avatar
                      dementian27
                      Just picked up one of these with the bumper sticker. Is it true that the promos never came with the printed inner sleeve?
                      • bestlewh's avatar
                        bestlewh
                        Great album but terrible quality control for this particular pressing. Got my copy with a lot of pops and a massive defect on the first track.