If you've been following a relatively obscure band and they start to become popular, do you tend to lose interest at some point? Is mainstream appeal a turn off when it comes to music?
This has actually happened a few times that I've been listening to someone since they were brand new on the scene, and all of a sudden their career explodes into the stratosphere. If it's an artist whose work I love, I tend to feel happy for them that they've found success. However, I usually regret not having taken an opportunity to see them in concert in a small venue before they started taking on stadiums and arenas.
For instance, I was listening to Sarah McLachlan from her very first album (released in 1988), before America even knew she existed and long before Lilith Fair was ever conceived. She came to Manitoba for a couple of smaller concerts back in the early 90s, and living in Brandon at the time it was hard for me to get out to Winnipeg to see her so it just never happened. And now it's impossible to see her anywhere but Lilith Fair. Bah. Honestly, I like her early work better than what she's putting out now.
Then there are those artists that I wish the world would catch on to as much as we have here in Canada. I've been a fan of Jann Arden since her very first album, and I got to see her open for Moxy Fruvous way back when they were the next big Canadian thing. It was just her and one friend up there on the stage at Pantages Playhouse going through the repertoire of her first album with nothing but a guitar, a bass, and her witty banter to fuel their performance. After all these years, it's her performance that I recall the best of that entire night, and I've seen her in concert a handful of times since then. She's brilliant and hilarious and deserves to be known around the world as more than the one-global-hit-wonder that produced
Insensitive -- a song that she didn't write, and certainly not her best song (though still a good one, I might add). Also, she is now my Facebook friend. Heh.
I don't think mainstream appeal, per se, is a turn off for me, but I do tend to like mining the airwaves for new music that I wouldn't otherwise hear by listening to the radio alone. I listen to podcasts that extoll the virtues of artists I've never heard of before, and I try to get a heavy dose of Canadiana in my musical meals. I read articles about new music in online magazines, and I sample a lot of artists via downloading. Sometimes, I find gems that become a regular part of my listening life, such as The Weepies and Girlyman. Other times, I just find interesting new listens that come and go in my memory. Occasionally, I end up finding a guilty pleasure song (most of the time from mainstream radio)...for some reason, I love Pink's song
Funhouse, about which I am somewhat ashamed.
I have to admit that I am a little prejudiced against mainstream radio. I hate Lady Gaga -- I admit it! I dislike a great deal of what passes for popular music these days. I guess that makes me a bit of a music snob. But even someone like me that searches for music others haven't heard will occasionally start tapping toes and singing along with whatever comes on a colleague's blaring radio...which is about the time I turn on my iPod.