I’ll take your “Jewish Ryland Grace” headcanon and raise you a “Jewish Eva Stratt.”
Think about it. An Eva Stratt raised Jewish but erased all public records connected to her people to protect them. So they wouldn’t be blamed for her mistakes. An Eva Stratt who wrapped her mission in Christian symbolism to make it more palatable to the public. An Eva Stratt who wholeheartedly believes in G-d.
An Eva Stratt who sits in the back during Yom Kippur services knowing the one person whose forgiveness she wants most can never grant it to her. An Eva Stratt who lit yahrzeit candles and says the Mourner’s Kaddish every year on the anniversary of the Hail Mary launch..just in case.
An Eva Stratt who chose to study history because of the stories her parents and grandparents told her of how their people were cast out and mistreated and killed over and over again - and she wanted to understand the why but could never find one. So she switched tracks to do everything in her power to make sure “Never again” wasn’t just a hollow slogan.
An Eva Stratt who knows how horrible humanity can be and still did everything in her power to ensure that they survived the impossible.
An Eva Stratt, who upon receiving the cure for the astrophage said the shehecheyanu for the first time in years.
….:Imagine a Jewish Eva Stratt.