Yikes! All these workarounds have led me to the conclusion that the HTML checkbox kind of sucks if you want to style it.
As a forewarning, this isn't a CSS implementation. I just thought I'd share the workaround I came up with in case anyone else might find it useful.
I used the HTML5 canvas element.
The upside to this is that you don't have to use external images and can probably save some bandwidth.
The downside is that if a browser for some reason can't render it correctly, then there's no fallback. Though whether this remains an issue in 2017 is debatable.
Update
I found the old code quite ugly, so I decided to give it a rewrite.
Object.prototype.create = function(args){
var retobj = Object.create(this);
retobj.constructor(args || null);
return retobj;
}
var Checkbox = Object.seal({
width: 0,
height: 0,
state: 0,
document: null,
parent: null,
canvas: null,
ctx: null,
/*
* args:
* name default desc.
*
* width 15 width
* height 15 height
* document window.document explicit document reference
* target this.document.body target element to insert checkbox into
*/
constructor: function(args){
if(args === null)
args = {};
this.width = args.width || 15;
this.height = args.height || 15;
this.document = args.document || window.document;
this.parent = args.target || this.document.body;
this.canvas = this.document.createElement("canvas");
this.ctx = this.canvas.getContext('2d');
this.canvas.width = this.width;
this.canvas.height = this.height;
this.canvas.addEventListener("click", this.ev_click(this), false);
this.parent.appendChild(this.canvas);
this.draw();
},
ev_click: function(self){
return function(unused){
self.state = !self.state;
self.draw();
}
},
draw_rect: function(color, offset){
this.ctx.fillStyle = color;
this.ctx.fillRect(offset, offset,
this.width - offset * 2, this.height - offset * 2);
},
draw: function(){
this.draw_rect("#CCCCCC", 0);
this.draw_rect("#FFFFFF", 1);
if(this.is_checked())
this.draw_rect("#000000", 2);
},
is_checked: function(){
return !!this.state;
}
});
Here's a working demo.
The new version uses prototypes and differential inheritance to create an efficient system for creating checkboxes. To create a checkbox:
var my_checkbox = Checkbox.create();
This will immediately add the checkbox to the DOM and hook up the events. To query whether a checkbox is checked:
my_checkbox.is_checked(); // True if checked, else false
Also important to note is that I got rid of the loop.
Update 2
Something I neglected to mention in the last update is that using the canvas has more advantages than just making a checkbox that looks however you want it to look. You could also create multi-state checkboxes, if you wanted to.
Object.prototype.create = function(args){
var retobj = Object.create(this);
retobj.constructor(args || null);
return retobj;
}
Object.prototype.extend = function(newobj){
var oldobj = Object.create(this);
for(prop in newobj)
oldobj[prop] = newobj[prop];
return Object.seal(oldobj);
}
var Checkbox = Object.seal({
width: 0,
height: 0,
state: 0,
document: null,
parent: null,
canvas: null,
ctx: null,
/*
* args:
* name default desc.
*
* width 15 width
* height 15 height
* document window.document explicit document reference
* target this.document.body target element to insert checkbox into
*/
constructor: function(args){
if(args === null)
args = {};
this.width = args.width || 15;
this.height = args.height || 15;
this.document = args.document || window.document;
this.parent = args.target || this.document.body;
this.canvas = this.document.createElement("canvas");
this.ctx = this.canvas.getContext('2d');
this.canvas.width = this.width;
this.canvas.height = this.height;
this.canvas.addEventListener("click", this.ev_click(this), false);
this.parent.appendChild(this.canvas);
this.draw();
},
ev_click: function(self){
return function(unused){
self.state = !self.state;
self.draw();
}
},
draw_rect: function(color, offsetx, offsety){
this.ctx.fillStyle = color;
this.ctx.fillRect(offsetx, offsety,
this.width - offsetx * 2, this.height - offsety * 2);
},
draw: function(){
this.draw_rect("#CCCCCC", 0, 0);
this.draw_rect("#FFFFFF", 1, 1);
this.draw_state();
},
draw_state: function(){
if(this.is_checked())
this.draw_rect("#000000", 2, 2);
},
is_checked: function(){
return this.state == 1;
}
});
var Checkbox3 = Checkbox.extend({
ev_click: function(self){
return function(unused){
self.state = (self.state + 1) % 3;
self.draw();
}
},
draw_state: function(){
if(this.is_checked())
this.draw_rect("#000000", 2, 2);
if(this.is_partial())
this.draw_rect("#000000", 2, (this.height - 2) / 2);
},
is_partial: function(){
return this.state == 2;
}
});
I modified slightly the Checkbox used in the last snippet so that it is more generic, making it possible to "extend" it with a checkbox that has 3 states. Here's a demo. As you can see, it already has more functionality than the built-in checkbox.
Something to consider when you're choosing between JavaScript and CSS.
Old, poorly-designed code
Working Demo
First, set up a canvas
var canvas = document.createElement('canvas'),
ctx = canvas.getContext('2d'),
checked = 0; // The state of the checkbox
canvas.width = canvas.height = 15; // Set the width and height of the canvas
document.body.appendChild(canvas);
document.body.appendChild(document.createTextNode(' Togglable Option'));
Next, devise a way to have the canvas update itself.
(function loop(){
// Draws a border
ctx.fillStyle = '#ccc';
ctx.fillRect(0,0,15,15);
ctx.fillStyle = '#fff';
ctx.fillRect(1, 1, 13, 13);
// Fills in canvas if checked
if(checked){
ctx.fillStyle = '#000';
ctx.fillRect(2, 2, 11, 11);
}
setTimeout(loop, 1000/10); // Refresh 10 times per second
})();
The last part is to make it interactive. Luckily, it's pretty simple:
canvas.onclick = function(){
checked = !checked;
}
This is where you might have problems in IE, due to their weird event handling model in JavaScript.
I hope this helps someone; it definitely suited my needs.
ctrl+f"accessibility")accent-colorCSS that (in most implementations) affects only the color when checked, it's also possible to further customise the background color when unchecked by using CSSfilters, see here (very useful for dark mode styles where the white of empty checkboxes don't fit in).