The typical answer for this is that you should use a service for this purpose. Here's some general information about this: http://docs.angularjs.org/guide/dev_guide.services.understanding_services
Here is a plunk with code modeled after your own starting example:
Example code:
var app = angular.module('savingServiceDemo', []);
app.service('savingService', function() {
return {
somethingOrOther: {
save: function(obj, callback) {
console.log('Saved:');
console.dir(obj);
callback(obj, {});
}
}
};
});
app.directive('saveable', ['savingService', function(savingService) {
return {
restrict: 'A',
link: function(scope) {
scope.saveModel = function(question) {
savingService.somethingOrOther.save(
{
id: question.id,
answer: question.value
},
function(response, getResponseHeaders) {
// a bunch of post-processing
}
);
}
}
};
}]);
app.controller('questionController', ['$scope', function($scope) {
$scope.question = {
question: 'What kind of AngularJS object should you create to contain data access or network communication logic?',
id: 1,
value: ''
};
}]);
The relevant HTML markup:
<body ng-controller="questionController">
<h3>Question<h3>
<h4>{{question.question}}</h4>
Your answer: <input ng-model="question.value" saveable ng-blur="saveModel(question)" />
</body>
An alternative using only factory and the existing ngResource service:
However, you could also utilize factory and ngResource in a way that would let you reuse some of the common "saving logic", while still giving you the ability to provide variation for distinct types of objects / data that you wish to save or query. And, this way still results in just a single instantiation of the saver for your specific object type.
Example using MongoLab collections
I've done something like this to make it easier to use MongoLab collections.
Here's a plunk.
The gist of the idea is this snippet:
var dbUrl = "https://api.mongolab.com/api/1/databases/YOURDB/collections";
var apiKey = "YOUR API KEY";
var collections = [
"user",
"question",
"like"
];
for(var i = 0; i < collections.length; i++) {
var collectionName = collections[i];
app.factory(collectionName, ['$resource', function($resource) {
var resourceConstructor = createResource($resource, dbUrl, collectionName, apiKey);
var svc = new resourceConstructor();
// modify behavior if you want to override defaults
return svc;
}]);
}
Notes:
dbUrl and apiKey would be, of course, specific to your own MongoLab info- The array in this case is a group of distinct collections that you want individual ngResource-derived instances of
- There is a
createResource function defined (which you can see in the plunk and in the code below) that actually handles creating a constructor with an ngResource prototype.
- If you wanted, you could modify the
svc instance to vary its behavior by collection type
- When you blur the input field, this will invoke the dummy
consoleLog function and just write some debug info to the console for illustration purposes.
- This also prints the number of times the
createResource function itself was called, as a way to demonstrate that, even though there are actually two controllers, questionController and questionController2 asking for the same injections, the factories get called only 3 times in total.
- Note: updateSafe is a function I like to use with MongoLab that allows you to apply a partial update, basically a PATCH. Otherwise, if you only send a few properties, the entire document will get overwritten with ONLY those properties! No good!
Full code:
HTML:
<body>
<div ng-controller="questionController">
<h3>Question<h3>
<h4>{{question.question}}</h4>
Your answer: <input ng-model="question.value" saveable ng-blur="save(question)" />
</div>
<div ng-controller="questionController2">
<h3>Question<h3>
<h4>{{question.question}}</h4>
Your answer: <input ng-model="question.value" saveable ng-blur="save(question)" />
</div>
</body>
JavaScript:
(function() {
var app = angular.module('savingServiceDemo', ['ngResource']);
var numberOfTimesCreateResourceGetsInvokedShouldStopAt3 = 0;
function createResource(resourceService, resourcePath, resourceName, apiKey) {
numberOfTimesCreateResourceGetsInvokedShouldStopAt3++;
var resource = resourceService(resourcePath + '/' + resourceName + '/:id',
{
apiKey: apiKey
},
{
update:
{
method: 'PUT'
}
}
);
resource.prototype.consoleLog = function (val, cb) {
console.log("The numberOfTimesCreateResourceGetsInvokedShouldStopAt3 counter is at: " + numberOfTimesCreateResourceGetsInvokedShouldStopAt3);
console.log('Logging:');
console.log(val);
console.log('this =');
console.log(this);
if (cb) {
cb();
}
};
resource.prototype.update = function (cb) {
return resource.update({
id: this._id.$oid
},
angular.extend({}, this, {
_id: undefined
}), cb);
};
resource.prototype.updateSafe = function (patch, cb) {
resource.get({id:this._id.$oid}, function(obj) {
for(var prop in patch) {
obj[prop] = patch[prop];
}
obj.update(cb);
});
};
resource.prototype.destroy = function (cb) {
return resource.remove({
id: this._id.$oid
}, cb);
};
return resource;
}
var dbUrl = "https://api.mongolab.com/api/1/databases/YOURDB/collections";
var apiKey = "YOUR API KEY";
var collections = [
"user",
"question",
"like"
];
for(var i = 0; i < collections.length; i++) {
var collectionName = collections[i];
app.factory(collectionName, ['$resource', function($resource) {
var resourceConstructor = createResource($resource, dbUrl, collectionName, apiKey);
var svc = new resourceConstructor();
// modify behavior if you want to override defaults
return svc;
}]);
}
app.controller('questionController', ['$scope', 'user', 'question', 'like',
function($scope, user, question, like) {
$scope.question = {
question: 'What kind of AngularJS object should you create to contain data access or network communication logic?',
id: 1,
value: ''
};
$scope.save = function(obj) {
question.consoleLog(obj, function() {
console.log('And, I got called back');
});
};
}]);
app.controller('questionController2', ['$scope', 'user', 'question', 'like',
function($scope, user, question, like) {
$scope.question = {
question: 'What is the coolest JS framework of them all?',
id: 1,
value: ''
};
$scope.save = function(obj) {
question.consoleLog(obj, function() {
console.log('You better have said AngularJS');
});
};
}]);
})();
