Reviews: Music and Middle Ages
Lately, I've been in a non-fiction-ish mood. Here's what I've read so far:
Musicophilia by Oliver Sachs is a collection of essays of varying length about music and the brain. He spends most of the book talking about music and various brain disorders, from Alzheimer's disease to obscure ones like Williams syndrome. Some of the essays illustrate more general points about how the brain processes music, but after the first few of them it became repetitive, with lots of specifics and no additional big-picture ideas. I also found it depressing to read about Sachs' various patients, many of whom have incurable diseases or horrific brain damage. Overall, this was an interesting read, but I wish I'd gotten it from the library instead of buying it.
Mysteries of the Middle Ages by Thomas Cahill was more interesting. He writes about the synthesis of Greek philosophy and Christianity during the middle ages, which produced the seeds of the modern world. His tactic is to look at one aspect of medieval culture and illustrate its development through a single person's achievements. For example, the chapter on courtly love examine the life of Eleanor of Aquitaine, as an illustration of how women's status rose in the late middle ages. I'm not sure I agree with all of Cahill's analysis, particularly the chapters about Ptolomaic vs. Christian philosophy in artwork, but the book is compellingly written, and it's obvious Cahill loves his subject. The conclusion was a criticism of the recent sex abuse scandals in the Catholic Church, which was entirely out of place; I sympathize with his views, but a history book is not the place to put them. However, I enjoyed the rest of the book enough that I'll probably look for more of his work.
Next up: Wild Swans: Three Daughters of China by Jung Chang
Musicophilia by Oliver Sachs is a collection of essays of varying length about music and the brain. He spends most of the book talking about music and various brain disorders, from Alzheimer's disease to obscure ones like Williams syndrome. Some of the essays illustrate more general points about how the brain processes music, but after the first few of them it became repetitive, with lots of specifics and no additional big-picture ideas. I also found it depressing to read about Sachs' various patients, many of whom have incurable diseases or horrific brain damage. Overall, this was an interesting read, but I wish I'd gotten it from the library instead of buying it.
Mysteries of the Middle Ages by Thomas Cahill was more interesting. He writes about the synthesis of Greek philosophy and Christianity during the middle ages, which produced the seeds of the modern world. His tactic is to look at one aspect of medieval culture and illustrate its development through a single person's achievements. For example, the chapter on courtly love examine the life of Eleanor of Aquitaine, as an illustration of how women's status rose in the late middle ages. I'm not sure I agree with all of Cahill's analysis, particularly the chapters about Ptolomaic vs. Christian philosophy in artwork, but the book is compellingly written, and it's obvious Cahill loves his subject. The conclusion was a criticism of the recent sex abuse scandals in the Catholic Church, which was entirely out of place; I sympathize with his views, but a history book is not the place to put them. However, I enjoyed the rest of the book enough that I'll probably look for more of his work.
Next up: Wild Swans: Three Daughters of China by Jung Chang

curious
creative