Commisserating Joyfully - a BTVS fic
It had been a month since the battle, since Sunnydale ceased to exist and California gained a shiny new crater in the ground. A month since Anya died. Xander stared at the wall calendar, trying to let that sink in. She’d really been gone for a whole month.
“You coming back some day?” Willow asked. Her voice, or maybe it was her plopping down in the chair across from him and scooting the tiny cafe table a bit, pulled him from his reverie.
“What? Who?” He looked over and his brain finally caught up with his ears, “What? Coming back from where? I’m going somewhere?”
“Not that I know of, but you were certainly gone somewhere. You okay?”
“Oh. Yeah, I guess so. It’s just… I just realized it’s been a month…” He glanced at the calendar and back at Willow, “You know, since…”
“Since Spike dressed up like Liz Taylor and I went prematurely gray for a few minutes and we turned our hometown into a hole in the ground? Yeah, I guess it has, huh?”
“And since Anya… since I lost her.” His one good eye watered up just a little, and somewhere in the back of her mind Willow couldn’t help but wonder if there were still tear ducts under that eye patch. She pushed that thought aside, though. Xander needed her now.
“Yeah, since you lost Anya.” She reached across the table to offer what she hoped was a comforting touch on his arm.
“I think sometimes I’m so deep in the accepting that I don’t even think about it, and then sometimes I’m so covered in the denial that I keep waiting for her to show up complaining about how she risked her life to help us and we left her behind and why didn’t we wait so she could get on that stupid yellow bus with us.” He sighed and looked at the familiar collection of life-long friends and teenage girls scattered around the other tables in this coffee shop. “It’s like it’s hard to believe it’s really been a whole month, but at the same time, it’s hard to believe it’s only been a month, you know?”
“Oh yeah, I know. I was still barely speaking when that one-month date rolled around after Tara,” she glanced over at Kennedy but didn’t really see her. Willow wasn’t sure how deeply she felt for Kennedy, but she knew it was definitely not the same as Tara. “I was working with the coven, or rather, staying with them, under close supervision, and they were trying to get me to do some centering exercises and stuff, but since I wasn’t talking much, they hadn’t started the heavy training yet.”
Xander pulled his attention away from the now luke-warm coffee and the chatter around him. Willow hadn’t really talked about this much, and he wanted to know what that summer was like for her, and also hoped she could offer some way to ease the ache he felt now, since she’d been through it before.
“I went to breakfast one day and it seemed like just any other day but I knew something felt different. I finally saw the date on the morning paper and it clicked, which then made me drop the glass I was holding, which of course made a loud cracking and shattering noise as it hit the stone floor, which immediately sent me into a flashback and…” suddenly her casual, light-hearted demeanor changed and her eyes quickly filled with tears and her voice altered as evidence of the tightening in her throat. “I saw her again. For just a few minutes, I saw her again, standing there in our bedroom, smiling at me, just like she was that day. We’d had such a wonderful night and morning, I’d basically given up hope that we’d ever get back together and then suddenly we were and everything was perfect.”
Xander put his hand over Willow’s that was still on his arm, “Wil, look, you don’t….”
“No, it’s okay.” She sniffed a little and cleared her throat. “Everything was perfect, and she died knowing I loved her. And if my suspicions are correct, Anya died knowing you loved her, too.” He watched in amazement as Willow blinked away the threatening tears while all he wanted to do was cry a bucket of his own. “See, it all comes down to this. We’re just shells here. Our spirits, our essence, it’s not forever attached to these bodies, so when they died, they got to take that knowledge and that love with them. But also, we had these really special connections to them, so we kinda get to keep a little part of them with us forever.”
Xander shook his head. If only he could believe her. “I don’t feel like there’s any part of Anya here with me.”
“Sure there is. You have your memories of her. And you know, some people believe that when you share your memories of a loved one who’s died, you bring them to life just a little, or you draw them nearer because they can feel your love for them again.”
“But Wil, they’re just memories.”
“Have you ever noticed how a character, like say, Luke Skywalker, or Harry Potter, almost seems alive when the really big fans are talking about them a lot? It’s because our thoughts and energies give power to those creations. So many people love Luke and Harry that they’ve become real in a sense. And Anya was already real. So if you express your love, and you talk about her and share your memories, it will touch her, and she will touch you.”
“We’re not talking creepy zombie Anya knocking on the door with a Monkey Paw, are we? ‘Cuz, I miss her, but I’m not down with monkey paws.”
Willow smiled at him reassuringly. “No monkey paws. Honest.”
“I can almost hear Anya being irritated, questioning that literary reference, or maybe she’d misunderstand completely and start talking about actual spells or rituals that involve monkey paws.”
