147

I've got almost the same question as here.

I have an array which contains aa ab aa ac aa ad, etc. Now I want to select all unique elements from this array. Thought, this would be simple with sort | uniq or with sort -u as they mentioned in that other question, but nothing changed in the array... The code is:

echo `echo "${ids[@]}" | sort | uniq`

What am I doing wrong?

0

17 Answers 17

191

A bit hacky, but this should do it:

echo "${ids[@]}" | tr ' ' '\n' | sort -u | tr '\n' ' '

To save the sorted unique results back into an array, do Array assignment:

sorted_unique_ids=($(echo "${ids[@]}" | tr ' ' '\n' | sort -u | tr '\n' ' '))

If your shell supports herestrings (bash should), you can spare an echo process by altering it to:

tr ' ' '\n' <<< "${ids[@]}" | sort -u | tr '\n' ' '

A note as of Aug 28 2021:

According to ShellCheck wiki 2207 a read -a pipe should be used to avoid splitting. Thus, in bash the command would be:

IFS=" " read -r -a ids <<< "$(echo "${ids[@]}" | tr ' ' '\n' | sort -u | tr '\n' ' ')"

or

IFS=" " read -r -a ids <<< "$(tr ' ' '\n' <<< "${ids[@]}" | sort -u | tr '\n' ' ')"

Input:

ids=(aa ab aa ac aa ad)

Output:

aa ab ac ad

Explanation:

  • "${ids[@]}" - Syntax for working with shell arrays, whether used as part of echo or a herestring. The @ part means "all elements in the array"
  • tr ' ' '\n' - Convert all spaces to newlines. Because your array is seen by shell as elements on a single line, separated by spaces; and because sort expects input to be on separate lines.
  • sort -u - sort and retain only unique elements
  • tr '\n' ' ' - convert the newlines we added in earlier back to spaces.
  • $(...) - Command Substitution
  • Aside: tr ' ' '\n' <<< "${ids[@]}" is a more efficient way of doing: echo "${ids[@]}" | tr ' ' '\n'
Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

11 Comments

+1. A bit tidier: store uniq elements in a new array: uniq=($(printf "%s\n" "${ids[@]}" | sort -u)); echo "${uniq[@]}"
+1 I'm not sure if this is an isolated case, but putting unique items back into an array needed additional parentheses such as: sorted_unique_ids=($(echo "${ids[@]}" | tr ' ' '\n' | sort -u | tr '\n' ' ')). Without the additional parentheses it was giving it as a string.
If you don't want to alter the order of the elements, use ... | uniq | ... instead of ... | sort -u | ....
@Jesse, uniq only removes consecutive duplicates. In the example in this answer, sorted_unique_ids will end up identical to the original ids. To preserve order, try ... | awk '!seen[$0]++'. See also stackoverflow.com/questions/1444406/….
-1: This breaks array elements containing a space into multiple values, which (to me) is one of the main benefits of using arrays over simple space-delimited strings.
|
48

If you're running Bash version 4 or above (which should be the case in any modern version of Linux), you can get unique array values in bash by creating a new associative array that contains each of the values of the original array. Something like this:

$ a=(aa ac aa ad "ac ad")
$ declare -A b
$ for i in "${a[@]}"; do b["$i"]=1; done
$ printf '%s\n' "${!b[@]}"
ac ad
ac
aa
ad

This works because in any array (associative or traditional, in any language), each key can only appear once. When the for loop arrives at the second value of aa in a[2], it overwrites b[aa] which was set originally for a[0].

Doing things in native bash can be faster than using pipes and external tools like sort and uniq, though for larger datasets you'll likely see better performance if you use a more powerful language like awk, python, etc.

If you're feeling confident, you can avoid the for loop by using printf's ability to recycle its format for multiple arguments, though this seems to require eval. (Stop reading now if you're fine with that.)

