1154

I'm trying to perform a LINQ query on a DataTable object and bizarrely I am finding that performing such queries on DataTables is not straightforward. For example:

var results = from myRow in myDataTable
where results.Field("RowNo") == 1
select results;

This is not allowed. How do I get something like this working?

I'm amazed that LINQ queries are not allowed on DataTables!

5
  • 3
    You can find more LINQ/Lambda example from webmingle.blogspot.com/2010_09_01_archive.html Commented Feb 17, 2011 at 19:18
  • It's because datatables predate LINQ by some number of years. Use a strongly typed datatable instead; a better experience all round than this stringly-typed, intellisense-defeating dt.Rows["FirstName] junk.. With a strongly typed table (add a DataSet type file to your project and create tables inside it in the visual designer) you just write e.g. myStronglyTpedDataset.Person.Where(p => p.FirstName == "John") - all the magic to make it happen is already done Commented Nov 25, 2020 at 11:11
  • @CaiusJard does that mean that you would have to create DataSet type file for every query? Commented Apr 29, 2021 at 13:46
  • Not for every query, no. The dataset represents the entities being modelled, so in the same way that you might have an Order entity that has a list of Product entity in an EF application, your strongly typed dataset has a OrdersDataTable that has a relation to a ProductsDataTable. It's similar effort to create them too if you have a DB, as EF can scaffold entities from an existing db, as can the dataset designer. If you were adding new entities to your code it's slightly easier with datasets; you just click click add a table, click add columns etc and in the background VS is writing your code Commented Apr 29, 2021 at 14:48
  • So all that's necessary here is one AsEnumerable() call. No idea why that requires so many answers. Commented Sep 23, 2021 at 13:24

22 Answers 22

1421

You can't query against the DataTable's Rows collection, since DataRowCollection doesn't implement IEnumerable<T>. You need to use the AsEnumerable() extension for DataTable. Like so:

var results = from myRow in myDataTable.AsEnumerable()
where myRow.Field<int>("RowNo") == 1
select myRow;

And as @Keith says, you'll need to add a reference to System.Data.DataSetExtensions

AsEnumerable() returns IEnumerable<DataRow>. If you need to convert IEnumerable<DataRow> to a DataTable, use the CopyToDataTable() extension.

Below is query with Lambda Expression,

var result = myDataTable
    .AsEnumerable()
    .Where(myRow => myRow.Field<int>("RowNo") == 1);
Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

8 Comments

VB Version: Dim results = From myRow In myDataTable.AsEnumerable _ Where myRow.Field("RowNo") = 1 _ Select myRow
I already had a reference to the dll mentioned, but was missing using System.Data;
VB Version needs to insert (Of String) between myRow.Field and ("RowNo"). That part should read: myRow.Field(Of String)("RowNo") = 1 - Reference @Cros comment.
this solution is needlessly complicated. Use myDataTable.Rows instead as @JoelFan suggested.
@Markus Just to clarify, the reason that @JoelFan's solution works with myDataTable.Rows is because the myRow variable is explicitly cast to DataRow. When it is compiled, that query is rewritten to myDataTable.Rows.Cast<DataRow>().Where(myRow => (int)myRow["RowNo"] == 1). Personally, I don't find the call to AsEnumerable() any more complicated than the call to Cast<DataRow>(). As far as I know, the performance is the same, so it's just a matter of preference.
|
142
var results = from DataRow myRow in myDataTable.Rows
    where (int)myRow["RowNo"] == 1
    select myRow

3 Comments

What about for selecting multiple rows, instead of just row 1?
Just remove the "where" line and you will get all the rows
Yes, this is how I use to do it, except for replacing (int)myRow["RowNo"] with the generic form myRow.Field<int>("RowNo") to more conveniently support nullable types.
75

It's not that they were deliberately not allowed on DataTables, it's just that DataTables pre-date the IQueryable and generic IEnumerable constructs on which Linq queries can be performed.

Both interfaces require some sort type-safety validation. DataTables are not strongly typed. This is the same reason why people can't query against an ArrayList, for example.

For Linq to work you need to map your results against type-safe objects and query against that instead.

