12. Antonia Hodgson, The Raven Scholar – Hm! This was a fun ride (helped along by knowing that
cafemassolit had enjoyed it a lot), and an ambitious debut novel, just in terms of sheer scope and density of plot twists, but while I enjoyed reading it basically at all points and stayed up so I could finish the last 100+ pages in one go, I don’t think it’s a Hugo-caliber work (although a few things about it did reach that level for me). So, this was a good time, and I will probably pick up the sequel (even though where it seems to be headed is less interesting to me than where this book has been), but I don’t see putting it at, or maybe even near (depends on how many books I manage to read, LOL), the top of my ballot.
I’m not sure how to talk about it, either, because this book has a LOT of stuff going on. Maybe in my occasional good/mixed/not-good format? Yeah, let’s try that.
( With spoilers )The book is up for Best Novel, where I’m definitely ranking it below
The Incandescent (also flawed, but more unusual and more coherent, despite its flaws), and Hodgson is up for Astounding, where I think I’ll also be ranking her below H.H.Pak, who was working on much smaller scale but to greater effect, IMO. But I won’t be mad if Hodgson wins Astounding, because I do think there’s ambition and talent there, and I won’t even be mad if the book wins Best Novel, I don’t think.
**
Taskmaster Australia s5e08 – Anisa looks fabulous in her neon pink suit, and I’m also liking Celia’s pink and brown knit top.
( Spoilers )