This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse.
Show this post
I don’t have this reissue, but imo the first question that should be asked is whether r226506 should be restored to the Ice Cube - AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted m97462 MR? If so, then gatefold is ok in the FTF. If not, then all of the other versions with the Kill At Will bonus tracks should be removed from the existing MR and a new one should be created.
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse.
Show this post
berothbr I don’t have this reissue, but imo the first question that should be asked is whether r226506 should be restored to the Ice Cube - AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted m97462 MR? If so, then gatefold is ok in the FTF. If not, then all of the other versions with the Kill At Will bonus tracks should be removed from the existing MR and a new one should be created.
This seems like a comp that should get its own MR to me. Anyone disagree?
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse.
Show this post
the_mean This seems like a comp that should get its own MR to me
I don’t know. It meets the criteria under RSG §16.2.1 for a MR and RSG §16.2.3 says:
“Releases that combine two albums can't be on the same Master release as the individual albums.”
This is an album + an EP, so it’s not explicitly prohibited by RSG §16.2.3
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse.
Show this post
Seem like RSG §6.16.4 makes this a Compilation. Can/should Compilations be in the same MR as the one of the releases combined?
To a certain extent, this is fuzzy, which is probably why the vinyl version is currently on its own. It is presented like a compilation of the two releases (back cover is Kill At Will.) However, the CD versions make it look like the Kill At Will tracks are bonus tracks.
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse.
Show this post
the_mean Seem like RSG §6.16.4 makes this a Compilation
Yet [g6.16,6] says “Releases reissued with bonus or extra tracks should not be tagged as a compilation”. An argument can be made that those are just bonus tracks. Imo this is very debatable and just needs a few opinions to be sorted.