And yes, this too was gacked from
likeadeuce:
Comment to this post and I will pick five things I would like you to talk about. They might make sense or be totally random.
Then post that list, with your commentary, to your journal. Other people can get lists from you, and the meme merrily perpetuates itself, hopefully for the rest of eternity!She provided me with
five items; my comments are included with each:
5. Van MorrisonVan the Man is one of those performers I should probably like more than I do. His voice is entirely satisfying, and he can pen a soulful tune as well as anyone, and when he involves a horn section in his songs (say, "Wild Night" or "Jackie Wilson Said"), great stuff often results.
That said, I own relatively little of his music. On CD, I've got his "Best of" collection and his album with the Chieftains, "Irish Heartbeat." I've also got "Astral Weeks" and "Tupelo Honey" on my hard drive. I've given the latter two less overall listening time than the former two, but I have tried to get into them, partly because a number of my friends and acquaintances over the years have been huge Van fans. The guitarist in my first serious band was a big one, and it influenced his songwriting to a large degree, giving most of his tunes a shuffling rhythm that I'll admit didn't thrill me. One of the players in my current half-assed band is also firmly in Van's camp, though I haven't yet seen much influence there, and it might be nice if I could see some.
But with all this said, Van has never quite grabbed me by the throat. It's not that I dislike his stuff--far from it. But I don't see anything in it that makes me fall into the worshipful haze in which I've seen others wandering about. "Astral Weeks," for example, is a lovely record in many ways, soulful and pastoral and full of interesting instrumentation, but its dreamlike qualities are to some degree what keep me from fully engaging with it; it's like hearing someone else describe his dream, and I think it's a truism that the only thing less interesting than hearing about someone else's dream is hearing about someone else's diet. The songs aren't really structured as songs so much as they're sets of chords over which Van sends his voice sailing, a lone white ship on a wide green sea. Nothing really develops or changes. It's not at all unpleasant, but for a guy like me who values structure (Why, yes, I
am an Alan Moore fan!) and rhythm (Why yes, I
do listen to Philip Glass!) and harmony (How
did you know? I
love the Roches!), it's tasty without being filling--a perfectly good soup, but not enough to work as a whole meal.
There's also the issue of lyrics. In terms of vocal style, Van is not a guy who's going to let mere enunciation stand in the way of emotion. As a result, many of the songs of his that I like best fall into that weird category so well staked out by Michael Stipe: Songs I Love to Sing Along With Despite Having No Idea What the Words Are. (Example: "Oh-oh, Domino... tho me oh ba Romeo... Lord have mercy... oh-oh, Domino... yo be over Obie oh... I said oh-oh Domino...") Sometimes, I'll grant you, Van is singing something like "dang a lang a lang, dang a lang a lang a lang" entirely on purpose, but at other times he seems to be singing it by accident. Occasionally I hear what were probably intended to be English words, but which seem to have lost everything but their vowels. It's not that I dislike this style--I own every single R.E.M. record, after all--but when there's no melodic development, or when there are no other voices at work, it can be a little much. When I can hear and understand them, they're often pleasant enough, but they often seem a bit too abstract to work like Billy Bragg's beautifully observed songs, or come off as lacking in the playful quality that a good Dylan lyric has.
But there are times when Van just
nails it--the title song of "Tupelo Honey," or "Queen of the Slipstream," or "And It Stoned Me"--and I find myself tempted to once again put on one of his albums and just lose myself in it. At this point he's unlikely to join my personal pantheon of pop musicians, but I'm glad he's out there, fusing elements that no other musician is fusing, and giving me some places to explore when I eventually head over to the bright side of the road.
In the meantime, if I never hear "Brown Eyed Girl" again, I will be satisfied.
Thanks for the inspiration, deuce! I worry that you may have gotten a bit more information than you really wanted...