Top Ten MaeMags Favourites

My top ten favourite MaeMags fics in alphabetical order. It was incredibly difficult to pick only ten and I had to exclude some incredible fics 😭 I tried to go for short fics which focus specifically on MaeMags. I hope you love them as much as I do!

The Best Laid Plans by disastrousexpense - (@polutrope) - E, 2.4k, MaeMags/OFC, the fic that convinced me that second person could be hot, great dynamics

Drunken Dancing by Sleepless_Malice (@feanope) - E, 6.3k, MaeMags taking Elrond's virginity (consensually), featuring the hottest bj I've ever seen in fic courtesy of MaeMags

Hush, tread on my path my love by eldvarpa (@eldvarpa) - E, 839, hot rough warlord sex. They are devoted but not kind and it feels very true to them to me

in all my dreams i drown by homelikecatastrophe (@welcomingdisaster) - E, 5k, beautifully written, dark, Maedhros marries Maglor after he is raped and becomes pregnant

midnight oil by Pastel_Sugar (@pastelsugar6w6) - T, 888, lovely and tender with a very erotic undertone

no other blood by jouissant (@jouissants) - E, 3.8k, Maedhros & Maglor marry in YTT due to Feanor's paranoia, gorgeous writing

ours would be a good life by aguntoaknifefight (swirlingvoid) (@thepastisaroadmap) - T, 2.3k, funny outsider pov of MaeMags in the kidnap fam era, feels very realistic

they thought us blind, we were just blinking by AdmirableMonster (Mertiya) (@admirablemonster) - E, 2.8k, Maglor helping Maedhros heal after Thangorodrim. Through sex. Hotter and more intimate than I'm making it sound!

Thine Ever, Makalaurë by am_fae (@meadowlarkx)- E, 3.8k, funny epistolary exchange followed by some very hot slightly d/s sex. This is exactly what Maglor would write like

a willing sheath by jouissant (@jouissants), E, 2.4k, the seminal size kink fic

A huge thank you to @elronds_library for your help & your resources making this much easier!

Previous rec list: Everyone Nails Finrod - A Rec List