Writer's Block: Next stop: Hollywood
Which book that you've read would make a great movie, and why? Who would you pick to play the main characters?
Let's play a game.
What's Stephanie's favourite book? You know, the one that doesn't start with "Harry Potter and the..." or take place in an Alabama boarding school?
That's right.
The Gatsby!
I nearly DIED when I saw that Baz Luhrmann is adapting the book to the screen! There's no such thing as a good Gatsby adaptation so far, and I'm sure this one will have its faults, but still. I HAVE A GATSBY FILM TO ANTICIPATE! Even if it's along the lines of Moulin Rouge! and Australia I will find a way to appreciate a glammed up, sensationalised version. All I pray is that Luhrmann pays strict attention to detail - HA! I do worry. This is a story which could do so damned well onscreen. The potential for sartorial, musical, emotional, and delicate beauty is all there. I wish I could be back in Grade 11 next year and discuss this film ad nauseum with my classmates. Or back in that adaptation class at uni! I don't know who on earth would come see this film with me, but you can guarantee I will be leaning forward in my seat, stunned into silent awe, or even horror. It will be MARVELOUS.
But then, good lord, then...
I found out some awful, horrendous, I'd-rather-go-blind-than-read-this news.
Have you seen the cast list?! It's a bleeding nightmare. Leonardo DiCaprio as Gatsby himself? REALLY?! I don't mind the man, no, and he's a far cry from being a bad actor. (Hello Revolutionary Road a.k.a. the Gatsby of the 1950s!) But I cannot see how his girly little voice and childish face will suit such a deep character at all. How can you get away with saying "ol' sport" when you sound and look like eunuch? Argh. And Ben Affleck as Tom Buchanan? I have a soft spot in my heart for Ben, being my first Hollywood crush, but the man is not an acting savant. Still, I have hope that he'll pull out all the stops for Tom, a role he undoubtedly has potential for. A rumoured Hayley Attwell as Jordan? Passable. Her duck-like face and unsympathetic acting may suit the bland, lesbian-esque (I LOVE YOU WOOD) character. Fine. Carey Mulligan as Daisy? I've never seen the girl do full-on adult characters, but aside from that she's a GENIUS choice. Daisy is easily the most frustrating and dimensional character, I think this could be Mulligan's oeuvre. Just please honey, practice your American accent.
No, the real tragedy - and it is a tragedy - is Luhrmann's crackpot idea that Tobey fucking Maguire will be a good Nick Carraway. I mean, come on. It's no great secret that possibly my least favourite film of all time is Spiderman. I have never in my long history of film-watching seen Tobey act anything with conviction, let alone empathy or grit. I want to weep at the idea of him as Nick, the flawed man who is narrating this whole beautiful story. JUST WEEP.
Summary? The idea of a 2012 film adaptation of one of my favourite novels of all time both fills me with delight and the darkest dread. I never even felt this strongly about the Harry Potter films! I did a whole lovely course on book>film adaptation. I know the risks, I know that critically-speaking, an adaptation cannot be better or worse only different. I'm sure I'll both reproach and exonerate it. But if you dare to adapt this story, of all stories, in any kind of earnest way - please, please Mr Luhrmann, do it right!
[In answering the original question... I'd love to see adaptations of David Nicholls' One Day, Diana Gabaldon's Outlander, and F. Scott Fitzgerald's This Side of Paradise. But mostly the first one. I think One Day would be incredibly moving and bittersweetly hilarious onscreen, though don't ask who could play Em and Dex!]
awake
satisfied
groggy
blank
giddy