This list collates and sorts every film selected by visitors to the Criterion Closet in order of most frequently picked. It is fed by the 442 individual closet pick lists transcribed by this account and is complete up to February 20, 2026.

"I'd love a chart of who has taken what. A graphic of that would be great." - Tavi Gevinson

The notes for each film in this list reflect which person(s) picked it during their respective visit. Boxsets are added in their entirety, regardless of which film was talked about.

Check out the companion list that shows all Criterion releases never picked during a visit to the Criterion Closet.

This list is maintained by Jacob. If you’d like to show your appreciation, consider buying him some popcorn 🍿!

If you like this project, check out Closing The Loops (+ Criterion Edition), which similarly collates and sorts all films present across Letterboxd's 16 featured lists shown on member stats pages.