Comments

54

As @ch00k said:

using System.Data; //needed for the extension methods to work

...

var results = 
    from myRow in myDataTable.Rows 
    where myRow.Field<int>("RowNo") == 1 
    select myRow; //select the thing you want, not the collection

You also need to add a project reference to System.Data.DataSetExtensions

5 Comments

If you try this, you'll find it won't work unless you put a specific type on myRow or use Cast<DataRow>() on Rows. Better to use AsEnumerable().
@NetMage this worked 12 years ago when I posted it. As long as you have System.Linq and System.Data.DataSetExtensions then myDataTable.Rows returns an enumerable collection of DataRow anyway. That might have changed, it's been a decade since I've used it.
Interesting - I guess it was changed at some point, as it doesn't work on .Net or .Net Core now.
@NetMage yes, I'm not surprised the DataSet extensions didn't make it into .NET Core or .NET Standard, they were already outdated when I posted this answer. I really wouldn't use DataSet in new projects, there are far better data access models, both for ease of coding and performance.
They are there, but DataRowCollection doesn't implement IEnumerable<T> just IEnumerable and so doesn't work with strongly typed LINQ.
48

I realize this has been answered a few times over, but just to offer another approach:

I like to use the .Cast<T>() method, it helps me maintain sanity in seeing the explicit type defined and deep down I think .AsEnumerable() calls it anyways:

var results = from myRow in myDataTable.Rows.Cast<DataRow>() 
                  where myRow.Field<int>("RowNo") == 1 select myRow;

or

var results = myDataTable.Rows.Cast<DataRow>()
                  .FirstOrDefault(x => x.Field<int>("RowNo") == 1);

As noted in comments, does not require System.Data.DataSetExtensions or any other assemblies (Reference)

1 Comment

This works without referencing System.Data.DataSetExtensions.
41
var query = from p in dt.AsEnumerable()
                    where p.Field<string>("code") == this.txtCat.Text
                    select new
                    {
                        name = p.Field<string>("name"),
                        age= p.Field<int>("age")                         
                    };

the name and age fields are now part of the query object and can be accessed like so: Console.WriteLine(query.name);

1 Comment

How I use name? For example, MessageBox.Show(name) is undefined.
34

Using LINQ to manipulate data in DataSet/DataTable

var results = from myRow in tblCurrentStock.AsEnumerable()
              where myRow.Field<string>("item_name").ToUpper().StartsWith(tbSearchItem.Text.ToUpper())
              select myRow;
DataView view = results.AsDataView();

2 Comments

The AsDataView doesn't appear in Intellisense for me. I included using System.Data.Linq and using System.Linq but still it's not working. Do you know what am I missing? Thanks in advance.
@Naomi It comes from System.Data.DataSetExtensions.
30
//Create DataTable 
DataTable dt= new DataTable();
dt.Columns.AddRange(new DataColumn[]
{
   new DataColumn("ID",typeof(System.Int32)),
   new DataColumn("Name",typeof(System.String))

});

//Fill with data

dt.Rows.Add(new Object[]{1,"Test1"});
dt.Rows.Add(new Object[]{2,"Test2"});

//Now  Query DataTable with linq
//To work with linq it should required our source implement IEnumerable interface.
//But DataTable not Implement IEnumerable interface
//So we call DataTable Extension method  i.e AsEnumerable() this will return EnumerableRowCollection<DataRow>


// Now Query DataTable to find Row whoes ID=1

DataRow drow = dt.AsEnumerable().Where(p=>p.Field<Int32>(0)==1).FirstOrDefault();
 // 

Comments

25

Try this simple line of query:

var result=myDataTable.AsEnumerable().Where(myRow => myRow.Field<int>("RowNo") == 1);

Comments

17

You can use LINQ to objects on the Rows collection, like so:

var results = from myRow in myDataTable.Rows where myRow.Field("RowNo") == 1 select myRow;

3 Comments

Because DataTable.Rows does not implement IEnumerable, I can't see how this query could compile.
@onedaywhen I just saw this being done in some code and it does compile. Trying to figure out why right now.
... or you can just use a filter expression within the Select method : var results = myDataTable.Select("RowNo=1"); This returns a DataRow array.
14

This is a simple way that works for me and uses lambda expressions:

var results = myDataTable.Select("").FirstOrDefault(x => (int)x["RowNo"] == 1)

Then if you want a particular value:

if(results != null) 
    var foo = results["ColName"].ToString()

Comments

11

Try this

var row = (from result in dt.AsEnumerable().OrderBy( result => Guid.NewGuid()) select result).Take(3) ; 

Comments

11

Most likely, the classes for the DataSet, DataTable and DataRow are already defined in the solution. If that's the case you won't need the DataSetExtensions reference.

