Return to Question

Previous episodes of this ongoing series can be reviewed starting with this October 2025 post Exploring new types of questions on Stack Overflow, if you wish. When we last tuned in, open-ended questions were meeting with modest success. Popular with people who want to ask open-ended questions, and some have written pretty good questions. Also popular (at least in principle) with people who welcome a Stack Overflow that includes a broader range of content. Not as popular with much of the core community since the format lacked the moderation and curation options that have kept the quality bar high on Stack Overflow for more than a decade. The narrative got to a certain point, the season finale left everyone wondering what was going to happen next, and the wait has been somewhat painful. (If this story sounds familiar, you might be thinking of season one: Discussions update: Expansion to all tags)

Previous episodes of this ongoing series can be reviewed starting with this October 2025 post Exploring new types of questions on Stack Overflow, if you wish. When we last tuned in, open-ended questions were meeting with modest success. Popular with people who want to ask open-ended questions, and some have written pretty good questions. Also popular (at least in principle) with people who welcome a Stack Overflow that includes a broader range of content. Not as popular with much of the core community since the format lacked the moderation and curation options that have kept the quality bar high on Stack Overflow for more than a decade. The narrative got to a certain point, the season finale left everyone wondering what was going to happen next, and the wait has been somewhat painful. (If this story sounds familiar, you might be thinking of season one: Discussions update: Expansion to all tags.)

Previous episodes of this ongoing series can be reviewed starting with this October 2025 post Exploring new types of questions on Stack Overflow, if you wish. When we last tuned in, open-ended questions were meeting with modest success. Popular with people who want to ask open-ended questions, and some have written pretty good questions. Also popular (at least in principle) with people who welcome a Stack Overflow that includes a broader range of content. Not as popular with much of the core community since the format lacked the moderation and curation options that have kept the quality bar high on Stack Overflow for more than a decade. The narrative got to a certain point, the season finale left everyone wondering what was going to happen next, and the wait has been somewhat painful. (If this story sounds familiar, you might be thinking of season one. (Discussions update: Expansion to all tags))

Previous episodes of this ongoing series can be reviewed starting with this October 2025 post Exploring new types of questions on Stack Overflow, if you wish. When we last tuned in, open-ended questions were meeting with modest success. Popular with people who want to ask open-ended questions, and some have written pretty good questions. Also popular (at least in principle) with people who welcome a Stack Overflow that includes a broader range of content. Not as popular with much of the core community since the format lacked the moderation and curation options that have kept the quality bar high on Stack Overflow for more than a decade. The narrative got to a certain point, the season finale left everyone wondering what was going to happen next, and the wait has been somewhat painful. (If this story sounds familiar, you might be thinking of season one: Discussions update: Expansion to all tags)

All the ripple effects of this change are things to be assessed and discussed. As I said above, how we move forward with this approach is very much in the hands of the Stack Overflow community. [Check out today’s companion post https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/440089/ for more about that.

All the ripple effects of this change are things to be assessed and discussed. As I said above, how we move forward with this approach is very much in the hands of the Stack Overflow community. Check out today’s companion post Looking ahead, starting conversations, and seizing the moment for more about that.