Question
How can I efficiently duplicate a Java 8 stream without collecting it into a list?
List<Pair<A, Throwable>> results = doSomething().collect(toList());
Stream<Pair<A, Throwable>> failures = results.stream().flatMap(either -> either.left());
failures.forEach(failure -> ... );
Stream<A> successes = results.stream().flatMap(either -> either.right());
successes.forEach(success -> ... );
Answer
In Java 8, streams are designed to be used only once, which is why you encounter the 'stream has already been operated upon or closed' error when you attempt to reuse a stream. However, there are strategies to efficiently process stream data multiple times without converting the entire stream to a collection.
Map<Boolean, List<Either<Pair<A, Throwable>, A>>> partitionedResults = doSomething()
.collect(Collectors.partitioningBy(either -> either.isLeft()));
List<Either<Pair<A, Throwable>, A>> failures = partitionedResults.get(true);
List<A> successes = partitionedResults.get(false);
failures.forEach(failure -> ...);
successes.forEach(success -> ...);
Causes
- Stream operations are not reusable. Once a terminal operation has been applied to a stream, it cannot be reused.
- Attempting to operate on the same stream for different purposes leads to runtime exceptions.
Solutions
- Instead of trying to duplicate a stream, consider using the 'peek' method to process elements as they pass through the stream pipeline.
- Utilize the 'Collectors.partitioningBy' method to split the results into two groups (successes and failures) in one pass, avoiding separate operations on the same stream.
Common Mistakes
Mistake: Trying to call a terminal operation multiple times on the same stream instance.
Solution: Always create a new stream instance for each terminal operation.
Mistake: Assuming streams can be reused like collections.
Solution: Understand the lifecycle of a stream. Either collect results or process them in a single stream pipeline.
Helpers
- Java 8 streams
- duplicate Java stream
- Java stream processing
- stream operations
- Stream API
- Eithers in Java