Parents sue over students' punishment for drinking...
This is the big headline of the day. I guess this means there'll be a German position open at Mariemont High soon. Were it Hamilton, I'd have been fired already.
Parents Sue Over Students' Punishment For Drinking
LAST UPDATE: 4/26/2004 6:52:09 PM
A federal judge heard arguments Monday from parents upset the Mariemont School District disciplined their children for drinking beer while taking part in a student exchange program in Germany.
Nineteen students flew to Munich in March, where they spent twelve days in the school sponsored program. While the drinking age for beer in Germany is sixteen, Mariemont High School code does not allow students to consume any alcohol during school functions.
Seventeen of the students ended up being disciplined over the drinking incident. Some of the parents said the school was out of line.
Local 12 reporter Jeff Hirsh was at federal court when the hearing was held, where U.S. District Court Judge Susan Dlott was asked to decide whether the school or parents had ultimate control of the students overseas.
The lawsuit by two of the parents said they verbally gave their children permission to take part in German culture, which includes beer. The school argued the student code of conduct clearly states that behavior is not permitted, and there was no waiver or violation of parental rights.
According to the suit, the school board suspended seventeen of the students from three to five days. However, after an appeal, the punishment was reduced to five consecutive Saturdays of community service.
"I think all the kids and parents feel, as one mother put it, a slap in the face about doing what they did," said Richard Ward, a stepfather of one of the students. "They have permission to do what they did, and should not have to hang their heads and feel like they did something wrong. We want to vindicate their rights. Parents have rights, too."
Ward said the student conduct code is for school events only. He said Mariemont should have what some other districts have, a specific form for parents to sign concerning alcohol overseas.
Student reaction varied over the punishment. "I think there's a lot of mixed feelings," said senior Emily Lapointe. "A lot of people think they should take responsibility, but there's also a lot of anger at the administration for giving them the suspensions."
"I think community service is good," said senior Allison Brum. "Suspension may be too much, but community service is good between suspension and nothing."
No decision was made by Judge Susan Dlott. She scheduled another hearing for May 3 where other parents whose children were punished may testify. The Saturday community service was put on hold at least until after that session.
Parents Sue Over Students' Punishment For Drinking
LAST UPDATE: 4/26/2004 6:52:09 PM
A federal judge heard arguments Monday from parents upset the Mariemont School District disciplined their children for drinking beer while taking part in a student exchange program in Germany.
Nineteen students flew to Munich in March, where they spent twelve days in the school sponsored program. While the drinking age for beer in Germany is sixteen, Mariemont High School code does not allow students to consume any alcohol during school functions.
Seventeen of the students ended up being disciplined over the drinking incident. Some of the parents said the school was out of line.
Local 12 reporter Jeff Hirsh was at federal court when the hearing was held, where U.S. District Court Judge Susan Dlott was asked to decide whether the school or parents had ultimate control of the students overseas.
The lawsuit by two of the parents said they verbally gave their children permission to take part in German culture, which includes beer. The school argued the student code of conduct clearly states that behavior is not permitted, and there was no waiver or violation of parental rights.
According to the suit, the school board suspended seventeen of the students from three to five days. However, after an appeal, the punishment was reduced to five consecutive Saturdays of community service.
"I think all the kids and parents feel, as one mother put it, a slap in the face about doing what they did," said Richard Ward, a stepfather of one of the students. "They have permission to do what they did, and should not have to hang their heads and feel like they did something wrong. We want to vindicate their rights. Parents have rights, too."
Ward said the student conduct code is for school events only. He said Mariemont should have what some other districts have, a specific form for parents to sign concerning alcohol overseas.
Student reaction varied over the punishment. "I think there's a lot of mixed feelings," said senior Emily Lapointe. "A lot of people think they should take responsibility, but there's also a lot of anger at the administration for giving them the suspensions."
"I think community service is good," said senior Allison Brum. "Suspension may be too much, but community service is good between suspension and nothing."
No decision was made by Judge Susan Dlott. She scheduled another hearing for May 3 where other parents whose children were punished may testify. The Saturday community service was put on hold at least until after that session.
numb