Soudob� d�jiny 2016 (vol.23) 3: 321-346 | DOI: 10.51134/sod.2016.020
Teraz alebo nikdy. Povojnov� proti�idovsk� n�silie a v��inov� spolo�nos� na Slovensku
Proti�idovsk� n�sil� na pov�le�n�m Slovensku, p�edev��m pogrom v Topol�anech v z��� 1945, p�edstavuje dnes relativn� prob�dan� t�ma. V�cero autor� a autorek detailn� popsalo pr�b�h a spektrum n�sil� v��i �id�m na osvobozen�m Slovensku. N�kter� nov�j�� pr�ce pak proti�idovsk� demonstrace, v�tr�nosti a pogromy proti �id�m na Slovensku, kte�� p�e�ili holokaust, zkoumaly v �ir��m kontextu p�etrv�vaj�c�ho antisemitismu v pov�le�n� Evrop�. A p�esto�e nejednou p�itom poukazuj� na spojitost ��sti slovensk� spole�nosti s tamn�m v�le�n�m re�imem a jej� �astou neochotu vr�tit p�ivlastn�n� �idovsk� majetek jako na dva d�le�it� tehdej�� faktory, n�lady a postoje obyvatel v��i �id�m v pov�le�n�m obdob� z�st�vaj� v�t�inou stranou pozornosti historik�. Proti�idovsk� n�sil� proto autorce v t�to studii slou�� zejm�na jako v�chodisko k anal�ze sm��len� a postoj� slovensk� spole�nosti ke zbytku �idovsk� men�iny. Ukazuje v n�, �e �id� byli ve slovensk�m ve�ejn�m m�n�n� t� doby st�le vn�m�ni jako "ciz�" element, jako Ma�a�i a ma�ariz�to�i, jejich� z�jmy se rozch�zej� se "slovenskou v�c�". K za�it�m stereotyp�m pat�ilo p�esv�d�en�, �e profituj� z "�ern�ho obchodu" a �ij� si nad pom�ry, kdy� vyu��vaj� ��edn� jim poskytovan� v�hody. Z�rove� se �dajn� vyh�baj� pr�ci na obnov� Slovenska, stejn� jako se za v�lky pr� vyh�bali ��asti na povst�n�. Naopak v tehdej��ch ��edn�ch zpr�v�ch i tisku na Slovensku, pokud se t�kaly �id�, se t�m�� nevyskytuj� zm�nky o holokaustu a kolaboraci v�t�inov�ho obyvatelstva s Tisov�m re�imem, kter� na n�m participoval.
Kl��ov� slova: Slovensko; proti�idovsk� n�sil�; v�t�inov� spole�nost
Now or Never: Post-war Anti-Jewish Violence and Majority Society in Slovakia
Anti-Jewish violence in post-war Slovakia, in particular the pogrom in Topo��any in September 1945, has by now been quite well researched by scholars. Several have considered the course and the scope of the violence against Jews in liberated Slovakia. More recent works consider the anti-Jewish demonstrations, provocations, and pogroms in Slovakia against Jewish Shoah survivors in Slovakia in the wider context of persistent antisemitism in post-war Europe. Though several scholars have pointed out the link between part of Slovak society and the local wartime regime and its frequent post-war reluctance to return confiscated Jewish property as two important factors, public moods and attitudes towards the Jews in the post-war period have mostly been ignored by historians. Anti-Jewish violence is therefore the author's starting point for her analysis of Slovak society's thinking and attitudes towards the remainder of the Jewish minority. She demonstrates that the perception of the Jews in Slovak public opinion at the time was still that of a 'foreign' element (as it was regarding the Magyars and Magyarizers) whose interests differed from those of the 'Slovak cause'. Among the well-established stereotypes was the belief that the Jews profited from black marketeering and lived beyond their means, taking advantage of the officially provided benefits. They also allegedly shunned work on the reconstruction of Slovakia, as they had also allegedly avoided taking part in the Uprising during the war. By contrast, Slovak official reports and the Slovak press from this period, when they mention the Jews at all, almost never address the Shoah, local antisemitism, or majority-society collaboration with the Tiso regime (1938-45)
Keywords: Slovakia; anti-Jewish violence; major society
Zve�ejn�no: 1. z��� 2016 Zobrazit citaci
Reference
- ALNER, Juraj: Slovensk� poh�ady na �idov, alebo �idia v Slovensk�ch poh�adoch. Bratislava, Adora Lingua 2011.