Ex. DataSet class name-> CustomSet, DataRow class name-> CustomTableRow (with defined columns: RowNo, ...)

var result = from myRow in myDataTable.Rows.OfType<CustomSet.CustomTableRow>()
             where myRow.RowNo == 1
             select myRow;

Or (as I prefer)

var result = myDataTable.Rows.OfType<CustomSet.CustomTableRow>().Where(myRow => myRow.RowNo);

Comments

9
var results = from myRow in myDataTable
where results.Field<Int32>("RowNo") == 1
select results;

1 Comment

This answer as a lot of issues with it.
8

In my application I found that using LINQ to Datasets with the AsEnumerable() extension for DataTable as suggested in the answer was extremely slow. If you're interested in optimizing for speed, use James Newtonking's Json.Net library (http://james.newtonking.com/json/help/index.html)

// Serialize the DataTable to a json string
string serializedTable = JsonConvert.SerializeObject(myDataTable);    
Jarray dataRows = Jarray.Parse(serializedTable);

// Run the LINQ query
List<JToken> results = (from row in dataRows
                    where (int) row["ans_key"] == 42
                    select row).ToList();

// If you need the results to be in a DataTable
string jsonResults = JsonConvert.SerializeObject(results);
DataTable resultsTable = JsonConvert.DeserializeObject<DataTable>(jsonResults);

2 Comments

I doubt this is faster, in the general cases. It has the overhead of two serialization, one deserialization and one parsing operations. Regardless, I downvoted because it is not concise, i.e. the serialization/deserialization doesn't make clear that the intent is to filter a list.
@an phu, using the .AsEnumerable extension method creates a collection of heavyweight System.Data.DataRow objects. The serialized and parsed data table creates lightweight data consisting only of the column names and values of each row. When the query runs, it will load the data into memory, which for a large dataset may involve swapping. Sometimes, the overhead of several operations is less than the overhead of copying large amounts of data in and out of memory.
8

Example on how to achieve this provided below:

DataSet dataSet = new DataSet(); //Create a dataset
dataSet = _DataEntryDataLayer.ReadResults(); //Call to the dataLayer to return the data

//LINQ query on a DataTable
var dataList = dataSet.Tables["DataTable"]
              .AsEnumerable()
              .Select(i => new
              {
                 ID = i["ID"],
                 Name = i["Name"]
               }).ToList();

Comments

7

For VB.NET The code will look like this:

Dim results = From myRow In myDataTable  
Where myRow.Field(Of Int32)("RowNo") = 1 Select myRow

Comments

7
IEnumerable<string> result = from myRow in dataTableResult.AsEnumerable()
                             select myRow["server"].ToString() ;

Comments

6

Try this...

SqlCommand cmd = new SqlCommand( "Select * from Employee",con);
SqlDataReader dr = cmd.ExecuteReader( );
DataTable dt = new DataTable( "Employee" );
dt.Load( dr );
var Data = dt.AsEnumerable( );
var names = from emp in Data select emp.Field<String>( dt.Columns[1] );
foreach( var name in names )
{
    Console.WriteLine( name );
}

Comments

5

You can get it work elegant via linq like this:

from prod in TenMostExpensiveProducts().Tables[0].AsEnumerable()
where prod.Field<decimal>("UnitPrice") > 62.500M
select prod

Or like dynamic linq this (AsDynamic is called directly on DataSet):

TenMostExpensiveProducts().AsDynamic().Where (x => x.UnitPrice > 62.500M)

I prefer the last approach while is is the most flexible. P.S.: Don't forget to connect System.Data.DataSetExtensions.dll reference

Comments

5

you can try this, but you must be sure the type of values for each Column

List<MyClass> result = myDataTable.AsEnumerable().Select(x=> new MyClass(){
     Property1 = (string)x.Field<string>("ColumnName1"),
     Property2 = (int)x.Field<int>("ColumnName2"),
     Property3 = (bool)x.Field<bool>("ColumnName3"),    
});

1 Comment

Has the world gone mad? Whats wrong with sql? DataRow[] drs = dt.Select("id=1"); Maybe this is too easy.
0

I propose following solution:

DataView view = new DataView(myDataTable); 
view.RowFilter = "RowNo = 1";
DataTable results = view.ToTable(true);

Looking at the DataView Documentation, the first thing we can see is this:

Represents a databindable, customized view of a DataTable for sorting, filtering, searching, editing, and navigation.

What I am getting from this is that DataTable is meant to only store data and DataView is there enable us to "query" against the DataTable.

Here is how this works in this particular case:

You try to implement the SQL Statement

SELECT *
FROM myDataTable
WHERE RowNo = 1

in "DataTable language". In C# we would read it like this:

FROM myDataTable
WHERE RowNo = 1
SELECT *

which looks in C# like this:

DataView view = new DataView(myDataTable);  //FROM myDataTable
view.RowFilter = "RowNo = 1";  //WHERE RowNo = 1
DataTable results = view.ToTable(true);  //SELECT *

1 Comment

This isn't really true at all I'm afraid. DataView are useful but they aren't intended to implement the sophisticated sorts of data operations LINQ does

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.