Collects stories from Superman (DC, 1939 series) #123 and Action Comics (DC, 1938 series) #252-268. On-sale date from the ComicList Database © 2001 by Charles LePage with information from Sun Coast Comics, listed with December cover dated titles.
Title page. The illustration is a detail from the cover of Action Comics #266 (see page 185).
| Pencils: | Al Plastino (credited) |
| Inks: | Al Plastino (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | typeset |
Illustration is from pg. 7, panel 6 of the Supergirl story from Action Comics #252 (see page 46).
| Script: | Diana Schutz (credited) |
| Pencils: | Al Plastino (credited) |
| Inks: | Al Plastino (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | typeset |
The illustration is from pg. 8, panel 4 of the Supergirl story from Action Comics #252 (see page 47).
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Dick Sprang (credited) |
| Inks: | Stan Kaye (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |

Although the Super-Girl in this story is not Kara Zor-El, the story is included in this volume because it features the first character of that name to appear in a Superman comic. The title, "The Three Magic Wishes" is from this volume's Table of Contents. Chapters II and III of this story are also reprinted, although Super-Girl only appears in Chapter I.
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Dick Sprang (credited) |
| Inks: | Stan Kaye (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
Super-Girl does not appear in this chapter.
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Dick Sprang (credited) |
| Inks: | Stan Kaye (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
Super-Girl does not appear in this chapter.
| Script: | ? |
| Pencils: | Curt Swan (credited) |
| Inks: | Stan Kaye (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
| Editing: | Mort Weisinger (original) |
Some sources credit art to Curt Swan and Al Plastino. Full cover text is: 'Introducing: "The Supergirl from Krypton!" Is She Friend or Foe?'
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Al Plastino (credited) |
| Inks: | Al Plastino (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
| Editing: | Mort Weisinger (original) |
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |

| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |

| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
| Script: | Otto Binder (signed) |
| Pencils: | Al Plastino (credited) |
| Inks: | Al Plastino (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |

Supergirl guest-stars in this Superman story.
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
| Script: | Jerry Siegel (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |

Streaky's 1st appearance and origin.
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |

| Script: | Jerry Siegel (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |

| Script: | Jerry Siegel (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |

| Script: | Jerry Siegel (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |

| Script: | Jerry Siegel (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |

Supergirl's first encounter with the Legion of Super-Heroes. She applies for membership, but is rejected.
| Script: | Otto Binder (credited) |
| Pencils: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Inks: | Jim Mooney (credited) |
| Colors: | |
| Letters: | ? |
Linda Lee gets a temporary job as junior reporter for the Daily Planet.
from Superman (DC, 1939 series) #123 (August 1958) [cover]
from Action Comics (DC, 1938 series) #252 (May 1959) [cover], #262 (March 1960) [cover], #266 (July 1960) [cover]Thumbnails of the covers of Action Comics #252, 262 and 266; and Superman (1939 series) #123.