And now onto the contrast to the 'angry artist' ... Milt's story is filled with hope, and goodness and the desire to bring wonderful things into the world. The contrast of the two was breathtaking. So different in approach, yet somehow so very similar!
Milton Glaser
Color:
Everything was presented in its natural, full color. By that I mean, there was no de-saturation, and although some of his work was done in black and white or perhaps two color, it was planned in its design that way. I felt that some of his designs contained an interesting color combination; particularly the RMA logo as well as the bombs in the anniversary poster. I didn't pick up any particular pattern to the colors or the way the works were presented, but there was definitely more of them shown than in the prior story, and I'm sure that can be chalked up to the fact that Milt's been in the business longer than James.
Sound:
Milt's story didn't have the varied range in music that James' did, but there was a distinct, pleasing, lovely melody that was present throughout, with occasional bouts of silence to focus the viewer on Milt's voiceover, and that it was important to pay attention to. I loved the fact that a banjo was very prominently displayed near the beginning, a still that was focused just on it, and that after the 'tomato' poster, small banjo twangs were worked into the melody. It was a very nice, beautiful touch that somehow you noticed in the back of your mind even when you weren't actively focusing on the music itself. There was no music in the beginning at the question: 'Where am I going in Design?' and at the question: "Why do I teach?' ... indicating THIS artist's reasons to be. Very effective. Another place the music as well as the voice-over stopped was at the poster, 'Together' ... once more giving prominence to one of Milt's special points. He seems to be more about changing people in a cooperative way, whereas James seems to like to shock people into reality. Again, different approach, but each is successful in different degrees depending on the project itself. After the last moment of silence, a small tone starts, joined by a bit of banjo music, a few more elements and then as Milt climbs the staircase, physically and symbolically, the music swells and your ears are filled with beautiful, loving, hope-filled music. Wonderful.
Pacing:
The pacing for Milt's piece seemed to grow and continue and steadily to increase. It didn't jumped around quite as much as I feel James' did, and seemed to reflect what he spoke about as being one of the fortunate ones to be able to still experience the world as wonderful in the last 3rd of his life. The walk up the stairs at the last few frames, also underscore that. It was really a powerful scene, he was STILL climbing, still learning, still experiencing wonder. And it was a wonderful way to present that concept! (yes, I know ... that was a bit droll! :) ) I really enjoyed the way Hillman took parts of so many pieces on here, showed small sections of it, and then took awhile to show the whole thing. The longest drawn out tease was the Dylan poster and though the other story contained some of that, how it was treated here was incredible and very authentic. Very nicely done in fact.
Conclusion:
Both stories, though contrasted and differently handled, were very profound and in fact, the points the artists made were very profound and thought-provoking. Milt's take on GD was that as all art does, GD establishes similar experiences in those that view and assimilate it, and that that common ground, lessens that chances that those people will kill each other. James uses GD as a big club to knock sense into people, Milt uses it to establish common ground, build up more communication, and to keep conflict from taking place. I think both of their views on GD are both valid, and very effective. Nice job on both of these pieces.