- BANKIER, David (ed.): The Jews Are Coming Back: The Return of the Jews to Their Countries of Origin after WWII. New York - Jerusalem, Berghahn Books - Yad Vashem 2005.
- B�CHLER, Yehoshua Robert: �idovsk� n�bo�ensk� obec v Topo��anoch: Po�iatky, rozvoj, z�nik. Bratislava, Slovensk� n�rodn� m�zeum - M�zeum �idovskej kult�ry 1996.
- BUMOV�, Ivica: Proti�idovsk� v�tr�nosti v Bratislave v historickom kontexte (august 1946). In: Pam� N�roda, ro�. 3, �. 3 (2007), s. 14-29.
- BYSTRICK�, Valeri�n - ROGU�OV�, Jaroslava (ed.): Storo�ie propagandy: Slovensko v os�dlach ideol�gi�. Bratislava, Academic Electronic Press 2005.
- CICHOPEK-GAJRAJ, Anna: Beyond Violence: Jewish Survivors in Poland and Slovakia, 1944-48. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press 2014.
P�ej�t k p�vodn�mu zdroji... - CICHOPEK-GAJRAJ, Anna: Limits to 'Jewish Power': How Slovak Jewish Leaders Negotiated Restitution of Property after the Second World War. In: East European Jewish Affairs, ro�. 44, �. 1 (2014), s. 51-69.
P�ej�t k p�vodn�mu zdroji... - �APKOV�, Kate�ina: Germans or Jews? German-Speaking Jews in Poland and Czechoslovakia after World War II. In: Kwartalnik Historii �yd�w / Jewish History Quarterly, �. 2 (246), 2013, s. 348-362.
- �APKOV�, Kate�ina: N�rodn� nespolehliv�?! N�mecky hovo��c� �id� v Polsku a v �eskoslovensku bezprost�edn� po druh� sv�tov� v�lce. In: Soudob� d�jiny, ro�. 22, �. 1-2 (2015), s. 80-101.
P�ej�t k p�vodn�mu zdroji... - ENGEL, David: Patterns of AntiJewish Violence in Poland, 1944-1946. In: Yad Vashem Studies, ro�. 26. Jerusalem, Yad Vashem 1998, s. 43-85.
- FELAK, James Ramon: After Hitler, before Stalin: Catholics, Communists, and Democrats in Slovakia, 1945-1948. Pittsburgh, University of Pittsburgh Press 2009.
P�ej�t k p�vodn�mu zdroji... - GRONSK�, J�n: Komentovan� dokumenty k �stavn�m d�jin�m �eskoslovenska, zv. 1: 1914-1945. Praha, Karolinum 2005.
- GROSS, Jan Tomasz: Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz: An Essay in Historical Interpretation. New York, Random House 2006.
- CH�OUPEK, Bohu�: Banderovci. Bratislava, Smena 1989.
- CH�OUPEK, Bohu�: M��niky: Report�e a �rty. Bratislava, Smena 1975.
- CH�OUPEK, Bohu�: Pogrom: Na sny sa nezomiera. Bratislava, Kni�n� centrum 2003.
- JECH, Karel - KAPLAN, Karel (ed.): Dekrety prezidenta republiky 1940-1945: Dokumenty. Brno - Praha, Dopln�k - �stav pro soudob� d�jiny AV �R 2002.
- JEL�NEK, Je�ajahu A.: �idia na Slovensku v 19. a 20. storo��: Zborn�k stat�, zv. 2. Bratislava, Slovensk� n�rodn� m�zeum - M�zeum �idovskej kult�ry 2000.
- KAMENEC, Ivan: Po stop�ch trag�die. Bratislava, Archa 1991.
- KAMENEC, Ivan: Proti�idovsk� pogrom v Topo��anoch v septembri 1945. In: Studia Historica Nitriensia, ro�. 8. Nitra, Filozofick� fakulta Univerzity Kon�tant�na Filozofa 1999, s. 85-97.
