Swamp Thing 1989 #1

cyberghostface posting in

scans_daily

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

From:

superfangirl1

I did not expect this to be a story about Jesus meeting Swamp Thing. I really enjoy the artwork Swamp Thing is floating through time and space, then he pops up near Jesus.

We even see different realities of certain characters.

From:

metadronos

It's wonderful to see this issue finally published in its entirety. (Previously, only selected, leaked scans of Zulli's pencils were available online.) It's in no way disrespectful to Jesus of Nazareth, as DC claimed when it rejected the story back in 1989. (It seems they were worried that the uproar from conservative Christians, over the then recently released The Last Temptation of Christ, could spell trouble for the publisher. But that reaction to the film in fact died down fairly quickly.)

DC's panicky move would have long-lasting negative consequences for Swamp Thing. Not only did writer Rick Veitch made good on his threat to quit the title several issues before the conclusion of the time-travel storyline (and his run on the comic), but both Neil Gaiman and Jamie Delano, who'd been slotted to alternate writing for the title after Veitch, quit in solidarity with their colleague. Instead, readers got the generally poorly-received runs of Doug Wheeler and Nancy Collins. It wouldn't be until the Mark Millar (with initial contribution by Grant Morrsion) run that Swamp Thing once again began to realize its potential.

Edited Date: 2026-04-29 06:43 pm (UTC)

From:

cainofdreaming

Yeah, not disrespectful. This feels more like it's wrapped in cotton wool. I mean not being able to conceive Jesus of being capable of violence? The money lenders might disagree there.

From:

metadronos

Like hey, man, you're silencing Jesus! He wasn't out to lay a violence trip on the money changers (note: not money lenders); he was telling it like it was about capitalism and exploitation of the poor, especially in a holy place, man! ✌️

----

Or to put it in a more serious way: from a non-devotional, historical perspective, we don't know much of anything about Jesus of Nazareth other than his existence, his real name (Yeshua, a common variant of Yehoshua [Joshua] at the time) and his crucifixion by order of Pontius Pilate. So there's little point in debating whether the historical Yeshua was (as has been variously theorized): an itinerant Stoic-like sage, a proto-socialist, a radical anti-Roman insurrectionist, a proto-Reform Jew, a faith healer, a mystic, or whatever. All of these theories have "support" in the Gospels if read very selectively. Truth is: who can say whether he was "really" into violence or into peace and love?

From:

cainofdreaming

If you go the whole "who can say" road then who can say they weren't actually money lenders? :p

From:

metadronos

Touché!

From:

super_fly

He said "no *innocent* blood" and while the passages mention tossing furniture and driving them out with a whip, they don't specify him using it *on* them.

From:

cainofdreaming

Breaking peoples' stuff and running them off is still violence, even if he doesn't physically hurt them.

From:

super_fly

Like the rest of the bible, I consider that up to interpretation

From:

cainofdreaming

If you can't take "shrimp doesn't belong in pizza" from the bible literally then what is it good for?

From:

agharta75

"It's all part of the cosmic unconsciousness."

From:

cyberghostface

In the context of violence on living beings and shedding innocent blood it doesn’t fit what Swamp Thing is describing.

From:

tripodeca113

It's nice this finally got published and oh good their doing the other issues as well.

From:

michael_ellis_day

I hope people will have the chance to read these issues in the context of the storyline that lead up to them, as published in issues 82 through 87. The synopsis or description that appears at the start of this book is way off the mark and doesn't do the original story justice at ALL. Two years prior Alan Moore sent Swamp Thing into space where he encountered Adam Strange, Thanagarians, a Green Lantern, and (in a an issue guest-written by Veitch) Metron and Darkseid. In Veitch's time travel storyline, Swamp Thing meets Sgt. Rock, the Unknown Soldier, Enemy Ace, a solid ton of DC Western heroes, Tomahawk, Merlin, the Shining Knight, and Etrigan. All of them get a little bit of extra depth and texture but are completely faithful to their original appearances. It's absolutely a love letter to cool old DC characters, published at a time when they were still widely viewed as archaic and embarrassing. That whole aspect understandably gets overshadowed by the controversy around the cancellation. But (and I know I may be alone in this) it's the most interesting part to me.

Anyway, I hope people read the whole storyline, not just the notorious conclusion. It's a banger.

From:

blueprintstyles

I think the run up to this release is free to read online on their app

From:

super_fly

I reckon they'd have had a lot in common, Swampy did do the "Smoke of this weed, for it is my flesh" thing after all.

From:

agharta75

"Your writers copied my writers."

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

Profile

Scans Daily

Extras

Founded by girl geeks and members of the slash fandom,

scans_daily strives to provide an atmosphere which is LGBTQ-friendly, anti-racist, anti-ableist, woman-friendly and otherwise discrimination and harassment free.

Bottom line: If slash, feminism or anti-oppressive practice makes you react negatively, scans_daily is probably not for you.

Please read the community ethos and rules before posting or commenting.

July 2026

S	M	T	W	T	F	S
			1	2	3	4
5	6	7	8	9	10	11
12	13	14	15	16	17	18
19	20	21	22	23	24	25
26	27	28	29	30	31

Scans_Daily

Bringing the crack since December 2003