Fashion Conscious Phenomenon
Abstract
An unsympathetic review essay of Anker and Felski"s "Critique and Postcritique"
FAQs
AI
What explains the emergence of postcritique in literary studies?
The paper reveals that postcritique surfaces mainly as a response to an oversaturated job market for PhDs, reflecting people's desire for less stringent critiques in a low-spirited academic environment.
How do proponents of postcritique misrepresent traditional criticism?
The paper notes that postcritique inaccurately portrays traditional criticism as purely negative, ignoring the historical and varied approaches that critics have employed, including rich appreciations of literary works.
When did critiques of the critique paradigm accelerate?
According to the paper, significant critiques against the historicist/contextualist paradigm gained momentum in the 1970s coinciding with emergent political movements advocating for inclusion and representation.
What paradox does the postcritique phenomenon present regarding aesthetics?
The study finds that postcritique simultaneously advocates for a return to aesthetics while also seeking alignment with scientific objectivity, highlighting a fundamental contradiction in their claims for universalism.
What role does age play in the discourse surrounding postcritique?
The paper identifies age as a critical blind spot in the postcritique movement, suggesting that middle-aged academics, reflecting on past inspirations, may anchor their critiques in nostalgia rather than relevancy.