Linked Questions
33 questions linked to/from When is a resource request on-topic?
Score of -21
2 answers
387 views
Why is this question marked off-topic [duplicate]
Where can I find the source for "fetch" implementation used in Chromium?
It is not asking for recommendation as noted in the closing dialog.
It can be asking for help with the external ...
Score of 11
1 answer
355 views
Are questions asking for documentation off-topic? [duplicate]
I came across two questions asking for a link or another way to access the documentation of a library. I immediately thought it has to be off-topic, but the close-reason doesn't state documentation:
...
Score of 3
2 answers
404 views
Is "Where do I find the Java JDK Source code for JDK 1.8?" off-topic? [duplicate]
I posted this question some time ago: Where do I find the Java JDK Source code for JDK 1.8?
It was tagged to be closed for being off-topic. I protested because although not specifically about ...
Score of -15
2 answers
216 views
How do you process questions that are particularly salient with good answers that are closed? [duplicate]
I'm curious as to how folks handle questions with good answers that get closed.
Recently, I was looking for where to find the downloadable Javadoc for a specific instance of Java, the other day (many ...
Score of -18
1 answer
229 views
There is not a single rule anywhere that states asking for sources is forbidden [duplicate]
I have a question about my Stack Overflow post: Gameboy advance assembly
I have read the how to ask page, the code of conduct and even the faq, but couldn't find any single rule that states asking ...
Score of -2
1 answer
156 views
How to avoid being off-topic for off-site recommendations if the problem necessarily involves a library? [duplicate]
Suppose I have a problem to solve, which necessarily involves using a library (but not a specific one). How can one ask for help with such a problem w/o it being closed as being off-topic? If it can'...
Score of 1
0 answers
94 views
Should the "seeking recommendations" close reason be used when the question just asks for a reference? [duplicate]
People often ask questions of the form "Is there a tool/library that does X?". I usually vote to close these using the "seeking recommendations" reason. But the explanation for ...
Score of 76
10 answers
10209 views
Overhauling our community's closure reasons and guidance
Overview
As we know Stack Overflow has a closure process which users begin participating in at 15 reputation with flagging privileges and then later with full closure votes at 3000 reputation
Recently,...
Score of 77
11 answers
7427 views
Question Close Reasons - Definitions and Guidance
This community-wiki Q&A is a compiled set of guidance for the close reasons used on Stack Overflow.
It's meant to be a canonical repository and a resource for the community – both for authors of ...
Score of 219
2 answers
43209 views
What exactly is a recommendation question?
What exactly is a 'recommendation' question?
I understand and agree with avoiding questions on SO that garner answers which are basically opinions or preferences, such as "I like X" or "We use Y and ...
Score of 54
7 answers
2269 views
A question that is not seeking recommendations (but which has attracted many) is locked and closed. Higher-value answers now stuck below 4th place
How can I test what my readme.md file will look like before committing to GitHub? is locked and closed by a mod as "seeking recommendations". The question itself does not ask for ...
Score of 46
2 answers
1724 views
How much deviation from Stack Overflow's guidelines is too much?
There's a Discussion on the NLP Collective which asks about validity of questions which seek recommendations, are broad, or would generally lead to opinionated answers. I am quoting the Discussion ...
Score of 45
4 answers
785 views
Please can we update the "Seeking recommendations for books, tools, software libraries, and more" close reason
It's 2023, almost nobody asks for books anymore, but they sure do ask for tutorials. So can we please update this close reason to match?
The "and more" bit is vague and unhelpful, so while ...
Score of 46
2 answers
1523 views
Is asking the community to find (not recommend) an off-site resource allowed?
Up until about a year and a half ago, one of our standard close reasons was:
Questions asking us to recommend or find a book, tool, software library, tutorial or other off-site resource are off-topic ...
Score of 185
1 answer
7027 views
Watson wants to get rid of [ibm]
This tag has been burninated. Please do not recreate it. If you need advice on which tag to use, see the answer below. If you see this tag reappearing, it may need to be blacklisted.
Watson's AI ...