musesfool: Death of the Endless, captioned "I was there, too, before everything else" (death)
i did it all for the robins ([personal profile] musesfool) wrote2010-09-02 10:27 am

we are tied in history

Come talk to me about The Hunger Games trilogy!

*

So there's nothing concrete yet, but allegedly, Kripke is involved in adapting Sandman for television.

My feelings when I read this last night were mixed, so I've been trying to sort them out via pros and cons.

Pros
+ Kripke gives good family dysfunction and Sandman is, on one level, a big old family melodrama
+ he did all right with Tessa, the Death knockoff in IMtoD and DTaH
+ Maybe we could convince him to cast Benedict Bandersnatch Cumberbatch as Morpheus
+ I have a feeling he'd do right by Lucien, Matthew and Mervyn, as well as The Corinthian
+ he clearly has no problem with incestuous subtext practically becoming text

Cons
- I don't trust him to handle Delirium well, let alone Despair, Lyta Hall, or, jebus help us, Desire
- I certainly don't trust him to get Thessaly
- Or Mazikeen
- Or Rose Walker
- I don't know if he gets that Morpheus' troubles stem from his own misogyny and short-sightedness; I love Morpheus, but let's face it, he's kind of an obnoxious asshole a lot of the time
- I don't trust him to not fridge or demote all the women, and if you do that, what you have left is a lot of untenable emo manpain, and also, no drivers for the story
- look at the fail of "Hammer of the Gods." Now, look at the DO NOT WANT face I'm making.
- would this be on the CW? Because no. A thousand times NO. Pay cable or nothing for this adaptation, man.

So basically right now it seems like a bad match to me, despite his self-proclaimed status as a Sandman fanboy. Obviously, this is way premature and more information would be needed if this actually happens, but while I am all, Sandman adaptation YAY! on one hand, on the other, I'd rather it not be done at all than be done badly (*cough*Earthsea*cough*).

***
scy: (lucifer and mazikeen)

[personal profile] scy 2010-09-02 02:45 pm (UTC)(link)
I agree. I don't trust him to get the characters you mentioned right - OR Lucifer. Because, the Sandman Lucifer is such a different creature than what Kripke envisioned on Supernatural - and- GAH

You CANNOT demote the women in Sandman, I mean, no Mazikeen, Rose Walker, Thessaly? *shakes head*
scy: (mazikeen)

[personal profile] scy 2010-09-02 06:05 pm (UTC)(link)
*nods* I can see that, but yes, HBO would be a good place for Sandman - for a LOT of reasons.

And yes, I have stopped watching Supernatural largely because of Kripke's attitude toward women, and the thought of him aiming that toward Sandman is severely off putting to me.
scy: (mazikeen)

[personal profile] scy 2010-09-02 09:50 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh, I KNOW. *shudders*
skywaterblue: (neil gaiman would unhappen so much)

[personal profile] skywaterblue 2010-09-02 03:43 pm (UTC)(link)
I wish I could think of a snappy name for my protest site. Not that I'm sure it's needed yet.
teand: (tea&oranges)

[personal profile] teand 2010-09-02 04:13 pm (UTC)(link)
I think the problem for me is that Kripke IS a fanboy. I'd be happier if he were going in cold with no intent to bring what he personally loved about the books to the screen. Because evidence seems to suggest that what he personally loves is not going to be what I personally loved.
thedivinegoat: A photo of a yellow handled screwdriver, with text saying "This could be a little more sonic" (Default)

[personal profile] thedivinegoat 2010-09-02 06:35 pm (UTC)(link)
M. Night is/was an Avatar:The Last Airbender fanboy...
thedivinegoat: A photo of a Christmas Fairy Tree Ornament on a pile of other tree ornaments. No text. (My Photo - Christmas Fairy)

[personal profile] thedivinegoat 2010-09-02 08:17 pm (UTC)(link)
I think it's the only way the movie can ever be a good thing - as a cautionary tale.

(I need me some A:TLA icons).