$ eval b=( $(printf ' ["%s"]=1' "${a[@]}") )
$ declare -p b
declare -A b=(["ac ad"]="1" [ac]="1" [aa]="1" [ad]="1" )

The reason this solution requires eval is that array values are determined before word splitting. That means that the output of the command substitution is considered a single word rather than a set of key=value pairs.

While this uses a subshell, it uses only bash builtins to process the array values. Be sure to evaluate your use of eval with a critical eye. If you're not 100% confident that chepner or glenn jackman or greycat would find no fault with your code, use the for loop instead.

7 Comments

produces error: expression recursion level exceeded
@Benubird - can you perhaps pastebin your terminal contents? It works perfectly for me, so my best guess is that you've got (1) a typo, (2) an older version of bash (associative arrays were added to v4), or (3) a ridiculously large influx of cosmic background radiation caused by the quantum black hole in your neighbour's basement, generating interference with the signals within your computer.
can't, didn't keep the one that didn't work. but, I tried running yours just now and it worked, so probably the cosmic radiation thing.
guessing that this answer utilizes bash v4 (associative arrays) and if someone tries in bash v3 it wont work (probably not what @Benubird saw). Bash v3 is still default in many envs
@nhed, point taken. I see that my up-to-date Yosemite Macbook has the same version in base, though I've installed v4 from macports. This question is tagged "linux", but I've updated my answer to point out the requirement.
|
35

I realize this was already answered, but it showed up pretty high in search results, and it might help someone.

printf "%s\n" "${IDS[@]}" | sort -u

Example:

~> IDS=( "aa" "ab" "aa" "ac" "aa" "ad" )
~> echo  "${IDS[@]}"
aa ab aa ac aa ad
~>
~> printf "%s\n" "${IDS[@]}" | sort -u
aa
ab
ac
ad
~> UNIQ_IDS=($(printf "%s\n" "${IDS[@]}" | sort -u))
~> echo "${UNIQ_IDS[@]}"
aa ab ac ad
~>

5 Comments

to fix the array I was forced to do this: ids=(ab "a a" ac aa ad ac aa);IFS=$'\n' ids2=(`printf "%s\n" "${ids[@]}" |sort -u`), so I added IFS=$'\n' suggested by @gniourf_gniourf
I also had to backup and, after the command, restore IFS value! or it messes other things..
@Jetse This should be the accepted answer as it uses only two commands, no loops, no eval and is the most compact version.
@AquariusPower Careful, you are basically doing: IFS=$'\n'; ids2=(...), since temporary assignment before variable assignments is not possible. Instead use this construction: IFS=$'\n' read -r -a ids2 <<<"$(printf "%s\n" "${ids[@]}" | sort -u)".
Shell check says no: SC2207, better use mapfile -t UNIQ_IDS < <(printf "%s\n" "${IDS[@]}" | sort -u).
19

If your array elements have white space or any other shell special character (and can you be sure they don't?) then to capture those first of all (and you should just always do this) express your array in double quotes! e.g. "${a[@]}". Bash will literally interpret this as "each array element in a separate argument". Within bash this simply always works, always.

Then, to get a sorted (and unique) array, we have to convert it to a format sort understands and be able to convert it back into bash array elements. This is the best I've come up with:

eval a=($(printf "%q\n" "${a[@]}" | sort -u))

Unfortunately, this fails in the special case of the empty array, turning the empty array into an array of 1 empty element (because printf had 0 arguments but still prints as though it had one empty argument - see explanation). So you have to catch that in an if or something.

Explanation: The %q format for printf "shell escapes" the printed argument, in just such a way as bash can recover in something like eval! Because each element is printed shell escaped on it's own line, the only separator between elements is the newline, and the array assignment takes each line as an element, parsing the escaped values into literal text.

e.g.

> a=("foo bar" baz)
> printf "%q\n" "${a[@]}"
'foo bar'
baz
> printf "%q\n"
''

The eval is necessary to strip the escaping off each value going back into the array.

