hhimring: Estel, inscription by D. Salo (Default)
[personal profile] hhimring
WARNING: Possible Hobbit movie spoilers.

At Tolkien Weekly, Dwimordene offered an excellent explanation of what Thranduil was doing on top of that cliff, looking down, just as the Dwarves were fleeing Erebor: http://tolkien-weekly.livejournal.com/954907.html

I suggested to her that she should write another drabble from the Dwarves' point of view, she challenged me to do it myself and I did (http://tolkien-weekly.livejournal.com/955623.html).

Now archiving that drabble here below the cut.


Title: Ill-gotten Wealth
Characters/Pairing: Dwarves of Erebor, Thranduil
Rating: Gen
Warnings: none
Book/Source: The Hobbit (movie-verse)
Disclaimer: I'm neither JRRT nor PJ. I hope nobody minds.
Summary: In response to dwimordene_2011's The Wealth of Kingdoms, which is written from Thranduil's POV. The dwarves have their say.

Thieves
, he thinks, murderers, and it shows in his face. Thranduil does not respect steel or its makers, handles Erebor-forged swords as if they were shoddy kitchen knives patched up in some Gondorian backyard. The work of the hands of the heirs of Durin!

The honor-price? Price of shame we should call it: such transactions demean both buyer and seller. He can ill afford it? He knows we have sometimes gifted freely to Dale what we charged him doubly for. It has taught him nothing. See, here he comes crawling back, no wiser than Thingol once was. Thieves, he thinks.

Date: 2013-02-13 05:08 pm (UTC)
levade: (Things half-seen)
From: [personal profile] levade
I liked Dwim's interpretation because wow, those few small glimpses in the movie have ignited a firestorm in some folks who, I think, maybe didn't read the book.

I like this. It's very, very Dwarven. They have every reason to be as proud as Elves, and often get looked down upon (no pun intended, oops) by fans. When I sit back and take the big picture in, I can see how both sides came with assumptions, histories (both races have long memories), and so much pride.

It's always amazing to me that anyone can write so much in short a span as a drabble. The last sentence is just perfect!

June 2026

S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930    

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 12th, 2026 02:05 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios