(X-posted from my journal.)
I try to keep quiet about SMeyer and
Twilight. I've tried to read the books (I really have, I still have the PDFs on my desktop). I've tried to see what people can see in this. But even if I look past the writing, the grammar, the characters, etc, I cannot get past the fact that the entire series is, at its core, no more than puerile wish fulfillment. And I certainly won't deny the kernel of seething hate I feel that I can't muster the courage/confidence/connections to get published, and this hack has.
And then there's
crap like this, utter stupidity that makes me insane with rage.
I'll let you read it yourselves, if you care, but I can't resist reposting a comment I made in another LJer's thread:
SMeyer:
With writing, the way you feel changes everything.No. No it doesn't. If whim dictates your work, you're a hobbyist, not a writer. This is something I struggle with; that wherewithal to keep moving forward, regardless of the despondency I typically feel. Writing, if left entirely to inspiration and "feeling," would simply never happen.
SMeyer:
If I tried to write Midnight Sun now, in my current frame of mind, James would probably win and all the Cullens would die, which wouldn't dovetail too well with the original story.So what she's saying is, again, whim - rather than plot or character - dictates story. Just... whatever she feels like at the time.
Wanker.