6 Comments

This is the only code that worked for me because my array of strings had spaces. The %q is what did the trick. Thanks :)
And if you don't want to alter the order of the elements, use uniq instead of sort -u.
Note that uniq does not work properly on unsorted lists, so it must always be used in combination with sort.
uniq on an unsorted list will remove consecutive duplicates. It will not remove identical list elements separated by something else inbetween. uniq may be useful enough depending on the expected data and the desire to maintain original order.
Can someone tell me why I need %q over %s?
|
15

'sort' can be used to order the output of a for-loop:

for i in ${ids[@]}; do echo $i; done | sort

and eliminate duplicates with "-u":

for i in ${ids[@]}; do echo $i; done | sort -u

Finally you can just overwrite your array with the unique elements:

ids=( `for i in ${ids[@]}; do echo $i; done | sort -u` )

2 Comments

And if you don't want to change the order of what's left, you don't have to: ids=( `for i in ${ids[@]}; do echo $i; done | uniq` )
Note, however, that if you don't change the order, you also won't get the desired result, as uniq only removes adjacent duplicate lines.
12

this one will also preserve order:

echo ${ARRAY[@]} | tr [:space:] '\n' | awk '!a[$0]++'

and to modify the original array with the unique values:

ARRAY=($(echo ${ARRAY[@]} | tr [:space:] '\n' | awk '!a[$0]++'))

2 Comments

Don't use uniq. It needs sorting, where awk does not, and the intent of this answer is to preserve ordering when the input is unsorted.
Btw this example was made famous by this blog post: catonmat.net/awk-one-liners-explained-part-two. What a fascinating awk one-liner
11

To create a new array consisting of unique values, ensure your array is not empty then do one of the following:

Remove duplicate entries (with sorting)

readarray -t NewArray < <(printf '%s\n' "${OriginalArray[@]}" | sort -u)

Remove duplicate entries (without sorting)

readarray -t NewArray < <(printf '%s\n' "${OriginalArray[@]}" | awk '!x[$0]++')

Warning: Do not try to do something like NewArray=( $(printf '%s\n' "${OriginalArray[@]}" | sort -u) ). It will break on spaces.

3 Comments

Remove duplicate entries (without sorting) is just like (with sorting) except change sort -u to be uniq.
@JesseChisholm uniq only merges duplicate lines that are adjacent, so it's not the same as awk '!x[$0]++'.
@JesseChisholm Please to delete misleading comment.
9

How about this variation?

printf '%s\n' "${ids[@]}" | sort -u

2 Comments

And then sorted_arr=($(printf '%s\n' "${ids[@]}" | sort -u).
Same answer as @das.cyklone
5

Without loosing the original ordering:

uniques=($(tr ' ' '\n' <<<"${original[@]}" | awk '!u[$0]++' | tr '\n' ' '))

Comments

5

If you want a solution that only uses bash internals, you can set the values as keys in an associative array, and then extract the keys:

declare -A uniqs
list=(foo bar bar "bar none")
for f in "${list[@]}"; do 
  uniqs["${f}"]=""
done

for thing in "${!uniqs[@]}"; do
  echo "${thing}"
done

This will output

bar
foo
bar none

3 Comments

I just noticed this is essentially the same as @ghotis answer above, except his solution doesn't take list items with spaces into account.
Good point. I've added quotes to my solution so it now handles spaces. I originally wrote it merely to handle the sample data in the question, but it's always good to cover contingencies like this. Thanks for the suggestion.
Note that order isn't maintained in an associative array: stackoverflow.com/a/29161460/89484
5

cat number.txt

1 2 3 4 4 3 2 5 6

print line into column: cat number.txt | awk '{for(i=1;i<=NF;i++) print $i}'

1
2
3
4
4
3
2
5
6

find the duplicate records: cat number.txt | awk '{for(i=1;i<=NF;i++) print $i}' |awk 'x[$0]++'

