Many of you will know this already, undoubtedly being regular visitors, but over at the ever wonderful No Badger Required, curator SWC regularly calls upon the services of their hand-picked Musical Jury to help compile a list of the Top Twenty on a number of different topics. When providing their nominations, the MJM (Musical Jury Member) is invited to provide a few words on their nominations, which SWC uses when going through the final list. although being members of a jury their identity is kept hidden, SWC providing them with a pseudonym. This time, it’s London Underground stations.
The current topic getting the rundown treatment and therefore no longer up for discussion is Rocks Greatest Number, that is, the artist with a number in their name who attracts the highest number of votes.
On Friday, SWC reached #14 in the final countdown, and posted offerings from two of the jury, MJM High Barnet and MJM Paddington, on a band much loved around these parts: 10,000 Maniacs. You can read what words they cobbled together here. I should add, before we go any further, that if you’re unfamiliar with them, please disregard the band name, which conjurs up the image of a punk rock hardcore band, when in reality that could not be further from the truth.
Anyway, both High Barnet and Paddington certainly know their stuff, especially MJM Paddington, who seems to be an incredibly wise and undoubtedly devilishly handsome sort to boot. Both mention there are two distinct phases in the life of 10,000 Maniacs: with Natalie Merchant providing lead vocals, and then without, following her departure from the band in 1993. Both contributors are keen to point out that their nominations for the Top 20 are based solely on the first phase, and both refer to the MTV Unplugged album as a highpoint, and they’re not wrong, it’s practically a Greatest Hits album, had 10,000 Maniacs ever had any hits (they only ever had one in the UK, and that was lifted from this record). The album was recorded on April 21st 1993, but not released until October 26th 1993; Merchant announced her departure on August 5th 1993.
You’ll be familiar with the concept of the MTV Unplugged series: back in the days when MTV still lived up to its own acronym (i.e. it was a TV channel devoted to music, unlike today when it features nothing but reality TV shows) a musical act would be invited into the studio to perform a concert in front of a live audience, where the act could only perform using acoustic instruments: no electrical equipment (bar microphones and speakers) were allowed. The results would be recorded, broadcast and often, but not always, released for sale. Most famous examples where commercial success with the records followed were by as diverse a groups of artists as Mariah Carey, Alice in Chains, Rod Stewart, (arguably most famously)Nirvana and Eric Clapton. All of these went platinum (as did 10,000 Maniacs’), with Clapton’s (which I’ve mentioned on these pages before, I have a soft spot for) selling 26 million copies worldwide, becoming the best-selling live album of all time.
So, yeah, quite a successful franchise.
This “no electric or electronic instruments” policy was lampooned back in the late 1980s/early 1990s on The Mary Whitehouse Experience:
But I digress.
What neither MJM High Barnet nor MJM Paddington mention is that the live broadcast of 10,000 Maniacs MTV Unplugged contained some extra songs which did not appear on the original release of the album, but were included when an Expanded Edition was released in 2024. These were three cover versions, presumably originally omitted as they would have made the record a little covers-heavy, what with the actual inclusion of their version of Patti Smith’s Springsteen-penned Because the Night a nailed-on, must have.
The first of those three covers really needs no introduction, taking the song to a much more mournful place than the original:
However, the other two do require a little bit of an introduction.
The first is a song written by Jimmie Dale Gilmore and first released in 1972; on both these next two versions, 10,000 Maniacs are joined on stage by the legend that is David Byrne:
10,000 Maniacs (feat. David Byrne) – Dallas
The second is by an artist who has featured on these pages once before, a long time ago (2023 is a long time ago, right?): Iris DeMent. As well as the Expanded Edition version of MTV Unplugged, this version can also be found on 10,000 Maniacs snappily-titled compilation album Campfire Songs: The Popular, Obscure and Unknown Recordings of 10,000 Maniacs:
10,000 Maniacs (feat. David Byrne) – Let the Mystery Be
All bloody marvelous, I’m sure you’ll agree.
And, as a treat, since I’ve not posted anything here for a while, here are the originals:
Jimmie Dale and The Flatlanders – Dallas
Iris DeMent – Let the Mystery Be
You’re welcome.
More soon.

