“Yeah. Remember when she and I accidentally let Olaf out of the hammer, after you and Tara tried to leave us to work out our issues? When Anya was being all particular and telling us we shouldn’t do magic at the store while Giles was away, I told her she was the fish from Cat in the Hat.”
“Oh, she totally was!” Xander smiled at the thought of it, and the many times Anya had adopted that role. “Oh, but she didn’t get it, right?”
“No, and it made her mad. I wasn’t trying to make her mad, honest… well, at least not with that part of it.” She smiled.
“Yeah, Tara told me you guys just seemed to be working on a bunch of misunderstandings and assumptions. You know, I never did tell you how grateful I was that you guys worked things out. Things were really uncomfortable there for a while, and man was I glad to see that over with.”
“Anya was not so bad as ex-vengeance demons go. And as much as I might not have understood it, she made you happy, which gave her points in my book.”
“Hey, I’m not the only one with relationships that make my friends go ‘huh?’ you know,” He always remembered when he finally realized Tara was one of the gang. “That birthday party for Tara at the Bronze? Buffy and I pondered for hours over what to get her, and weren’t sure if we’d fit in with the rest of the crowd there, and you know, for a while I even wondered if you’d end up losing interest in the Scoobies and go hang more with the mostly-girl crowd,” he paused, thinking about that for a moment. “You know, cuz you were interested in girls and you were a girl, er, uh, are a girl, and well, the Wiccan thing seems to be pretty heavily populated by the X chromosomes. But, uh, I guess it kinda worked out that way anyway, since I was pretty much the only guy around for a year or two there… at least until Spike and Andrew, and let me tell you how much of a comfort that isn’t.”
“So, you thought Tara would take me from the gang? Xander, you know…”
He scoffed at her. “Yeah, I know. I mean, I knew then, but I didn’t really know, you know?” She furrowed her brow and he just shook his head. “Anyway, I tried to figure out where Tara fit in, because she seemed so different from the rest of us and it was hard to know what she meant sometimes, or when she was joking, or if she even liked the rest of us. Then when her family came to visit, and we all realized they’d been lying to her, well, I realized a couple things then. One, was that she wouldn’t take you from the gang because you brought her to the gang, and we didn’t need to find a place for her to fit in because she was already in, and that she was part of the family just like you and Dawn and Buff and Giles.”
Willow smiled again. She had been so proud of her friends when they all stood their ground to show Tara they were on her side, and a little sad that Tara had been so surprised by that show of support. “What was the other thing you learned?”
“The second thing was that all the ways Tara was different were no weirder than the ways we were all different. When I really thought about it, Anya was like that, even for me – confusing sometimes, and hard to read. And you know, Angel had his moments of fitting in and not fitting, and so did Faith, and Oz was so quiet it took a while to figure him out… so really, We all have our little quirks, and you all accepted Anya’s and we all accepted Tara’s, and for that matter, everyone accepted mine and that’s really what’s so great about you guys.”
“And that’s what’s so great about you, too, Xander.” Buffy’s voice came unexpectedly from behind. Xander turned to look at her and reached for an extra chair. “Thanks,” she said as she joined them at the table. “So, is this triggered by the one-month thing?”
Xander smiled to himself. He shouldn’t have been surprised that Buffy knew him that well, but he supposed if the surprise went away, it might take the warm snuggly feeling in his chest with it, and he wouldn’t want that. “Yeah.”
“Well, then I have to say I think you’re going about it in exactly the right way.” She offered her trademark ‘I’ve got it all figured out’ smile.
“Oh? And what way is that?” Willow asked.
“Well, let’s see. It’s been exactly a month since Anya, Spike, and Amanda and the rest died in the final battle of Sunnydale. It’s been just over 13 months since Tara died, about 7 months since Cassie died, a couple months since Chloe died, about two and a half years since Mom died. We’ve lost Ms. Calendar, Jonathan, Kendra, Ford, Dr. Gregory, Principal Flutie, Principal Snyder – not that we really cared for him deeply -, Kevin, Morgan, Mr. Platt, Debbie, Pete, Larry, Annabelle, Molly, and so many more.” Xander and Willow waited for her to continue, confused by this train of thought and saddened at the seemingly endless string of dead. “So we sit here commiserating about them but it triggers the good memories too, and that brings some joy back to our days. And you know, I think they’re all having a party somewhere, watching us and cheering us on, and whenever we stop a minute, and remember them and tell stories about them, they know and it matters to them. They know."
The three of them sat quietly for a few minutes, pondering this and thinking of various people from that list.
Finally, Willow looked across the table again, “See, Xan, that’s what I told you. I bet us sitting here commiserating together about Anya and Tara makes them happy.” The twisted meaning of her words sunk in and Xander and Buffy looked at her with raised eyebrows. “Oh, you know what I mean, er don’t you?”

sleepy
creative
excited