- KREKOVI�OV�, Eva - PANCZOV�, Zuzana: Obraz nepriate�a v po�iatkoch slovenskej politickej karikat�ry: Vizu�lne stereotypy v �asopise �ernok�a�n�k v rokoch 1861-1910. In: Slovensk� n�rodopis, ro�. 61, �. 1 (2013), s. 31-54.
- KUB�TOV�, Hana: Nepokrade�! N�lady a postoje slovensk� spole�nosti k �idovsk� ot�zce, 1938-1945. Praha, Academia 2013.
- L�N��EK, Jan: Czechs, Slovaks and the Jews, 1938-48: Beyond Idealization and Condemnation. New York, Palgrave Macmillan 2013.
P�ej�t k p�vodn�mu zdroji... - LETZ, R�bert: Slovensko v rokoch 1945-1948: Na ceste ku komunistickej totalite. Bratislava, �stredie slovenskej kres�anskej inteligencie 1994.
- LEVENE, Mark: Annihilation, zv. 2: The European Rimlands 1939-1953. Oxford, Oxford University Press 2013.
- MEDVECK�, Matej (ed.): Posledn� a prv� slobodn� () vo�by 1946, 1990: Zborn�k z odborn�ho semin�ra. Bratislava, �stav pam�ti n�roda 2006.
- MEYER, Peter: The Jews in the Soviet Satellites. Syracuse (New York), Syracuse University Press 1953.
- OUZAN, Fran�oise S. - GERSTENFELD, Manfred (ed.): Postwar Jewish Displacement and Rebirth: 1945-1967. Leiden - Boston, Brill 2014.
P�ej�t k p�vodn�mu zdroji... - PECKA, Jind�ich (ed): Acta Contemporanea: K p�ta�edes�tin�m Vil�ma Pre�ana. Praha, �stav pro soudob� d�jiny AV �R 1998.
- RYB��OV�, Petra: Antisemitizmus v Uhorsku v 80. rokoch 19. storo�ia. Bratislava, Pro Historia 2010.
- SALNER, Peter (ed.): �idovsk� komunita po roku 1945. Bratislava, �stav etnol�gie SAV 2006.
- SALNER, Peter: Pre�ili holokaust. Bratislava, Veda - �stav etnol�gie Slovenskej akad�mie vied 1997.
- SOKOLOVI�, Peter (ed.): Perzek�cie na Slovensku v rokoch 1938-1945. Pre�ov, �stav pam�ti n�roda 2008.
- SOUKUP, Ladislav - MAL�, Karel (ed.): V�voj pr�va v �eskoslovensku v letech 1945-1989. Praha, Karolinum 2004.
- SZAB�, Miloslav. Od slov k �inom: Slovensk� n�rodn� hnutie a antisemitizmus (1875-1922). Bratislava, Kalligram 2014.
- �I�JAKOV�, Jana: �idovsk� rodina v konfront�cii s povojnovou situ�ciou a antisemitizmom na Slovensku (1945-1948). In: Forum Historiae [online], 2009, ro�. 3, �. 1 [cit. 2016-03-10]. Dostupn� z: http://www.forumhistoriae.sk/FH1_2009/texty_1_2009/sisjakova.pdf.
- VRZGULOV�, Monika - RICHTEROV�, Daniela (ed.): Holokaust ako historick� a mor�lny probl�m v minulosti a v s��asnosti. Bratislava, �evt, a.s. pre �rad vl�dy SR a DHS 2008.
- VRZGULOV�, Monika - SALNER, Peter (ed.): Reflexie holokaustu. Bratislava, Dokumenta�n� stredisko holokaustu 2010.
- WYMAN, David S. - ROSENZVEIG, Charles H. (ed.): The World Reacts to the Holocaust. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press 1996.
P�ej�t k p�vodn�mu zdroji...
Tento �l�nek je publikov�n v re�imu tzv. otev�en�ho p��stupu k v�deck�m informac�m (Open Access), kter� je distribuov�n pod licenc� Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC 4.0), kter� umo��uje nekomer�n� distribuci, reprodukci a zm�ny, pokud je p�vodn� d�lo ��dn� ocitov�no. Nen� povolena distribuce, reprodukce nebo zm�na, kter� nen� v souladu s podm�nkami t�to licence.


