John Simon

John Simon

Favorite films

  • Citizen Kane
  • The Rules of the Game
  • Forbidden Games
  • I Vitelloni

Recent activity

All
  • The Dresser

  • The Right Stuff

  • Under Fire

  • Sophie's Choice

Recent reviews

More
The Dresser
Watched

The Dresser is one of those rare cases where a movie version, in
this case Ronald Harwood’s adaptation of his own undistinguished
play, is better than the stage original.

Dealing with the terminal day in the life of the last of the British touring actor-managers — a character modeled largely on Donald Wolfit, for whom Harwood once worked — it is an effective quadruple testimonial. It praises, first, the half-mad, half-inspired actor, an infuriating despot somehow awesome despite his senescent…

The Right Stuff
Watched

Philip Kaufman's script and direction try to be faithful both to Tom Wolfe’s book (which I have read about enough to feel I have read it), with its arch-conservatism, and to Kaufman’s own views, a mixture of San Francisco hip (i.e., liberal verging on radical) and Hollywood movie buff (i.e., retrograde). What emerges is a mighty peculiar hybrid, like a giant nouvelle cuisine hamburger. It isn’t unpalatable, and it has both sociological and comic-strip interest, but it certainly isn’t art.…

Popular reviews

More
Blue Velvet
Watched

How long has it been since an American movie has garnered a harvest of laurels like the one being heaped on a piece of mindless junk called Blue Velvet ? David Lynch’s previous films were Eraserhead, a grossout for cultists, and the inept and contemptible Elephant Man and Dune. True pornography, which does not pretend to be anything else, has at least that shred of honesty to recommend it; Blue Velvet, which pretends to be art, and is taken for…

Reds
Watched

There were, I think, two ways of making a film about John Reed —
author of Ten Days That Shook the World, the principal American buried in the Kremlin — and Louise Bryant, his fellow journalist, fellow Communist, and wife. Either you could stick to historical facts, with minor elisions, imaginative guesses, and clarifications added as necessary. Or you could create a fiction based on these real-life characters, preferably not using their actual names. Reds, which Warren Beatty co-scripted with…