Review: The Ultimate Cut of "Watchmen"
Yesterday, I bought the eagerly-awaited Watchmen: The Ultimate Cut. I've been waiting for this sucker since March 2009. First off, I want to say that the front cover is atrocious a beveled yellow circle with a skull-and-crossbones and a blood splatter. And I thought the DVD covers for the Theatrical Cut and Director's Cut were uncreative! Seriously, what is this? Just because it has Tales of the Black Freighter you have to put a bland little skull-and-crossbones? Despite the awful front, the construction of the box set is beautiful. It's of high quality, with "The End Is Nigh" on the back, along with blood splatter and silhouette of the seaman's makeshift raft. The box folds out with a gorgeous Doomsday Clock and promotional posters of the all the Crimebusters inside. It has two DVD cases inside: One is the The Motion Comic, which means now I have two copies of this, and the fold-out case for the film DVDs, again with the ugly skull-and-crossbones, with Ozymandias, the Comedian, and Nite Owl II.


This third variation of the film integrated with the 2D-animated The Tales of the Black Freighter, starring by Gerard Butler, which is a symbolic meta-fiction describing the tragedy of Adrian "Ozymandias" Veidt. I have to say a few sentences on Black Freighter itself. I do own the individual DVD, with the Under the Hood mockumentary, and as an animator myself, I cannot help but critique. The story itself is beautiful, the compositions are attractive, the acting is emotional, and the overall feel is wonderfully gritty and atmospheric. Because I really hate the Japanese anime stylization. It's overdone and overrated. It's a stylization that's in vogue, it's not timeless, and it definitely does not fit with the 1980s period. When you have character designs that are very detail-oriented and the studio is one a tight schedule, like this film was, the results are rarely good. I abhor the 3D water, ships, and other models; they stand out horrifically, like you're missing you're big toe. The animation goes from decent to godawful. It's very, very rushed. I would have much preferred Dave Gibbons' naturalistic comic book art style an, I feel, would have produced better results.
With all of that said, how does the Black Freighter work in the overall film? Extremely well, in fact! I adore the Director's Cut and I didn't think one could approve the film beyond. I was extremely surprised that I enjoyed the Ultimate Cut just equally to the Director's Cut. Some have complained that the film stops whenever the Black Freighter sections come in. In a way, yes, it does, but it still continues the story on quite well. I really love the extended footage with the two Bernies, the Knot-tops, Hollis Mason, and unmasked Walter Kovacs. I particularly loved when the Knot-tops harass Lil' Bernie, grabbing the comic book away from him, and became quite ominously threatening characters. Watching the two Bernies embrace (a metaphor to the Hiroshima lovers) when New York City was bombed, I cried. I really did cry, just as I did when I read the graphic novel. I do think it might have integrated better if the narration boxes and/or speech bubbles were used. Therefore you have a pop-up narration box with a Butler's voice over live-action footage and still work.
The commentaries are a delight. Director Zack Snyder sounds ill with a flu, so his voice is crackly, but still has the exuberant with a great love of the material. He's a trooper! Dave Gibbons, who illustrated the original graphic novel of Watchmen, is not as talkative as Zack. It feels like he's watching the film, sitting next to you on the sofa, and commenting here and there, enjoying himself. I'm actually a follower of Dave Gibbon's Twitter and messaged him on how much I enjoyed his commentary, expressing my opinion on the Ultimate Cut in several 140-character messages. I had no idea that he'd answer back! I was grinning from ear to ear for an hour!

I'd like to take the time to rant about something. I hate Digital Copy DVDs! When I buy a DVD I expect a special features. It's the reason why I buy them. I don't buy the DVD to get two versions of the same film. That's just stupid! What I want is special features! I really hope Digital Copies are just a vogue because it's really ruining the concept of DVDs for me. (See previous entries for a more complete rant on Digital Copies.)
Unfortunately, we get the bare minimum when it comes to special features:
But there are things missing in this edition. I don't get the option to see Tales of the Black Freighter as its own short, like in the separate Black Freighter released awhile ago. We don't have the Maximum Movie Mode, which was on the Director's Cut Blu-Ray, where the film would pause and director Zack Synder would come how and give his own personal commentary on the scene. I saw a preview of his on Amazon and I loved it. I really wish it was on here, but we're just given the simple audio commentaries. Hurm.11 (extended cut) video journals My Chemical Romance's "Desolation Row" music video (which is I dislike) "The Phenomenon: The Comic that Changed Comics" (which is basic, nothing really special) "Real Super Heroes, Real Vigilantes" (boring!) "Mechanics: Technologies of a Fantastic World" (which is cute) The amazing Under the Hood mockumentary and its featurette, "Story Within A Story: The Books of Watchmen" (which is awesome) Watchmen: The Complete Motion Comics (which I already own)
In conclusion, the Ultimate Cut is not for the general audience member. I recommend the Director's Cut for a regular viewer, but this is really meant for the fans! Those who can't get enough Watchmen! Enjoy!

Music of the Moment: "I'm Your Boogie Man" by KC and the Sunshine Band.
Media of the Moment: Watchmen: The Ultimate Cut (2009).
Book of the Moment: Watchmen: The Film Companion, by Peter Aperlo.
Food of the Moment: Jell-O.
Lust of the Moment: Walter Kovacs.
Research of the Moment: Watchmen.
Philosophical Perspective of the Moment: "Prison's a prison" (Rorschach, Watchmen).