4
3
2

Replace duplicate records: cat number.txt | awk '{for(i=1;i<=NF;i++) print $i}' |awk '!x[$0]++'

1
2
3
4
5
6

Find only Uniq records: cat number.txt | awk '{for(i=1;i<=NF;i++) print $i|"sort|uniq -u"}

1
5
6

Comments

3

Another option for dealing with embedded whitespace, is to null-delimit with printf, make distinct with sort, then use a loop to pack it back into an array:

input=(a b c "$(printf "d\ne")" b c "$(printf "d\ne")")
output=()

while read -rd $'' element
do 
  output+=("$element")
done < <(printf "%s\0" "${input[@]}" | sort -uz)

At the end of this, input and output contain the desired values (provided order isn't important):

$ printf "%q\n" "${input[@]}"
a
b
c
$'d\ne'
b
c
$'d\ne'

$ printf "%q\n" "${output[@]}"
a
b
c
$'d\ne'

Comments

2

All the following work in bash and sh and are without error in shellcheck but you need to suppress SC2207

arrOrig=("192.168.3.4" "192.168.3.4" "192.168.3.3")

# NO SORTING
# shellcheck disable=SC2207
arr1=($(tr ' ' '\n' <<<"${arrOrig[@]}" | awk '!u[$0]++' | tr '\n' ' ')) # @estani
len1=${#arr1[@]}
echo "${len1}"
echo "${arr1[*]}"

# SORTING
# shellcheck disable=SC2207
arr2=($(printf '%s\n' "${arrOrig[@]}" | sort -u)) # @das.cyklone
len2=${#arr2[@]}
echo "${len2}"
echo "${arr2[*]}"

# SORTING
# shellcheck disable=SC2207
arr3=($(echo "${arrOrig[@]}" | tr ' ' '\n' | sort -u | tr '\n' ' ')) # @sampson-chen
len3=${#arr3[@]}
echo "${len3}"
echo "${arr3[*]}"

# SORTING
# shellcheck disable=SC2207
arr4=($(for i in "${arrOrig[@]}"; do echo "${i}"; done | sort -u)) # @corbyn42
len4=${#arr4[@]}
echo "${len4}"
echo "${arr4[*]}"

# NO SORTING
# shellcheck disable=SC2207
arr5=($(echo "${arrOrig[@]}" | tr "[:space:]" '\n' | awk '!a[$0]++')) # @faustus
len5=${#arr5[@]}
echo "${len5}"
echo "${arr5[*]}"

# OUTPUTS

# arr1
2 # length
192.168.3.4 192.168.3.3 # items

# arr2
2 # length
192.168.3.3 192.168.3.4 # items

# arr3
2 # length
192.168.3.3 192.168.3.4 # items

# arr4
2 # length
192.168.3.3 192.168.3.4 # items

# arr5
2 # length
192.168.3.4 192.168.3.3 # items

Output for all of these is 2 and correct. This answer basically summarises and tidies up the other answers in this post and is a useful quick reference. Attribution to original answer is given.

Comments

1

In zsh you can use (u) flag:

$ ids=(aa ab aa ac aa ad)
$ print ${(u)ids}
aa ab ac ad

1 Comment

The question was aimed at bash not zsh.
0

Try this to get uniq values for first column in file

awk -F, '{a[$1];}END{for (i in a)print i;}'

Comments

0

BASH single liner, without changing order, and having items with spaces:

readarray -t my_array < <( (for i in "${my_array[@]}"; do echo "$i"; done) | awk '!uniq[$0]++' )

Comments

-2
# Read a file into variable
lines=$(cat /path/to/my/file)

# Go through each line the file put in the variable, and assign it a variable called $line
for line in $lines; do
  # Print the line
  echo $line
# End the loop, then sort it (add -u to have unique lines)
done | sort -u

Comments

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.