Clearing Up More Misconceptions Over the Nature of Peeta’s Hijacking.
A little over a month ago, I made a post listing each instance of Peeta regaining his real personality and pull towards goodness. In essence, how he came back to himself - contrary to popular, mindlessly regurgitated online talking points - both literally and symbolically. Now, I want to address the actual mechanics of the hijacking that many readers continue to misconstrue and use to lead them to the belief that the “Old Peeta” is dead.
The Capitol never actually took away Peeta’s memories. They inserted competing ones, and the tracker jacker venom temporarily pushed those to the forefront of his mind because of the fear they induced. So, Peeta essentially had two, originally lopsided recollections of the same events, not a total replacement of his memories. He would not even have been able to formulate his “real or not real” questions if the only thing he had was new, fabricated memories. And are people forgetting that he already got to a place where he didn’t need to ask “real or not real” before the war ended sometimes? Just two examples off the top of my head, when he tossed Katniss the can of lamb stew (her absolute favorite Capitol meal) or when he reminded Gale that Katniss’s family “mean more to her than her own life.” If that memory and central truth about Katniss can return - part of the meat of what Snow wanted to flush out of Peeta’s conscience - any memory could come back. And did come back. With time, as described by him in both the book and the film, he gradually learned how to sort them out based on the quality, and the real memories were unburied thanks to continued reinforcement through both extensive rehabilitation and his own accord. He can literally paint his real memories again at the end, damnit!
This is why I always seethe when I see comments like “Peeta learned to love Katniss again, but will never remember how much he loved her the first time.” Because A). He does remember, and B). He loves her more than ever at the end. Because he fought for it. I don’t know what the obsession is with trying to make the ending of already sad books sadder, but when it actively refutes the text and distorts an entire character arc - leaching out one of the only positive and satisfying elements of the ending - I am going to call it out every time.