The Girl Who Wasn't Feminist Enough
I had various strains of an interesting argument about the best modern uses of feminism that I was considering turning into a post, but instead I just need to let off a rant:
I don't remember your name and I don't care, but to whomever wrote in Entertainment Weekly that Lizbeth Salander might not be a good feminist character I say.... You're an idiot.
Either that, or someone threw a dart at all their female employees to choose who would give a response to that question and that's how you wound up so out of your depth. One or the other.
Her argument against this character being a good or proper feminist character (I'm too peeved to reread the exact wording) is because she sleeps with a male character and doesn't like her body shape.
REALLY, E.W.? YOU PUBLISHED THIS?
So if she was 100% lesbian instead of 'just' bisexual, and if she sang I'm Every Woman when she devotes hours, days, weeks of her life to fighting back against men who hate and abuse women, instead of sometimes looking at her body and experiencing doubts about it - like a human being - then and only then you'd approve of her?
I don't know what feminism is. But for it to mean anything it has to be more than just running our thoughts and actions by a different set of pundits.
Also, let the record reflect she is described as having the physique of a teenage boy. So, yeah, that she wonders about how much of a turn on it may or may not be for her lovers seems normal. Which I assume is the verboten aspect of the character.
That's right. Someone looked at LIZBETH SALANDER and decided she's too normal. If you need to take a moment after processing that thought, I'm right there with 'ya.
Gah. Just wake me when it stops being a shock that we're people.
( Collapse )
Now if you want to debate the Mary/Gary-Stu-ness of the writing, that could be a whole other story...
I don't remember your name and I don't care, but to whomever wrote in Entertainment Weekly that Lizbeth Salander might not be a good feminist character I say.... You're an idiot.
Either that, or someone threw a dart at all their female employees to choose who would give a response to that question and that's how you wound up so out of your depth. One or the other.
Her argument against this character being a good or proper feminist character (I'm too peeved to reread the exact wording) is because she sleeps with a male character and doesn't like her body shape.
REALLY, E.W.? YOU PUBLISHED THIS?
So if she was 100% lesbian instead of 'just' bisexual, and if she sang I'm Every Woman when she devotes hours, days, weeks of her life to fighting back against men who hate and abuse women, instead of sometimes looking at her body and experiencing doubts about it - like a human being - then and only then you'd approve of her?
I don't know what feminism is. But for it to mean anything it has to be more than just running our thoughts and actions by a different set of pundits.
Also, let the record reflect she is described as having the physique of a teenage boy. So, yeah, that she wonders about how much of a turn on it may or may not be for her lovers seems normal. Which I assume is the verboten aspect of the character.
That's right. Someone looked at LIZBETH SALANDER and decided she's too normal. If you need to take a moment after processing that thought, I'm right there with 'ya.
Gah. Just wake me when it stops being a shock that we're people.
( Collapse )
Now if you want to debate the Mary/Gary-Stu-ness of the writing, that could be a whole other story...
