hhimring: Estel, inscription by D. Salo (Default)
[personal profile] hhimring
Some people on my f-list have seen this already: it's a cleaned-up version of my essay on Eowyn and Aerin that I posted for the LOTR Community non-fiction challenge some time ago (longer ago than I quite like to think!).
I incorporated some of the very helpful feedback I received at the time and also later, from Dawn and the SWG reference readers.
This is as good as I've been able to make it under present time constraints. (Some of the sketchier bits of discussion that I haven't been able to support fully with references have been sneaked into the footnotes.)

Date: 2018-07-03 07:03 pm (UTC)
grundyscribbling: Maeglin (tolkien - maeglin)
From: [personal profile] grundyscribbling
I've been wondering when this would be posted. Will have to read it now that you've incorporated the feedback, I imagine it's changed somewhat from the version that was sent out for reference checks. I'll say the same thing I've told Oshun a couple times now - if you don't see a comment from me sometime soonish (say, by the end of the weekend), feel free to badger me about it! (I sometimes read when I don't have time to comment, mean to comment, get side-tracked, and without prompting don't remember that the 'comment' never got beyond intentions...)

Date: 2018-07-05 10:30 pm (UTC)
grundyscribbling: buffy summers (tolkien -gandalf)
From: [personal profile] grundyscribbling
No thanks necessary! I'm a reference reader, but I was too late to volunteer to read over your essay - apparently everyone else in the reference reader pool was quicker to check their email that day. (The 'we have enough volunteers' email came in literally as I was about to hit send on my 'I volunteer!' reply.) Dawn sent me the essay and the expectations for reference readers so I'd have an idea of what it is we're being asked to read/review/do.

I'm saving Oshun's bio for the weekend, I've found that if I read the bios during the week I almost always either a) get interrupted, or b) think 'I will write a comment when I have more time/am not about to fall asleep' and then forget that I meant to go back to do that. :)

June 2026

S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930    

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 12th, 2026 03:07 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios