Commons:Monuments database/Missing IDs

This page contains an overview of Missing IDs encountered in lists of monuments. These are entries in the monument list templates where the monument identifier — the primary key used to uniquely identify the monument in the database — is missing or empty. Entries without an ID cannot be reliably harvested and are skipped by the bot. All the pages and the statistics are updated on a regular basis by a bot based on the data in the monuments database.

How does it work?

Every night a ErfgoedBot updates the Monuments database with all the lists we have on Wikipedia. When the bot processes a monument row template it checks whether the monument identifier (the primary key field) has been filled in. If the identifier is missing or empty, the monument cannot be stored in the database. The bot makes a note of this and reports the affected pages and the number of missing IDs per page.

Note that for some countries the monument identifier is composed of multiple template fields (e.g. a municipality code combined with a monument number). In these cases the entry is reported as having a missing ID if any of the fields that make up the identifier are empty.

How can you help?

Go to the missing IDs page (linked below). You'll see a table listing each source page and how many monument entries on that page are missing their identifier.

For each page, open it and look for monument entries where the ID field is empty. There are a few common scenarios:

• Accidentally left blank: The ID field was simply not filled in when the entry was added. Look up the correct identifier and add it.
• Newly added monument: A volunteer added a monument to the list but did not yet know its official identifier. Try to find the correct ID from the relevant heritage register or authority.
• Malformatted template: The template parameters may have been shuffled or broken, causing the ID field to end up empty even though the value is present elsewhere in the entry. Fix the template formatting so the ID is in the right parameter.

After you fix a missing ID, the next time ErfgoedBot harvests that list (probably tonight) the entry will be removed from the report and the monument will be correctly stored in the database.

How can I localise the instructions?

Since the missing ID reports are overwritten by ErfgoedBot each time the list is updated you cannot add instructions (or categories) directly to the page. To solve this the /header sub-page is automatically included at the top of the page, if it exists. Thus to add instructions for volunteers in your own language simply create the /header sub-page with the required information.

To localise the message used when there are no more missing IDs, simply create a /done sub-page with the desired message.

Overview

country	lang	Total pages with missing IDs	Total occurrences	Report page	Row template
ad	ca	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ad (ca)	Filera BIC And
ae	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ae (en)	UAEmonument row
al	sq	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments al (sq)	Rreshti Monumentet në Shqipëri
am	hy	3	3	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments am (hy)	Հուշարձան ցանկ
aq	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments aq (en)	Antarctic Protected Area row
ar	es	6	11	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ar (es)	MonumentoArgentina
at	de	443	1039	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments at (de)	Denkmalliste Österreich Tabellenzeile
az	az	8	51	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments az (az)	AZE Monument row
be-bru	nl	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments be-bru (nl)	Tabelrij erfgoed Brussels Hoofdstedelijk Gewest
be-vlg	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments be-vlg (en)	Table row BE
be-vlg	fr	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments be-vlg (fr)	Ligne de tableau MH-Fla
be-vlg	nl	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments be-vlg (nl)	Tabelrij erfgoed Vlaanderen
be-wal	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments be-wal (en)	Table row Wallonia
be-wal	fr	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments be-wal (fr)	Ligne de tableau MH-Wal
be-wal	nl	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments be-wal (nl)	Tabelrij erfgoed Wallonië
bo	es	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments bo (es)	MonumentoBolivia
by	be-tarask	33	70	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments by (be-tarask)	Вікі любіць славутасьці/Элемэнт сьпісу
ca	fr	4	73	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ca (fr)	Ligne de tableau LPC
ca-fed	en	125	9982	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ca-fed (en)	HPC row
ca-muni	en	132	4832	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ca-muni (en)	HPC row
ca-prov	en	130	9539	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ca-prov (en)	HPC row
ch	de	1	4	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ch (de)	Denkmalliste Schweiz Tabellenzeile
ch	fr	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ch (fr)	Ligne de tableau Monuments (Suisse)
ch	it	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ch (it)	Riga della tabella dei beni culturali (Svizzera)
ch-old	en	27	1354	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ch-old (en)	SIoCPoNaRS row
ch2	de	35	729	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ch2 (de)	Denkmalliste2 Schweiz Tabellenzeile
ch3	de	28	364	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ch3 (de)	Denkmalliste2 Schweiz-ZH Tabellenzeile
cl	es	4	6	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments cl (es)	MonumentoChile
cm	fr	1	1	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments cm (fr)	Monument Cameroun ligne
cn	en	2	2	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments cn (en)	NHS China row
co	es	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments co (es)	MonumentoColombia
cz	cs	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments cz (cs)	Památky v Česku
de-by	de	95	320	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments de-by (de)	Denkmalliste Bayern Tabellenzeile
de-he	de	356	15870	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments de-he (de)	Denkmalliste Hessen Tabellenzeile
de-hh	de	1	1	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments de-hh (de)	Denkmalliste Hamburg Tabellenzeile
de-nrw-bm	de	1	1	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments de-nrw-bm (de)	Denkmalliste Bergheim Tabellenzeile
de-nrw-k	de	5	5	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments de-nrw-k (de)	Denkmalliste Köln Tabellenzeile
dk-bygning	da	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments dk-bygninger (da)	Tabelrække FBB
dk-fortids	da	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments dk-fortidsminder (da)	Tabelrække FF
dz	ar	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments dz (ar)	صف معلم الجزائر
ee	et	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ee (et)	KRR rida
eg	ar	1	8	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments eg (ar)	صف معلم مصر
es	ca	3	99	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments es (ca)	Filera BIC
es	es	56	1473	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments es (es)	Fila BIC
es-ct	ca	9	10	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments es-ct (ca)	Filera IPA
es-gl	gl	4	24	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments es-gl (gl)	BIC
es-vc	ca	2	19	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments es-vc (ca)	Filera BIC Val
fr	ca	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments fr (ca)	Filera MH
fr	fr	87	1241	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments fr (fr)	Ligne de tableau MH
fr-object	fr	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments fr-object (fr)	Ligne de tableau objet MH
gb-eng	en	7	8	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments gb-eng (en)	EH listed building row
gb-nir	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments gb-nir (en)	NIEA listed building row
gb-sct	en	2	2	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments gb-sct (en)	HS listed building row
gb-wls	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments gb-wls (en)	Cadw listed building row
ge	ka	1	2	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ge (ka)	GEO Monument row
gh	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments gh (en)	Ghana Monument row
hk	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments hk (en)	HK Declared Monument row
hr	hr	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments hr (hr)	Spomenik red
hu	hu	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments hu (hu)	Műemlék
ie	en	5	10	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ie (en)	NMI list item
il	he	1	2	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments il (he)	אתר מורשת בישראל בשורה
il-npa	he	1	329	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments il-npa (he)	יצירת אמנות במרחב הציבורי בישראל בשורה
in	en	2	32	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments in (en)	ASI Monument row
in-com	commons	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments in-com (en)	India heritage list row
iq	ar	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments iq (ar)	صف معلم العراق
ir	fa	2	14	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ir (fa)	ردیف یادمان ایران
it	it	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments it (it)	WLM2015-riga
it-88	ca	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments it-88 (ca)	Filera BC Sard
it-bz	de	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments it-bz (de)	Denkmalliste Südtirol Tabellenzeile
jo	ar	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments jo (ar)	معلم الأردن
jp-nhs	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments jp-nhs (en)	NHS Japan row
ke	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ke (en)	Kenya Monument row
lu	lb	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments lu (lb)	Nationale Monumenter row
mt	de	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments mt (de)	Denkmalliste Malta Tabellenzeile
mx	es	6	15	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments mx (es)	MonumentoMéxico
my	commons	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments my (en)	Wiki Loves Monuments in Malaysia/Monuments/row
ng	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ng (en)	Nigeria listed historic sites item
nl	nl	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments nl (nl)	Tabelrij rijksmonument
nl-aw	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments nl-aw (en)	Table row Aruba monuments
nl-aw	nl	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments nl-aw (nl)	Tabelrij monument Aruba
nl-gem	nl	43	575	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments nl-gem (nl)	Tabelrij gemeentelijk monument
nl-prov	nl	2	4	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments nl-prov (nl)	Tabelrij provinciaal monument
no	no	4	7	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments no (no)	Kulturminner row
np	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments np (en)	Nepal Monument row
pa	es	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments pa (es)	Fila PCN
pe	es	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments pe (es)	MonumentoPerú
ph	en	30	975	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ph (en)	Philippine cultural property row
pk	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments pk (en)	PKmonument row
pl	pl	27	81	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments pl (pl)	Zabytki/wpis
pt	pt	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments pt (pt)	IGESPAR/linha
ro	ro	3	29	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ro (ro)	ElementLMI
rs	sr	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments rs (sr)	Споменици ред
ru	ru	2	50	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ru (ru)	Monument
se-arbetsl	sv	5	5	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments se-arbetsl (sv)	Arbetslivsmuseum
se-bbr	sv	3	26	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments se-bbr (sv)	BBR
se-fornmin	sv	2	8	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments se-fornmin (sv)	FMIS
se-ship	sv	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments se-ship (sv)	K-fartyg
sk	de	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments sk (de)	Denkmalliste Slowakei Tabellenzeile
sk	sk	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments sk (sk)	Monuments tableline-SK
sv	es	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments sv (es)	MonumentoElSalvador
th	th	27	137	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments th (th)	แถวโบราณสถาน
tn	fr	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments tn (fr)	Ligne de tableau monument Tunisie
ua	uk	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ua (uk)	ВЛП-рядок
ug	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ug (en)	National Cultural Site of Uganda row
us	en	2	12	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments us (en)	NRHP row
us-ca	en	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments us-ca (en)	CHL row
uy	es	1	1	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments uy (es)	MonumentoUruguay
ve	es	3	574	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments ve (es)	MonumentoVenezuela
wlpa-at	de	6	42	Monuments database/Missing IDs/wlpa at (de)	WLPA-AT-Zeile
wlpa-es-ct	ca	5	254	Monuments database/Missing IDs/wlpa es-ct (ca)	Filera art públic
wlpa-fi	fi	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/wlpa fi (fi)	Wlpa-teokset-rivi
wlpa-il	en	1	1	Monuments database/Missing IDs/wlpa il (en)	Public art in Israel - row
xk	sq	0	0	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments xk (sq)	Rreshti Monumentet në Kosovë
za	en	4	6	Monuments database/Missing IDs/monuments za (en)	SAHRA heritage site row
		1799	50332